Kitabı oku: «Faust’s Metropolis: A History of Berlin»
FAUST’S METROPOLIS
A HISTORY OF BERLIN
ALEXANDRA RICHIE

COPYRIGHT
William Collins
An imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers Ltd. 1 London Bridge Street London SE1 9GF
www.harpercollins.co.uk
First published in Great Britain by HarperCollinsPublishers in 1998
Ebook edition published in Great Britain by William Collins in 2013
Copyright © Alexandra Richie 1998
Alexandra Richie asserts the moral right to be identified as the author of this work
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. By payment of the required fees, you have been granted the nonexclusive, nontransferable right to access and read the text of this ebook on-screen. No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, decompiled, reverse engineered, or stored in or introduced into any information storage and retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the express written permission of HarperCollins ebooks
HarperCollinsPublishers has made every reasonable effort to ensure that any picture content and written content in this ebook has been included or removed in accordance with the contractual and technological constraints in operation at the time of publication
Source ISBN: 9780002158961
Ebook Edition © SEPTEMBER 2013 ISBN: 9780007455492
Version: 2017-04-25
DEDICATION
For Władysław Bartoszewski
CONTENTS
COVER
TITLE PAGE
COPYRIGHT
DEDICATION
PREFACE
LIST OF MAPS
INTRODUCTION
I: History, Myth, and the Birth of Berlin
II: The Capital of Absolutism
III: The Emerging Giant
IV: From Revolution to Realpolitik
V: The Rise of Red Berlin
VI: Imperial Berlin
VII: The Road to the First World War
VIII: The Bitter Aftermath of War
IX: The Golden Twenties
X: The Betrayal of Weimar
XI: Nazi Berlin – Life Before the Storm
XII: The Second World War
XIII: The Fall of Berlin
XIV: The Berlin Crisis and the Cold War
XV: Flashpoint Berlin
XVI: East Berlin
XVII: The Walled City – West Berlin
XVIII: The New Capital
KEEP READING …
NOTES
INDEX
ABOUT THE PUBLISHER
PREFACE
From the moment I first set foot in the city as a young student I became fascinated by Berlin. Like Faust, Berlin can be said to have two spirits in the same breast; it is both a terrible and a wonderful city, a place which has created and destroyed and whose name is both acclaimed and blackened. It is not without reason that Berlin has been called everything from the ‘symbol of German destiny’ to the ‘city of the twenty-first century’. Above all, it is a place where history could not and still cannot be hidden away.
When I first went to live there Berlin was the ultimate border city, representing nothing less than the Cold War division between the ‘Communist’ and the ‘Free’ world. It was a capital city and a strange backwater, a centre and a borderland at the same time. The revolution which erupted in 1989 and led to the destruction of the Berlin Wall made it once again the focus of world attention. As I watched the Wall being reduced to rubble I realised that the dramatic changes would raise very disturbing questions about Berlin’s role in Germany and its function as a symbol in the creation of German identity. Now more than ever it is imperative for us to be aware of the triumphs and the mistakes of its past, as the decisions made in Berlin in years to come will affect us all.
I have tried to write a book that addresses the city’s crucial role in world events. It is not a local history, although it has elements of this, but is a history of Germany – even of Europe, including the often-neglected east – as seen through the ‘prism’ of Berlin. The book is meant for the general reader. Much of the material is known and its claim to originality lies more in the selection and presentation of information than in new discoveries. I have tried to avoid specialist language and the narrow categories of contemporary historiography, choosing instead to weave various aspects of cultural, social and economic history together with more conventional military or diplomatic approaches into a comprehensive whole. With the exception of the introduction, which brings the story up to date, the book follows a broad chronological framework. Although I cover all periods of Berlin’s past, the emphasis is clearly on the city in the twentieth century, its role in the First World War, in the Holocaust, in the creation of modernist culture, in the identity of post-Cold War Europe – in numerous crucial events of the recent past.
Many people have helped me in the writing of this book. It evolved from the D.Phil which I wrote at St Antony’s College, Oxford, and I would like to thank the Warden of St. Antony’s, Lord Dahrendorf, and the Fellows of the College, particularly those at the European Studies Centre who have done so much to support my research. I would like to thank the President of Wolfson College, Sir David Smith, and the Fellows of the College for granting me a fellowship and providing the wonderful haven in which I was able to work. Timothy Garton Ash has been a great source of inspiration and I am most grateful to him for recommending me to HarperCollins. I would also like to thank Michael Burleigh for first suggesting Berlin as a topic, and Warren Magnusson and Raymond Klibansky for their help. I am most grateful to the late Sir Isaiah Berlin for persuading me to write history, it is not too much to say that his words changed the course of my life.
HarperCollins has been everything an author could hope for. Michael Fishwick has been an exemplary editor and has patiently guided this project from the beginning; Rebecca Lloyd was not only highly professional but also great fun to work with; both have become friends. I am grateful, too, to Helen Ellis, Stuart Proffitt, Kate Parrish, Annie Robertson, Phyllis Richardson, Sophie Nelson for copy-editing, Phil Lewis for the picture lay-out, Jon Gilkes for cartography and the many others who have contributed to the book.
Literally hundreds of Berliners let me into their lives and helped me to understand their city. Some selflessly showed me their neighbourhoods and took me into their homes; some assisted me in the search for sources, guided me through the archives and answered seemingly endless questions with characteristic good humour. I am particularly indebted to those East Berliners who befriended me before 1989, when such contact put them at considerable risk, and to the ‘rubble ladies’ who spoke of their post-1945 experiences with candour and courage. I would also like to thank the Boston Consulting Group, and in particular Barry Jones, John Lindquist and Charbel Ackermann, for giving me the opportunity to glimpse at first hand the economic transformation of East Germany after 1989.
I was enormously touched that Gordon Craig, that most respected of German historians and a man whose work I have long admired, took the time to read the manuscript and send comments and corrections, and I thank him for his very kind words. Thanks also to Peter Gay for reading so much and for his very helpful comments, to Harold James for reading the book and sending his very reassuring and insightful remarks, to Norman Naimark for reading the post-war chapters, to Thomas DaCosta Kaufmann for his detailed corrections of the early chapters and to Robert Conquest for, amongst other things, shedding light on the realities of 1930s Berlin. I would also like to thank James Sheehan, Fritz Stern, Max Hastings, Sir Michael Howard and Charles Maier for their comments, advice, and kind words of encouragement.
The writing of this book would have been much less enjoyable without the contributions of my dear friends Victoria Joffe, Levin von Trott zu Solz, Erik Svendson, Marlene Apmann, Stephen Pettyfer, James Allison, Margaret Craig and Serguisz Michalski. I am grateful to the many members of my extraordinary extended family around the globe who have done so much, and I owe a special debt to my father-in-law, Wladyslaw Bartoszewski, and to Andrew Ciechanowiecki, not least for their insights into German-Polish history. Above all, I would like to thank my father, Karl-Wilhelm, who, through his love and knowledge of German culture first awakened my passion for our shared heritage; my mother, Heather, whose unconditional love made this possible, and my brother, Fraser, with whom I shared my first Berlin adventures and so much besides. Finally, I have dedicated this book to my beloved husband, Wladyslaw Bartoszewski, whose tolerance, kindness and compassion know no limits and without whom the book would simply never have come to fruition. My gratitude is beyond words.
LIST OF MAPS
Borderlands between Germany and Poland, 10th–11th Century
12th-Century Berlin and the Townships now included in the Modern City
14th-Century Berlin
Growth of Prussia 1640–1866
Prussia-Germany 1815–1871
Purported ‘Encirclement’ of Germany
Territorial Changes with Treaties of Brest-Litovsk and Versailles
The Government Quarter
Hitler’s Planned Autobahn Extension Straddling the Polish Corridor
Nazi Prison/Camp Network
Montgomery/Eisenhower Strategy for the Invasion of Germany
Chancellery Bunker
Sketched Plan for the Soviet Attack on the City Centre
Post-1945 Division of Berlin and Germany
Berlin Airlift
INTRODUCTION
FAUST: Yes, one great thing did tempt me, one. You guess at it!
MEPHISTOPHELES: That’s quickly done. I’d choose a typical metropolis,
At centre, bourgeois stomach’s gruesome bliss,
Tight crooked alleys, pointed gables, mullions,
Crabbed market stalls of roots and scallions …
Then boulevards and spacious squares
To flaunt aristocratic airs;
And lastly, with no gate to stop them,
The suburbs sprawl ad infinitum.
(Goethe, Faust, Part Two, Act IV)
AT THE END OF GOETHE’S FAUST Mephistopheles takes his charge to the top of a great mountain and tempts him one last time. ‘You have surveyed the kingdoms of this world and all their glory,’ he says to Faust and asks him if his ‘insatiable appetite’ would not be fulfilled by a life in the heart of the metropolis. He offers him a teeming city where he could explore streets bustling with ‘activity and stench’, through crowds of men and women who run back and forth like ants whose nest has been kicked in. It is not a flattering picture; nor is it surprising that Goethe equates ‘the metropolis’ with the Devil’s world. The city in Faust is a mythical place, but it could well have been based on Berlin – which Goethe loathed. He visited only once, in May 1778, and apart from those he saw on his Italian journeys it was the only big city – certainly the only German ‘metropolis’ – that he ever experienced. When he arrived Frederick the Great was preparing for one of his campaigns and Goethe was overwhelmed by the ‘thousands upon thousands of people’ who filled the streets in ‘preparation of their sacrifice’. He found the grandiose buildings overbearing, and the crowds and the noise and the brashness of the place oppressive: ‘one doesn’t get very far with politeness in Berlin’, he snorted, ‘because such an audacious race of men lives there that one has to have a sharp tongue in order to keep oneself afloat.’ He summed up Berlin in a single word: ‘crude’.1
Goethe was certainly not the only one to comment on Berlin’s raw edges. Like the metropolis in Faust it has always been a rather shabby place – it is neither an ancient gem like Rome, nor an exquisite beauty like Prague, nor a geographical marvel like Rio. It was formed not by the gentle, cultured hand which made Dresden or Venice but was wrenched from the unpromising landscape by sheer hard work and determination. The city was built by its coarse inhabitants and its immigrants, and it became powerful not because of some Romantic destiny but because of its armies and its work ethic, its railroads and its belching smokestacks, its commerce and industry and its often harsh Realpolitik. The longing to make something out of the flat, windswept landscape is still reflected in the remnants of Berlin’s grimy brick slums, in its ground-breaking industrial architecture, in its heavy imperial buildings, even in its rusting memorials to the gods of war – now embarrassing reminders of a belligerent past. Berlin is no beauty, to be sure, but for those captivated by her she does have a strange, rough magic; an endearing resilient spirit that is hard to define. In Streets in Berlin and Elsewhere Siegfried Kracauer, another admirer, wrote: ‘Before my window the city condenses into an image that is as wondrous as the spectacle of nature. This landscape is artless Berlin. Unintentionally she speaks out her contradictions – her toughness, her openness, her co-existence, her splendour.’ Kracauer is right – Berlin is special not as a result of any carefully placed statues or magnificent buildings, but because of an unintended ugly beauty which surrounds the old ochre Hinterhöfe or tenements in Moabit or the unpretentious local Kneipen with their menus of pea soup and Bockwurst and beer, or the extravagant nineteenth-century villas in Zehlendorf or the little fountain in Friedrichshain with its carved frogs and turtles. It is a sprawling city with an ever-changing landscape from the wealthy Tiergarten to the desolate anonymity of Hellersdorf; from the imposing Mitte to the old citadel at Spandau, one of the best-preserved Italian Renaissance fortresses in Europe.2
It is impossible to escape the ghosts of history which hover above the Reichstag and over Göring’s intact Air Ministry and around the Brandenburg Gate. They waft around the remnants of the great brick and iron railway stations and the pieces of the Wall being ground to gravel on disused wasteland on the outskirts of the city; they linger in the pungent, mustard-coloured hallways of the monstrous East German housing projects and in the remnants of the Hinterhof cellars where, during the last century, the poor workers died of typhus and cholera. History is in the Landwehr Canal into which Rosa Luxemburg’s body was dumped in 1919, in Schinkel’s beautifully proportioned buildings and in the rubble mountains of ‘Mont Klamott’ and the Teufelsberg, the latter built on the ruins of Speer’s Technical University. Ghosts watch the shores of Berlin’s lovely lakes: the peaceful Grunewaldsee, so beautifully painted in Walter Leistikow’s 1895 work of the same name; or the Wannsee with its little sailboats and pretty aspects, the site of Heinrich von Kleist’s suicide in 1811 after writing the poem On the Morning of my Death, and of the conference which formalized the Final Solution.3
But above all history is in the empty spaces – in the broad, windswept fields and vacant lots which still stretch across the centre of town, where one can still find pieces of wrought iron or porcelain from long-forgotten staircases or dinner services. History is there in the single houses which stand alone – all that is left of a row, or perhaps even an entire street – their awkwardness emphasized by the 1970s murals peeling from the huge, beige fire walls. History twines through the branches of the trees which follow abandoned streets and along rusty tram tracks which lead nowhere and lingers on the piece of ground where Spandau Prison once stood. In Berlin the wounds of a troubled past are still painfully open, the scars still fresh.
Many have tried to capture this strange, incomplete city, this unfinished metropolis. It has been filmed and written about in hundreds of works, the subject of a thousand paintings. Ernst Toller and Sergei Diaghilev and Arnold Schoenberg loved it; Goethe and Lessing and Heinrich Heine were infuriated by it; Theodor Fontane and Alfred Döblin saw through it. Paunchy, cocky Berliners were the main subjects of Heinrich Zille’s witty sketches; weary, grey-faced workers inhabit Baluschek’s moving portrayals of the slums; self-confident Wilhelmine ladies dazzle us from Menzel’s warm portraits of the Kaiser’s court; its hardness is captured in the faces of prostitutes leering from the works of Georg Grosz and Otto Dix, and its very history is encapsulated in Meidner’s apocalyptic visions which exploded across his canvases and foretold the end of innocence in the twentieth century. Berlin (disguised as London) is the star of Brecht and Weill’s Threepenny Opera and of Isherwood’s Goodbye to Berlin and the film Cabaret; it is captured in the Berlin Diaries of Marie Vassiltchikov and William Shirer and in films like Wim Wenders’s Der Himmel über Berlin or Walter Ruttmann’s Sinfonie der Grossstadt or Michail Tchiaureli’s 1949 The Fall of Berlin with its score by Dmitri Shostakovich. Now a new group of hopefuls have taken up where Döblin left off and Berlin has become the main character of novels from Botho Strauss’s Die Feheier des Kopisten and Matthias Zschokke’s Der dicke Dichter to Bodo Morshäuser’s Gezielte Blicke and Jakob Arjouni’s Magic Hoffmann.
All these works offer tantalizing glimpses of Berlin but none can truly capture the essence of a place whose identity is based not on stability but on change. Berlin can appear solid and secure at one moment, but its history has shown the dangers of taking the image for granted. It is a volatile place, and many have found to their cost that the veneer of normality can vanish as quickly as yellow Mark Brandenburg sand slips through the fingers. Berliners themselves have rarely appreciated their own unique qualities and have spent much of their history striving to emulate – or dominate – Paris or London or Moscow, or boasting that they have more bridges than Venice, or that they are the Athens or the Chicago on the Spree. Berlin is a city which has never been at ease with itself.
It is in its portrayal of constant striving without counting the cost that the legend of Faust can serve as a metaphor for the history of Berlin. With Mephistopheles at his side Faust embarks on a terrible journey of discovery, meeting vile witches and the griffins and sphinxes of antiquity, being thrilled by the science and art and politics of the world, and murdering and burning those who stand in his way. Berlin, too, has undertaken an extraordinary journey, and its persistent quest for change has left it either – as now – cautiously searching for a role, or indulging in overweening arrogance and aggression. Its chameleon tendency to follow each new great ideology or leader, or to lurch maniacally from one grand political vision to another, has left a mesmerizing but often tragic legacy.
‘So it is, when long-held hopes aspire’, Goethe’s Faust cries, ‘fulfilment’s door stands open wide when suddenly, from eternal depths inside, an overpowering flame roars to confound us.’ Berlin is no stranger to this fire. No other city on earth has had such a turbulent history; no other capital has repeatedly become so powerful and then fallen so low. Its early years were marked by waves of immigration and population shifts – Burgundians, Wends, missionary Christians all left their mark on the little trading town in the Mark Brandenburg. Its rise began in earnest with the coming of the Hohenzollern dynasty which, after the gruesome deprivations of the Thirty Years War, led Prussia’s relentless drive for great power status through the creation of a stable economy and, more to the point, a formidable army – the ‘army with a state’. But the path was not a smooth one and Berlin seesawed between triumphalism and defeat, one moment revelling in the spoils of Frederick the Great’s victory in the Seven Years War, the next licking its wounds as the humiliated vassal occupied by Napoleon. Berlin’s drive for prestige was fulfilled when it became the capital of Bismarck’s united Germany in 1871, when the parvenu, ‘upstart’ city took on the world and became a dynamic industrial powerhouse. But this too was shattered in the slaughter of the First World War, a bloodbath largely provoked by Berlin’s leaders which led to the deaths in the trenches of 350,000 of its young men. The city emerged from war a mere shadow of its former self, racked by civil strife and targeted both by Lenin as the key to the world revolution, and by Hitler as the key to the German one. The extraordinary burst of creativity for which the Weimar Republic is remembered was not enough to prevent both left and right from turning its streets into a bloody battleground. Hitler’s victory led to another convulsion, and all that Weimar had stood for was swept aside. Many of Berlin’s greatest artists, writers, directors, architects and actors – men and women who touched every aspect of twentieth-century culture – fled or were murdered after 1933. Nevertheless, most Berliners dedicated themselves energetically to the Nazi cause with only a few brave individuals risking their lives to resist the downward spiral into criminality and mass murder. The shadow cast by Hitler’s ‘Germania’ was dark indeed – it was Berlin, after all, which prompted Elias Canetti to write in 1943 that he could no longer look at a map as ‘the names of cities reek of burnt flesh’.4 Throughout its history Berlin has seemed to contain, in Nietzsche’s words, something that ‘is hostile to life and destructive … a hidden will to death’.5 As early as 1907 the Berlin critic Maximilian Harden wrote in Die Krisis that Berlin held the seeds of its own destruction; it was already famous for its tendency ‘to suffer more than other cities in an endless parade of grisly disappointments’.6
The city has a violent past, but the ‘misery thesis’ of the post-war period which taught that Luther begot Frederick begot Bismarck begot Hitler, or that the Prussian capital was the ultimate source of all that was evil in German history, was simplistic at best and overshadowed its great cultural, political and economic contributions to Europe’s heritage. The poetry and music written to celebrate the end of the Thirty Years War, the tolerance enshrined in the Edict of Potsdam which granted asylum to the persecuted Huguenots of France, the Enlightenment of Nicolai and Mendelssohn and the salons of Rahel Levin and Henriette Hertz also have their place in Berlin’s history. The city was a focus for the arts: Carl Maria von Weber’s Der Freischütz was premièred in Berlin, as was Alban Berg’s Wozzeck; indeed the first ever performance of fragments of Part I of Goethe’s Faust took place there in 1819.7 Nineteenth-century Berlin might have been the most militaristic city in Europe, but its university and its myriad institutes and museums and societies also made it one of the greatest centres of intellectual life; if Berlin was the city of von Roon and von Moltke it also belonged to Hegel and Virchow, Schinkel and Fontane. And it was then that a tough new breed of businessmen – Rathenau, Borsig, Bleichröder, Ullstein and Siemens – began to invent and invest and industrialize, transforming nineteenth-century Berlin from a struggling manufacturing centre into the mightiest industrial city in Europe. Industry attracted immigrants, and ‘Red Berlin’ grew exponentially, from 170,000 in 1800 to 4 million in just over a century, becoming the focal point of the new working-class movement soon to sweep the world. Lenin, Marx, Luxemburg and Liebknecht, Bebel and Radek all spent time there, plotting the Communist revolution to be carried out by disgruntled workers rising up in the factories and slums. At the same time Berlin became an unlikely centre for those modernists who dared to defy the Kaiser’s bizarre pronouncements on art; the new Freie deutsche Bühne staged plays by Ibsen and Hauptmann while the Berlin Secession displayed the works of Max Liebermann and Käthe Kollwitz and Edvard Munch. And then, in the 1920s, Berlin became a magnet for the most innovative spirits of the age, home to architects and members of the Bauhaus such as Mies van der Rohe, Walter Gropius, Moholy-Nagy and Wassily Kandinsky, artists from Otto Dix and Georg Grosz to Christian Schad, directors like Fritz Lang and Josef von Sternberg and Billy Wilder, actors such as Josephine Baker, Marlene Dietrich and Greta Garbo; musicians including Wilhelm Furtwängler, Otto Klemperer and Arnold Schoenberg; and writers like Heinrich Mann, Gerhart Hauptmann and Stefan Zweig, Carl Zuckmayer and Alfred Döblin. For a brief shimmering moment these men and women made Berlin the undisputed capital of twentieth-century culture. The Nazis destroyed all that and the city has never recovered; nor did it recover from the demise of its once thriving Jewish community. Most of Berlin’s 170,000 Jews – a third of all Jews in Germany – were forced to flee, or were murdered.
Defeated by the Allies in 1945 and occupied by the rapacious Soviet army, Berlin turned its back on history and ‘began again’ at Stunde Null – Zero Hour. The Cold War brought division between the world’s two dominant and opposing ideologies, and the sector boundary became the place where the ‘Communist east’ and the ‘capitalist west’ confronted each other, bringing with them the constant threat of nuclear war. With the erection of the Wall in 1961 the city was divided, each half with its own identity and culture yet linked by a common past which everyone wanted to forget. In 1989 the grim, Stasi-ridden GDR collapsed, and Berlin was once again unified and was later named the capital of a united Germany. Now a new city is rising from the vast building sites at the Potsdamer Platz and the Alexanderplatz and the Spreebogen. Great promises are being made for this ‘symbol of the new German’, the ‘capital of Mitteleuropa’, the ‘heart of Europe’. But how accurate will such predictions be?
When Berlin was named the capital of a united Germany in 1871 the optimism was unbridled. Pages of newsprint were dedicated to ‘the phenomenon that is Berlin’: a 1900 guide entitled Berlin für Kenner (Berlin for Connoisseurs) called it ‘the most glorious city in the world’, ‘the capital of the German Reich and the Kingdom of Prussia, Residence of the German Emperor and the Kings of Prussia, Seat of the German Reichstag and Prussian Landtag’. Greater Berlin, it said, had ‘a population of 3,019,887’, a ‘garrison of 23,000 men’; it was the ‘cleanest city in the world’, it contained ‘as much railway track as lay between Frankfurt and Berlin’, it collected ‘over 89 million marks in taxes’ and had ‘362 million marks in savings in its banks’ – even its mayor had written a masterpiece, the (now forgotten) Green Chicken.8 By the turn of the century the optimism seemed justified. As Berlin approached the year 1900 it claimed to be the ‘richest city in Europe’ and the ‘metropolis of intelligence’. In an 1899 survey published in the Berliner illustrirte Zeitung Berliners declared that the most important event in the past hundred years of world history had been the unification of Germany – which had in turn led to the creation of its new capital.9 Berlin, it was said, was destined to be the most important place on earth, which would hold the key to history ‘economically, culturally, politically’. But twenty years after the ebullient predictions the city was suffering war, defeat and revolution. The term ‘capital city’ became a curse as Berlin was transformed into the doomed capital of Weimar, then the criminal capital of the ‘Thousand Year Reich’, and then the illegal capital of the GDR. It has not been a very promising record.
Today Berlin stands on the threshold of another centenary and its new status is a fait accompli; on 31 August 1990 Germans signed the Unification Treaty naming Berlin as ‘Capital of United Germany’; on 20 June 1991, after a fierce debate, the Bundestag voted by 337 to 320 to move the capital back to Berlin; on 25 August 1992 Helmut Kohl signed the Capital Agreement, followed on 10 March 1994 by the Berlin/Bonn Act, which enshrined the move of the German parliament (the Bundestag) and the federal government (the Bundesregierung) to Berlin. The Chancellery of the Federal President had already moved by January 1994, and the rest are to be transferred in the course of 1999. Berlin will soon house Germany’s most important ministries, including Foreign Affairs, the Interior, Justice and Finance and Economics, as well as Transport, Labour and Social Affairs, the Family and Regional Planning. Berlin will be the political capital; only a handful of offices will remain in the administrative capital, Bonn.10 Like Faust, Berlin has been given another chance.
The new Berlin visionaries are not daunted by the failures of the past. On the contrary, they are keen to prove that Berlin has changed and that its present aspirations are peaceful and democratic. Berlin, say its supporters, now has a ‘new role’ in Germany and in Europe, a new place in the world. Its construction will be based on its past excellence – the so-called ‘critical reconstruction’ of the architectural historian Dieter Hoffmann-Axthelm – and incorporated into Hans Stimmann’s extensive street plans.11 An official guide to the city, with a foreword by the mayor, Eberhard Diepgen, spelled this out:
I History, Myth, and the Birth of Berlin
Set him down here close at hand –
to find new life in this land
of myth and legend …
(Goethe, Faust, Part II, Act 2)
STENDHAL ONCE SAID OF BERLIN: ‘What could have possessed people to found a city in the middle of all this sand?’ He was not the only visitor to wonder at Berlin’s curious location, its parvenu style, its seeming lack of roots. August Endell said it was a place of ‘dreary desolation’, and even the German nationalist historian Heinrich von Treitschke remarked that the Germans were the only people to have achieved greatness without having built a great capital.1 In his famous work Berlin: Ein Stadtschicksal Karl Scheffler contrasted Berlin with other European capitals, those glorious places which ‘are the centres of a country, are rich and beautiful cities, harmoniously developed organisms of history’. Berlin, on the other hand, developed ‘artificially, under all kinds of difficulties, and had to adapt to unfavourable circumstances’. It was a ‘colonial city’ made up of the dispossessed and uprooted. And, when one views the gigantic building sites and new developments covering the latest incarnation of Berlin, Scheffler’s words seem even more appropriate today than when he wrote them nearly a century ago: ‘Berlin is a city that never is, but is always in the process of becoming.’2
Geography does not make history but it does influence it, and Berlin’s location seems to embody its erratic, insouciant nature. It is striking precisely because, unlike Paris or Rome or Istanbul, Berlin seems to have come from nowhere, wrenched from the sandy soil by some hidden force. One looks in vain for great rivers or lakes, for ports or mountains, for natural riches or fortifications, and as one approaches there is precious little to suggest the presence of one of Europe’s great cities. Instead, Berlin lies in a long sweeping plain dotted with pine forests, marshes and swamps which stretch out until cut by the Oder in the east and the Elbe in the west. The land south and east extends down into wooded base moraine with small hills, chains of lakes and streams created by the distortions and deposits of the last Ice Age. This area, known as the Mark Brandenburg, covers an area of around a quarter of a million square kilometres and forms part of the great Grodno-Warsaw-Berlin depression. The German capital lies in the centre of this strangely inhospitable land, exposed as it is to the cold winds from the east.3 It is clear both from the dearth of natural features and from the vast network of rail tracks, old industrial slums, roads and factories that Berlin was made into a formidable powerhouse not by nature, but by the industry and the politics of man.
The exposed position has made Berlin, like Warsaw and Moscow, subject to endless migrations and wars. Tacitus defined the Germani as people who inhabit the dense forests between the ‘Rhine and the Vistula’ and claimed that they were a ‘pure’ race who had lived there since time immemorial. He was wrong. These plains dwellers were – and are – the product of countless population shifts which have occurred over millennia. Berlin history made a mockery of notions of German racial purity which became so popular in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Nor were migrations a product of the industrial age; in Berlin the pattern was set in prehistoric times.
From the very beginning the region was populated by successive waves of different peoples and cultures. Humans reached the Berlin area around 55,000 BC, but settlements were first formed at the end of the last Ice Age, around 20,000 BC, when hunter-gatherers followed migrating animals north to the area around the river Spree. The earliest farms with their small enclosures of domesticated cows and pigs appeared as late as 4000 BC; one still lies buried under the famous Weimar horseshoe housing estate, the Britzer Hufeisensiedlung. The last of the Stone Age peoples represented the Kugelamphoren Kultur and moved into areas from Tegel to Rixdorf and even on to the present Museum Island around 2000 BC, leaving glimpses of their artistic prowess in the beautiful pottery deposited at sacred religious sites. They too disappeared with the coming of the Bronze Age, which saw a succession of different groups in districts from Spandau to Steglitz. The most successful of these were the ‘Lausitzer’ people, who by 1300 had reached the substantial population of 1,000 people. But they, too, would disappear around 700 BC, when the climate began to cool, and were replaced by the Germanic ‘Jastorf’ people whose weapons, tools and utensils are dotted throughout the soil from Spandau to Mahlsdorf. A site on the Hauptstrasse in Schöneberg contains the remains of horses and the cooked bones of domesticated animals including pigs and sheep, but most incredible are the finds of inlaid bronze jewellery with twisted threads of silver as delicate and beautiful as any found at Celtic sites of the same period.4 But despite the fact that people had lived in the Berlin area since the last Ice Age it was the next group, the Germanic ‘Semnonen’ of the first century BC, who would later be referred to as ‘original Berliners’. This was in part because the Semnonen were the first to appear on the pages of recorded history. They were described not by the Germans, who were illiterate, but by the Romans.
Berlin’s history was shaped by an event which did not take place. The area was never conquered by the Romans. Unlike Paris or London or Cologne or Trier, Berlin would not be able to boast of its imperial heritage nor look to romanitas, with its ideals of government and architecture and use of Latin by the educated elite, and it was this which contributed to Berlin’s later lack of self-confidence. The Romans were not ignorant of the peoples beyond the Elbe, but except for one brief foray into the area they did not attempt to conquer the region. This momentous decision changed the destiny of the city.
It is not known what the Germanic tribes thought of the Romans who edged up to the river Elbe around the time of the birth of Christ, but for their part the Romans viewed these frightening tribesmen with a mixture of awe and contempt. Julius Caesar had incorporated the river Rhine into the empire by 31 BC but had refused to allow expansion further east; not only did he believe that the dark forests were home to fearful beasts and magical creatures like unicorns, but he and other Romans considered the Germans to be too barbaric to be absorbed into the empire. General Velleius was typical when he dismissed them as ‘wild creatures’ incapable of learning arts or laws, or said that they resembled human beings only in that they could speak. It was Julius Caesar’s adopted son Augustus who decided to capture the land east of the Rhine and to push the boundary of the empire up to the Elbe. In a campaign led by Augustus’ stepsons Nero Drusus and Tiberius Roman troops reached the mysterious river bank in 3 BC. The legate L. Domitius Ahenobarbus actually crossed the water to meet some of the tribesmen in order to conclude amicitia or treaties of peace.5 Despite this success Augustus forbade his armies to cross the Elbe. This decision was apparently sanctioned by the gods, for it was said that when Tiberius’ brother Drusus approached the water a horrible giantess had appeared and warned him to go back as he had only a short time to live. Drusus retreated and died a few days later, convincing his companions that they had in fact seen a deity.6 Shortly afterwards, in ad 9, Varus was ambushed in the Teutoberg forest. In one of the worst routs in Roman history three legions were massacred by Arminius, the chief of the Cherusci tribe, who came to be known in Germany as the legendary Hermann. The Romans lost control of the territory between the Rhine and the Elbe, and only a handful of traders dared brave the dangers of the ‘Amber Road’ which led up to the Baltic Sea. Those who returned continued to fascinate Rome with their tales of the strange religious rituals and the fierce tribesmen to be found in the land beyond the Elbe.
The forests of the north remained unconquered, but they were nevertheless the subject of much popular literature in Rome. The Teutons were mentioned in classical sources as early as 400 BC and the word ‘German’ was first used by Posidonus in 90 BC.7 Caesar wrote about the Teutons in his Gallic War; Livy devoted his 104th book of histories to them; Pliny the Elder followed with his now lost work German Wars and in Naturalis Historia; and both Cassius Dio and Velleius Paterculus described aspects of the German campaigns in their histories of Rome.8 But by far the best known and most influential account was written in ad 98 by Cornelius Tacitus. It is called De origine et situ Germanorum or Germania.9
Tacitus had not been to Germany but had lived along the Roman frontier, had read contemporary works about the region and had talked to the soldiers and traders who had travelled there. His account is an intriguing mixture of fact and fiction. Tacitus also seems to have had a definite moral or political purpose in mind when writing the book. Germania was published in the reign of the Emperor Trajan, who had served in the German provinces.10 In some passages it appears that Tacitus is trying to warn the Romans not to be complacent about the Germans, and to show them that if the Teutons should ever combine their skill in battle with Roman discipline they would be invincible. If Rome does nothing or continues to degenerate, he argues, and if the Germans should ever organize against them the empire will be lost: ‘Long I pray may foreign nations persist, if not in loving us, at least in hating one another.’11 Apart from this political warning and despite the historical inaccuracies Germania was the first systematic attempt to describe the land on the edge of the civilized Roman world, beyond the Albis or Elbe which, he laments, was ‘well known and much talked of in earlier days, but [is] now a mere name’.12 Tacitus was also the first to shed some light on the Elbe German Semnonen, the people who lived in the region around what is now the city of Berlin.
Tacitus’ descriptions of the Semnonen, with their topknots and their warlike appearance, are particularly vivid. For him, an author with republican sympathies, the very structure of their tribes was a model of good government. Each was a state in itself with no permanent central government and no king; the supreme authority was found in the assembly of all free men who met at intervals at a Thing or Moot, where chiefs were chosen to decide on specific questions of war and justice. The chiefs themselves possessed great wealth and had large retinues made up mostly of family members. According to Tacitus, chastity was highly regarded, as were family loyalty and ferocity in battle; wives even accompanied their husbands to war. He did note, however, that during peacetime the men were lazy, gluttonous gamblers, and drunkards capable of acts of appalling brutality. They were also deeply religious and at a set time ‘deputations from all the tribes of the same stock would gather in a grove hallowed by the auguries of their ancestors and by immemorial law’. The sacrifice of a human victim in the name of all ‘marks the grisly opening of their savage ritual’. The meeting place in a sacred grove in the forest is ‘the centre of their whole religion … the cradle of the race and the dwelling-place of the supreme god to whom all things are subject and obedient’.13 Tacitus talks of tree and horse worship; gods included Ziu, who was probably derived from Zeus and later ousted by Odin, while the goddess of mother earth was Nerthus.14 A number of her shrines, situated near water, have been found in the Berlin area – including at a spring in Spandau, which was found filled with the remains of birds, and in Neukölln, which was littered with the skeletons of dogs and other animals. The sacrifice of horses was also important to the Semnonen, as were gifts made to lesser deities – wooden carvings, pots of fat and hazelnuts.
Archaeological remains have verified many of Tacitus’ claims. We know that the villages were small and that freemen had their own long houses of wood-post construction with the cracks filled and covered in lime for protection against the elements and vermin. The houses had a hearth and a stable under a gable roof and families lived together with their animals. Arable land was divided into sectors and the ploughing and sowing was done in common. Remains of an industrial area were found in the Donaustrasse in Neukölln which consisted of wells and three lime kilns; there were even facilities for smelting iron.15 Even so, the Germanic tribes were not sophisticated compared to their Roman cousins: agriculture was primitive, and instead of enlarging their resources by cutting down the forests and cultivating new areas they preferred to conquer the nearest fertile land for themselves, a practice which was particularly common on the provincial borders. By the second century ad ever more Teutons were clamouring to get inside the empire. The population of Europe had begun to shift once again.
When Tacitus was writing Germania Teutonic tribes extended deep into eastern Europe, past present-day Poland and into Ukraine. Had Europe been more stable the Semnonen might well have remained in place and become the forebears of present-day Berliners. But, as Tacitus had warned, the Teutons were set to invade Rome itself. In the middle of the second century the German Marcomanni tribe suddenly surged across the Danube into Italy. They were held back with difficulty by the Emperor Marcus Aurelius but fifty years later the Goths conquered present-day Romania and spread throughout the Balkans into Asia Minor, while the Alamanni broke through the Roman Limes and moved to the Rhine and the Danube. The Berlin area was affected in turn around ad 180 when the Elbe German Semnonen suddenly packed up and moved to the south-west, eventually settling by the river Main. They were replaced around ad 260 by the Burgundians, who moved from the Danish island of Bornholm (Borgundarholmr) and whose remains have been found in the Berlin-Rudow area.
Up until this point the movement of peoples towards Rome had been deflected by a series of strong emperors who managed to protect the old imperial boundaries, but in 375 the Teutons attacked once again. This time the onslaught was unstoppable. The Germanic tribes were no longer moving of their own free will but were being forced west by one of the most ferocious charges in European history, the attack of the Huns. The ‘movement of the peoples’, or the Völkerwanderungzeit, had begun in earnest, and the migrations destroyed the old ethnic make-up of the European continent for ever.16
It was Kipling who said:
For all we have and are,
For all our children’s fate,
Stand up and take the war,
The Hun is at the gate!
The word ‘Hun’ still conjures up horrifying images in the minds of Europeans. During the First World War the name was given to the Germans accused of murdering babies in Belgium; in the Second the young soldier Alexander Solzhenitsyn, horrified by the carnage meted out by the Soviets during their conquest of East Prussia in 1945, likened the Red Army to the mongol hordes. Nobody knows why these people suddenly left the steppes north of the Aral Sea and swept into Europe in the fourth century – perhaps there had been a change in the climate like that which prompted the Vikings to raid with such restless energy – but when the Roman Ammianus Marcellinus asked them where they were born and where they came from he reported that ‘they cannot tell you’. Their unstoppable expansion into Europe was one of the most gory in history. Romans wrote of their hideous features, which they believed to be the result of self-mutilation; all referred to their masterful horsemanship and deadly archery, but above all it was the pleasure they were reported to take when butchering their victims which left a lasting reputation for ruthlessness and barbarism.
As the Hun advanced westwards the Goths were driven to take refuge in the Roman Empire. Teutons surged over the frontier; in 406 the Vandals attacked southern Gaul and Spain and then moved on to Africa; the Burgundians, who had for a time settled around Berlin, now moved westwards.17 The Berlin area had become a part of the Hunnic confederacy by 420; indeed a grave was found in Neukölln-Berlin in which a warrior lies buried beside his horse according to their custom. The Burgundians from Berlin were not yet safe; in 436 the Hun caught up with them in Worms and drove them on to the RhÔne valley, where they gave their name to Burgundy. In 450 Attila the Hun moved his forces across Germany with such brutality and violence that it was said no grass would grow where his horse had stepped. Then, on the eve of the campaign of 453, fate intervened. On the drunken night of his wedding to the beautiful German Ildiko (called Kriemhild in legend) Attila had a stroke and died and his kingdom was destroyed. The battles did yield one cultural treasure, namely an epic which tells the story of the battle between the Burgundian King Gundahar and Attila the Hun. It was called the Nibelungenlied (the Burgundians are the Nibelungs) and became the basis for Wagner’s cyclical Bühnenfestspiel, Der Ring des Nibelungen.
By the time of Attila’s death the old integrity of Europe had already been shattered and thousands of restless people were on the move. The sixth-century emperor Justinian tried to keep the empire together but the barbarian invasions did not stop; the gradual decline of Rome and cross-fertilization of Roman and barbarian culture and customs continued.18 In the north the Slavs, who had lived around the eastern Carpathian mountains since perhaps 2000 BC, began to migrate westward.19 It was they who now moved into the area around Berlin.
The Slavs were the latest newcomers to the lands which would later be known as Poland and Germany; by the seventh century they had spread over most of eastern Europe from the Baltic to the Peloponnese and had crossed the Oder into the Elbe-Saale region and into what is now Germany. The border between Germans and Slavs was later confirmed in the 843 Treaty of Verdun: it ran along the river Elbe and down a boundary which cut north-west from Dresden to Magdeburg, past Hamburg and up to the North Sea.20 The Slavs founded a number of cities along the border, including old Lübeck, Meissen and Leipzig, whose name was derived from the Slav word lipsk or linden tree.
As the Slavs moved towards the Berlin area they found a vast, depopulated land with only a few Germans remaining scattered in small settlements. These stragglers were not massacred; on the contrary, archaeological evidence in over forty sites in Barnim and Teltow shows that the remaining Germans were assimilated into the new communities and that the Slavs even adopted some of the old Germanic place names like the river ‘Havel’ and the ‘Müggelsee’, which survive to this day.21 The great Theodor Fontane was one of the few nineteenth-century Germans to acknowledge Berlin’s debt to this much maligned people, and in the third part of the Wanderungen durch die Mark Brandenburg describes how the myriad lakes, streams and hills of the Berlin area which end in ‘-itz’ like Wandlitz, ‘-ick’ as in Glienicke and ‘-ow’ like Teltow had in fact been named by the Slavs.22 Nineteenth-century Germans would have been shocked to learn that the capital was not named after the noble ‘bear’, but was old Elbe-Slav brl, meaning ‘swamp’ or ‘marsh’.23 But long before Berlin existed there were dozens of Slavic settlements within the present city limits: Gatow and Glienicke, Steglitz and Marzahn were Slavic; Pankow was named for the Slavic word pania, meaning ‘flat moor’; pottery shards confirm the existence of a Slavic radial village in Babelsberg; Lützow (Charlottenburg) was founded in the fifth century, and even nearby Potsdam began as a Slavic stronghold. But by far the most important settlements for the future of Berlin were two gigantic fortresses which now lie only a U-Bahn ride away from one another on either side of the city, but which at one time represented the borders of two great territories: Köpenick to the south-east, and Spandau to the north-west.
If nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Germans admitted the presence of the Slavs at all they tended to dismiss them as coarse and unsophisticated – all they had built there was seen as uncivilized compared with superior Germanic culture. This was ahistorical, and had more to do with contemporary German politics than with ancient history. In reality the Slavic fortresses of Spandau and Köpenick were not only highly developed; they created an infrastructure which would prove crucial to the development of Berlin itself.
Each fortress represented the boundary of a great Slavic principality and although the Slavs were collectively referred to by the Latin term Venedi – the Wends – there were two distinct groups in the regions.24 Those who had settled on the river Havel were known as the Hevellians, rulers of the provintia heveldun. Their headquarters were at Brannabor (Brandenburg) but their second town was at Spandau, which was built in the 750s and which already contained around 250 people by the end of the century. The Slavs who settled around the Spree were known as the Sprewans and their province was called the provintia Zpriauuani; they were based around Mittenwalde and founded the villages of Mahlsdorf, Kaulsdorf, Pankow and Treptow. Their capital was Köpenick, itself founded on an old Neolithic site. The name was derived from the Slavic word for ‘settlement on an earth hill’ and, although protected by the Spree, the fort had a commanding view over the area. In 825 it was fortified with high oval wooden walls of about fifty metres in length complete with towers and palisades and gates.25
The first written evidence of such fortresses dates from the records of a 798 expedition by a Frisian fleet under Charlemagne which made its way up the tributaries of the Havel and saw typical Havellian fortresses there. An even more detailed record is found in one of the most extraordinary travel diaries in the history of central Europe, the eye-witness account written in 970 by the Jewish merchant Ibrahim ibn Ja’quab. Ibrahim was born in Muslim Spain and travelled north as an envoy for the caliph of Córdoba. Like so many masterpieces of the ancient world the diary was saved by an Arab scholar, in this case the eleventh-century Abu Obaid Abdallah al Bekri, who found it so impressive that he reproduced it in his Book of Ways and Lands. Ibrahim ibn Ja’quab’s journey took him along the established trade routes through Prague and probably to Cracow, and then towards Mecklenburg, where it is thought he described the settlement at Schwerin.26 He was struck by the large, secure Slavic fortresses with their high wooden walls strengthened by mounds of packed earth and protected by rivers so that one could only reach them on ‘a wooden bridge over the water’. Evidence shows that even the smaller fortresses at Potsdam, Treptow and Blankenburg were built on islands and were not merely defensive but housed carpenters, weavers, tanners, furriers and other tradesmen. Ibrahim ibn Ja’quab noted that the Slavs ‘are especially energetic in agriculture’. The fortresses also provided a safe haven for the priestly hierarchy who kept the shrines for Dazbag, the god of the sun, Jarovit, the god of spring, and the fertility gods Rod and Rozanicy in their midst. Ibrahim also recognized that the Slavs were skilled merchants and that ‘their trade on land reaches to the Ruthenians and to Constantinople’. The fortresses of Spandau-Burgwall and Köpenick had grown powerful from their position on an important medieval east – west trade route which extended from the Rhine and Flanders through Magdeburg, on to Brennabor, over the Berlin area to Leubus and Posen and on to Kiev. Muslims and Jews were the most influential traders, regularly travelling from China to Africa and up the Caspian Sea and the Volga to the Baltic; trade with the Latin west was maintained primarily by Jewish merchants who, according to the early ninth-century geographer Ibn Khurradadhbeh, were highly sophisticated and could ‘speak Arabic, Persian, Greek, Frankish, Spanish and Slavonic. They travel from west to east and from east to west, by land and sea.’27 The Jews were not the only merchants to visit the fortresses, however, and although the Slavs themselves used cloth as currency around 1,000 foreign coins of Arabian, German, English, Scandinavian, Polish, Bohemian and Hungarian origin have been found there. Even at this early date Spandau and Köpenick were filled with international dealers: Scandinavian traders had moved in by the ninth century and Arabian and Jewish traders predominated by the year 1000.28 Dozens of products changed hands – from skins, honey, potash, wax, textiles, slate and weapons to jewellery from Kiev and salt from the Rhineland. Slaves were bought and sold; indeed the word ‘Slav’ was first given to the hapless victims captured in the east and then dragged across Europe to be sold in the markets around the Mediterranean. By ad 1000 the Slavs had created prosperous, stable communities on the banks of the Havel and the Spree. Like the Semnonen before them they might well have become the founders of modern Berlin. But Europe was about to undergo another herculean change. This time people would move in from the west. These warriors and settlers would be Christian.
The spread of Christianity was one of the definitive movements in the creation of modern Europe. The advance began within the bounds of the Roman Empire during the first centuries ad; the first bishoprics were established in northern Europe by the fourth century – the bishop of Rheims, for example, was first mentioned in 314 – a process accelerated by the conversion of the legendary Frankish king Clovis.29 For those outside the empire conversion was often brought about by force, and one of the most successful of these Christian warriors, the man who essentially created the Holy Roman Empire, was called Charles the Great or Charlemagne.30
Charlemagne was born in 742 and became king of the Frankish realm in 768. He was determined not only to resurrect the glory of Rome but to expand its boundaries, to spread Christianity as far as possible and to convert or eradicate the Saxon heathens. After establishing himself in his mighty castle at Aachen he spearheaded a campaign which would take him far into Germany. For eighteen years he waged a bloody war against the Saxons, putting down resistance and massacring those who opposed change. After the battle at Verden in the 782 war he had 4,500 Saxon hostages beheaded in cold blood.31 Not surprisingly, Saxon resistance was crushed by 804 and Charlemagne’s became the first imperial army to reach the river Elbe since Augustus. In 800 he was confident enough to proclaim himself imperator et augustus, the ancient title of the victorious empire, and he was crowned in St Peter’s Basilica by the pope in a dramatic ceremony on Christmas Day.
Despite his ferocity on the battlefield Charlemagne proved himself an admirable administrator, sponsoring the arts and education and dividing the conquered territory into administrative regions called Marken (marches), which were governed by loyal counts or dukes known as Markgrafen or margraves. Charlemagne also favoured the establishment of bishoprics in the conquered lands and made Hamburg the first diocesan seat east of the Elbe. In the end Charlemagne created a new boundary down the centre of Europe called the Limes Sorabicus or Sorbian Wall, which effectively separated Christians from the heathen. It ran from Regensburg through Erfurt, and along the Elbe to Kiel. Berlin still lay a hundred miles beyond the border but Christianity was drawing ever closer. The nearest outpost was a settlement founded on the Elbe. It was called Magdeburg.
The first thing one sees when journeying towards Magdeburg is the great cathedral which rises up from the centre of the small city, its great spires dwarfing everything else around. The building is a mere hint of the city’s role as a beacon on the edge of the Christian world, a stronghold which once lay between ‘Europe’ and the wilderness. Like Trier under the Romans and like West Berlin during the Cold War Magdeburg became a splendid showcase meant both to dazzle and intimidate the poor pagans to the east. The cathedral itself, which started as a small Romanesque church, was regarded as so important that it was endowed by the English king Alfred the Great’s grand-daughter with eighteen casks of gold. Even in its earliest incarnation, it served as a base for missionaries determined to convert the unenlightened Slavs to the east.
Magdeburg continued to be a frontier post under Charlemagne’s successors but it was not until the reign of Henry the Fowler, who ruled from 919 to 936, that a fresh attempt was made to push the borders of Christianity eastward. Like his son Otto I, Henry believed that Magdeburg should be a metropolitan see ‘for all the people of the Slavs beyond the Elbe and the Saale, lately converted and to be converted to God’, and from his palace in the Harz mountains he ordered the creation of bishoprics at Havelberg and the foundation of Quedlinburg and Merseburg.32 The desire to create new strongholds was not simply the result of religious zeal; Henry and his contemporaries felt – quite legitimately – that Christian Europe was under constant threat and that such outposts were essential to its defence. In 845 the Norsemen had decimated the newly founded town of Hamburg and in 875 wiped out a great Saxon and Thuringian army on the Lüneburg Heath while the Magyars from Hungary, the ‘scourge of Europe’, attacked regularly and fought their way as far north as Bremen.25 The new church settlements were built not only as religious centres but also as fortresses to protect the duchy of Saxony against the Hungarians. When Henry died in 936 his son Otto I, who reigned until 973, was determined to continue in his father’s footsteps and expand eastward. This was evident in the ceremony of his investiture as duke of Saxony: ‘I bring before you Otto, chosen by God, designated by Henry, formerly lord of the kingdom, and now made king by all the princes,’ boomed the archbishop of Mainz. ‘Accept this sword with which you are to eject all the enemies of Christ, barbarians and bad Christians. For all power over the whole empire of the Franks has been given to you by divine authority, so as to assure the peace of all Christians.’33
Since I found this building constructed on an old German site and built in the real German age, to be so highly evolved; and since the Master’s name on his modest tombstone was also fatherlandish by sound and origin, the merit of the work emboldened me to change the hitherto ill-famed designation of ‘Gothic’ … and to justify it as the ‘German Architecture’ of our own nation.86
It was this love of the ‘true’ German past which would come to dominate Berlin Romanticism of the nineteenth century.
Despite its extraordinary diversity one of the most striking features of German Romanticism was the obsession with history and the longing to find a modern German identity buried back in the Middle Ages. Many Romantics, including Clemens Brentano and Achim von Arnim, rediscovered German folk art and fostered the collection of old songs, ballads, folklore and fairy tales. In 1800 Friedrich Schlegel wrote To the Germans, in which he encouraged people to fulfil their cultural mission.87 Romantic notions of the German nation appeared in the work of poets like Novalis; fairytales by the brothers Grimm and Moritz von Schwind contained lavish illustrations of German knights and castles, while paintings like Ferdinand Olivier’s The Fairytale King’s Homecoming and Henry Fuseli’s Thor Battering the Midgard Serpent personified not only the fascination with the occult but also the desire to dig through centuries of ‘foreign influence’ to find that ‘pure’ German culture that was said to have existed in the mists of time. This was linked to the obsession with the Volk, the new love for ‘Fatherland’ and, above all, with the yearning to create a new nation-state which would reflect the glory of the German Empire of the high Middle Ages. As the nineteenth century progressed these national pursuits became more patriotic, and it was George Bernard Shaw who warned of the craving for German greatness hidden in Wagner’s revival of the themes of the lust for flesh, power and gold.88
The rediscovery of ‘true German’ medieval art and culture was soon put to political use. In his 1808 Addresses to the German Nation given in a Berlin occupied by Napoleonic troops Fichte explained to the German people that they were a race morally superior to all others and that they had a duty to learn about their past through the study of art and architecture, poetry and language. The cry for nationhood intensified after the defeat of France: by the 1830s young people were gathering at events like the Hambach Festival of 1832 to recall the glories of the past and to call for the unification of Germany; medieval societies restored old buildings and held mock historical services and praised the lost glory of the Holy Roman Empire. Attempts to create a national identity took a new form: the writing of national history.
By the mid nineteenth century historians at the new university in Berlin had started to create a state-centred political history to justify Germany’s new powerful role in the world. In the years between the failed attempt at revolution in 1848 and the unification of Germany in 1871 historians from Ranke to Droysen, from Sybel to Treitschke worked to create a nationalist version of the past, outlining the importance – and indeed the superiority – of the traditions and the language shared by all Germans. Ranke had attempted to write a history free of personal bias but his very choice of subject, the rise of the nation-state or Machtstaat, was thinly veiled praise of the extraordinary rise of Prussia within Germany. Treitschke replaced Ranke’s conception of a balance of powers with the idea that individual states were constantly battling with one another for a position of dominance. Related to this was the glorification of war as a German destiny which would allow the nation to fulfil its cultural mission. For Droysen the concept of the Volk was inseparable from the desire to create a German state led by Prussia, while Friedrich Naumann defined nationalism as the urge of the Germans to spread their influence throughout the world. But it was in the years leading up to the creation of Bismarck’s Reich in 1871 that historians began to legitimate Germany’s new aggressive colonial and military policies, the political exploitation of cultural achievements in science, technology and the arts, the isolation of those in society who were considered not at one with the Volk, and above all the promulgation of German Kultur abroad.89 The historian Sybel wrote in 1867 that Germans had to learn about the history of the ancient Volk because without this the nation would be like a tree without roots, and that they must look back to the ancient tribes described in Germania, for ‘the Germans of Tacitus were the Germans in their youth’.90 Tacitus was also used by xenophobes like Houston Stewart Chamberlain to ‘prove’ German racial purity and ancient Germanic national traits from loyalty to honour in battle. History was used to give the new Germans a sense of pride in their nation. The story of Berlin was no exception.
The most important author in the creation of the popular legend of Berlin was the historian Adolph Streckfuss, who coined the expression From Fishing Village to World City, the title of his 1864 history of the city. As a young man Streckfuss had been a democrat and a supporter of the 1848 Revolution, and it was he who popularized notions of the Berliner Unwille.91 Nevertheless the myth that Berlin had been founded in a barren wasteland in the twelfth century soon became orthodoxy and by 1910 it had become a staple of the Baedeker guide. But why was history rewritten? Why was this dry story taken up with such enthusiasm – a story which ignored so much of the region’s complex and fascinating history? The reason was less than pleasant. Not only had the Berlin area been one of the last areas to be Christianized; unlike ‘truly German’ cities like Cologne or Nuremberg, it had been populated for six centuries not by Tacitus’ Germans, but by the hated Slavs.92 Rather than acknowledge their contribution, the Wendish past was at best marginalized and at worst simply written out of history.93
The Berlin legend was created in an age when concepts like ethnic purity and the superiority of one race over another were taken for granted by many Germans. It was devised at a time when Germans were being taught that their own national characteristics had evolved through contact with certain geographical areas or with the Heimat (homeland) or even with the ‘soil’; at a time when Germans genuinely believed that they were direct descendants of the pure northern race of Germans described by Tacitus. In our multi-ethnic, relativist world it is difficult to understand the importance placed in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries on concepts like ethnic, racial or cultural ‘purity’; indeed the notion of a racially ‘pure’ area was ludicrous in a continent in which every corner has been touched by wars, migration, intermarriage, conquest and commerce, and where even the isolated British were a mixture of Celtic, Roman, Norman, Viking and other peoples. This was particularly true of Germany, which for most of its history had been a patchwork of squabbling territories with no clearly defined borders and no real sense of unity. It was perhaps the very lack of a distinct national identity which made Germans so keen to create a coherent history after 1871 and to turn Berlin into a unifying symbol for the entire nation. But to do so meant that history had to be altered to fit contemporary demands. And the first victim was Berlin’s Slavic past.
In keeping with racial Darwinism and other such theories many Germans now believed that civilization in Europe had moved from the ‘superior’ west to the ‘inferior’ east. Of course such ideas were not unique to Germany; in Britain they were reflected in the colonial policies of the Victorian age, and many nations throughout the nineteenth century created equally chauvinistic accounts of their own superiority. But while internal prejudice was being increasingly channelled into rising anti-Semitism, the external foe was seen to lie in the Slavic lands to the east. Negative views of ‘the Slavs’ were widespread in nineteenth-century Prussia. Friedrich Engels was voicing a popular view when he wrote that ‘all these [Slavic] peoples are at the most diverse stages of civilization, ranging from the fairly highly developed (thanks to the Germans) modern industry and culture of Bohemia down to the almost nomadic barbarism of the Croats and Bulgarians’.94 All Slavs were ‘inferior’, but for Berliners the most contemptible group were their neighbours – the Poles.
The vast borderlands between Germany and Poland have long been one of the most controversial regions of Europe. The lines between them have constantly shifted, leaving mixed populations on one or other side and, despite claims and counter-claims by both nations, there is not and never has been anything like a simple clear-cut historical border to divide the two. The mutual contempt was not merely the result of a long and troubled history but had to do with contemporary questions of political power. The Prussians, with Austria and Russia, had erased Poland from the map in 1795. Germans were taught that the re-creation of a Polish state would result in unacceptable losses to the Prussian – German eastern frontier, and instead of responding to legitimate demands for Polish independence they had tried to Germanize the Prussian-Polish lands through the Kulturkampf and through special bodies created to oversee German colonization; these measures included the prohibition of the use of the Polish language in schools and the purchase of Polish estates for German settlers.95 And yet, to Bismarck’s chagrin, Polish cultural and economic bodies were so well organized that despite his concerted efforts there was little decline in use of the Polish language or in the ownership of land. Worse still, his measures seemed to have intensified a sense of Polish national consciousness.
Berlin’s history was rewritten at a time when Germans felt threatened by this increasing tide of Polish nationalism and when words like ‘Wend’, ‘Slav’ and ‘Pole’ were increasingly – and incorrectly – used interchangeably. Late nineteenth-century Germans were bombarded with images of Slavs as a chaotic people whose towns and villages were primitive and dirty compared with their pristine German counterparts. Poles were commonly portrayed as devious and untrustworthy and incapable of governing themselves. Why, it was asked, should Germany allow the creation of a Polish state which would merely collapse into anarchy? Furthermore, Engels’s view that all civilization, culture, progress and advancement in the Polish lands had ultimately been introduced by Germans was widely believed. One of the most pervasive themes in popular history was the notion of the Drang nach Osten: the ancient German ‘mission in the east’ was viewed as one of the crowning achievements of European history. Wilhelm Jordan was typical when he asked: ‘Are not the Germans more important and more difficult to replace from the perspective of the progressive development of the human race than the Poles?’96 Furthermore it was argued that this was not a modern phenomenon; archaeology and ancient history could ‘prove’ that the Slavs had ‘always’ been comparatively primitive. Ancient Germanic villages could be identified because they were neat and technologically advanced, whereas Slavic ones were crude and disorganized. The archaeologist Wilhelm Unversagt, who carried out excavations between the Oder and the Elbe, said of one Slav fortress:
The domestic and defensive buildings were constructed in the most primitive block-technique … when one recalls that such houses appear in the residences of Slav princes, and at a time when the imposing Romanesque churches were built on the Rhine and in central Germany, which even today arouse our highest admiration, one can understand what the culturally superior Germanic West had to give to the primitive Slavic East.97
These ‘scientific’ and ‘scholarly’ views provided fertile ground for the National Socialists in 1933.
The process of rewriting Berlin history was intensified in the 1930s, when it became a tool of Nazi state policy through the work of bodies such as Walter Frank’s Reichsinstitut für die Geschichte des neuen Deutschlands (the Institute for the History of New Germany) and the work of eminent men like Erich Marcks, Fritz Hartung and Heinrich von Srbik. And it was then that a concerted attempt was made to thoroughly ‘Germanize’ Berlin’s history. Positive references to Jews, Slavs and other ‘undesirable groups’ were simply erased. In the 1936 article ‘What All Berliners Must Know About Their History’ Dr Hermann Rügler, the head of the Institute for the History of Berlin, wrote that ‘Berlin was from the very beginning to the present day a German city’. He acknowledged that although there had been a period of Slavic settlement this had been ‘insignificant’, as Germans had quickly resettled the altes deutsche Stammesgebiet – the old German ancestral area. He claimed that there was plenty of archaeological evidence of early Germanic settlements in the region but that the ‘few Wendish finds’ revealed that the Slavs had merely ‘existed – nothing more’. The 1937 Nazi publications for Berlin’s official birthday boasted that the city was indeed ‘founded on good Germanic soil’, and the mention of the city’s Slavic past disappeared from the 1937 Baedeker.98 In short, Berliners were taught that although there had been a brief period of ‘illegitimate’ Slavic settlement in a Germanic area, these people had contributed nothing to the history of the city. The message was as powerful as it was sinister. If the medieval Germans had been right to retake the ‘true German’ areas around Berlin and if the Slavs were not worthy of inhabiting ‘German soil’, why should this end in the Mark Brandenburg?99 The same arguments were quickly extended to whip up support for the retaking of ‘true German’ cities like Danzig. As early as 1936 the Nazi version of the history of Berlin had become a handmaiden to the war effort.
The denial of the Slavic heritage became the first great myth of Berlin historiography. It was pathetic – rather as if the British had tried to deny the Norman Conquest – but the extraordinary notion that one could use ancient history to legitimate contemporary politics was taken with deadly seriousness. The abuse of early history continued even after the war and not only by the Germans; the ludicrous assumption that the ancient Wends were in fact Polish was used by some Polish extremists in 1945 to claim that because Slavs had at one time lived in the Berlin area the city should become part of Poland.100 Nevertheless the most blatant abuses in the early history of the Mark Brandenburg were corrected after the war, and the Wends were finally given their rightful place as one of the many groups who had lived in and contributed to the long and complex history of the city of Berlin.
Such considerations were of course irrelevant to the Berliners of the fifteenth century. The city was still small and insignificant and paled in comparison to Paris or London, Amsterdam or even Rome, where Cardinal Odoardo Farnese could hear twenty-seven languages spoken in the refectory of the Jesuit college in the Piazza Altieri. Berlin still had nothing to compare with the marvels of the rest of Europe, whether in the Vladislav Hall in Prague or the Palazzo Vecchio in Florence or the magnificent guild hall of Ypres. But Berlin was now firmly in the grip of the Hohenzollern family and was about to be pushed on to the world stage. In the coming years it would undergo a transformation so profound that it would become one of the most important and powerful cities in Europe. It would be a traumatic birth.
II The Capital of Absolutism
The chance is offered; take it while you can.
(Faust, Part II, Act 1)
WHEN EMINENT FIFTEENTH-CENTURY EUROPEANS like Copernicus and Albrecht Dürer set out on their travels through Europe they did not contemplate visiting Berlin; why should they when Florence, Venice, Padua, Paris and Rome beckoned with ‘the most glorious sights for state and magnificence that any city can show a traveller’ or when the Low Countries were reaching ever greater heights of art and culture?1 Why should they go to the small German town when so many other cities, from Buda to Prague to Moscow, were being transformed by Italian Renaissance architects and artists, when Nuremberg and Augsburg and Munich were producing fabulous works of art, or when Copernicus’ own university of Cracow was being transformed by the spirit of religious tolerance and Humanism of the ‘Golden Age of Poland’ reflected in the works of that great poet Jan Kochanowski.2 The Dutch art historian Karel van Mander travelled not to Berlin but to Vienna, and recommended those travelling south to go to Prague, which, under Rudolf II, had become the Parnassus of the arts.3 Compared to the great princely houses of Europe the Hohenzollern margraves were poor and their city was rough, unsophisticated and shabby.4 Even so, Berlin was now a residence city and its culture was improving.
The sixteenth century had started well for Berlin. The Reformation, which had swept through Germany after 1517 when Luther nailed his ninety-five theses to the castle church of Wittenberg, had come to Brandenburg peacefully. The Hohenzollern Elector Joachim II had adopted Lutheranism on 13 February 1539 – the first service was held in Berlin by Luther’s friend Johann Agricola in 1540 – and the people had followed him. Within a few years the great families of Berlin were commissioning paintings and monuments for themselves in the new style: the Blankenfeldes had a massive memorial carved showing the family at prayer, while the Reiches ordered a painting of the entire family mourning at the crucifixion. Most of the great painters of sixteenth-century Germany – Albrecht Dürer, Lucas Cranach, Hans Baldung (Grien) and Hans Holbein – worked in the service of the Reformation, helping to spread its ideas and to glorify the new leaders on canvas. Luther’s friend Lucas Cranach the Elder painted a magnificent portrait of Joachim I, who ruled in Berlin until 1535. In 1551 Cranach the younger painted his heir, Joachim II.
This 1551 portrait captures the self-confident air of a man not yet troubled by conflict. He stands stocky and proud, with a hint of cruelty hovering around his eyes in a manner reminiscent of Holbein’s 1536 portrait of Henry VIII.5 Joachim’s red tunic is shot through with gold, his bearskin hat is decorated with pearls and his heavy fur cloak is weighted down by two enormous jewel-encrusted gold chains. There is nothing in the portrait to suggest any doubt about the future. The painting was commissioned at an optimistic moment in northern Europe’s history, when Amsterdam was outpacing Antwerp as the greatest city of the Low Countries and when east – west trade was sustaining towns from Danzig to Nuremberg. The culture of northern Germany was becoming more sophisticated: great castles were built from Dresden to Stettin; princes and merchants patronized the arts and employed craftsmen, furniture makers, metal workers, sculptors and painters in the creation of their magnificent courts.6
The elector had started to improve Berlin. He invited the Torgau master-builder Konrad Krebs to build the electoral residence, which in the 1540s became a monumental Renaissance palace; he invited in Dutch-trained builders and hired artists and architects like Kaspar Theyss, Hans Schenk and Kunz Buntschuh to bring a glimmer of the Renaissance to the city. Under him Berlin sustained a population of 10,000 people. But the self-confidence of this generation would be short-lived. Despite the Religious Peace of Augsburg of 1555, during which all imperial rulers from the electors to the knights had promised to tolerate Lutherans and Catholics within the empire according to the principle cuius regio, eius religio, the divisions brought about by the Reformation were about to resurface.7 Berlin was on the verge of another of those traumatic upheavals which mark its history, known as the Thirty Years War. This time the war would wipe out virtually all vestiges of Berlin’s medieval past.
One can sometimes catch glimpses of the violence and despair of so many people’s lives in the paintings of the time. There are flashes of ugliness and cruelty in the works of Holbein and Cranach; there is a sense of gloom, an undercurrent of despair in the works of Brueghel and of Bosch with their cold peasant villages, destitute vagabonds and terrifying visions of carnage. Brueghel’s beggars have sunken battered faces, they wear rags, they are blind and struggle down cart tracks on crutches; Bosch’s downcast pedlar wears only one shoe as he creeps slowly away from an isolated inn, its broken windows and hanging shutters just visible in the bleak light of mid-winter. Grünewald’s depiction of the ugly enraged villagers in The Mocking of Christ shows the people dragging an accused man through the streets on a rope, beating him as he passes and leaving blood streaming down his face – common treatment of condemned men and women in the villages of northern Europe. In Three Ages of Woman and Death Grien shows a ghastly rotting corpse holding an hourglass over the head of a young maiden; his woodcuts with titles like Young Witch and Dragon, or Albrecht Altdorfer’s Departure for the Sabbath, hint at the common fear of the occult. Even Holbein, better known for his revealing portraits of monarchs and princes, depicts horrific scenes in his series of drawings, Der Totentanz (Dance of Death) and Das Todesalphabet (Death Alphabet) of 1524; indeed it was the turbulence following the Reformation which drove him to England and the court of Henry VIII. An acceptance of violence shows in the thousands of contemporary woodcuts with their gory portrayals of battle scenes, torture and dismemberment. The images were not fantasy but reflected the harsh spirit of an age consumed by the religious and dynastic conflicts which erupted in Europe and Berlin, and they capture the despair of populations forced to endure decades of violence during that most grisly of religious conflicts.8
The Thirty Years War began in 1618 and raged until 1648. It left deep scars on the German psyche and it was a turning point for Berlin, destroying the old city and paving the way for the benevolent despots of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries.9 Even before the outbreak of hostilities it was clear that Europe was on the verge of a disaster. There had been a sense of impending doom since the 1550s, which had seen waves of unrest, peasant uprisings and a general mood of crisis. Berlin had also experienced increased poverty and social unrest; once again Jews were targeted. In July 1510 100 people were tried for allegedly stealing and selling sacred items from a Berlin church: thirty-eight Jews were burned in the Neue Markt and the rest were banished from the Mark Brandenburg. But above all there was a sense that the fragile truce between Protestants and Catholics hammered out at the Peace of Augsburg was about to fail. Governments throughout the German lands had started building up their defences, and even in Prussia, where the estates refused to pay for a militia, the elector raised taxes to pay for fortifications for Memel and Pillau and built two warships to patrol the Baltic.10 The premonition was correct: in 1608 the imperial Diet collapsed. By 1618 four important political conflicts had emerged in Europe. The first was between Protestant princes and the Catholic Habsburgs in the Holy Roman Empire; the second was the continued hostility between Poland and the Swedes; the third, the conflict between France and the Habsburgs, and the fourth, that between the Spanish and the Dutch. These were woven into a net of related quarrels, dynastic ambitions and petty rivalries so that even before the war began treachery, broken alliances and deceit amongst rulers had become common on all sides.11 No single religion, ruler or state was powerful enough to impose any decisive settlement on the others. War was a foregone conclusion.
In the event the Thirty Years War began in Prague. Hostilities broke out during the Bohemian revolt of 1618 when a Protestant king, the twenty-three-year-old Frederick II of the Palatinate, was chosen by the estates to rule Bohemia instead of the Catholic Habsburg successor. The Habsburgs, then in league with a number of other German states, attempted to oust the new king; they were victorious under General Tilly, who triumphed at the Battle of the White Mountain in 1620. The Habsburg emperor’s success fuelled his hope that he might wipe Protestantism from the face of Europe altogether, and he decided to push northward and retake converted lands, a scheme later codified in the Edict of Restitution. With the help of his brilliant general, Albrecht von Wallenstein, it seemed that he might succeed. Wallenstein conquered great swathes of Germany, finally approaching the Mark Brandenburg in 1626. In the tenth year of fighting, the war reached Berlin.
Until then Berliners had been spared the worst of the conflict. A few troops had passed by the city in 1620, including 3,000 English mercenaries on their way to Prague under Ernst von Mansfeld, but although a fire had swept through the town that year it had had nothing to do with the troops. Now, however, the armies were drawing near. Berlin was ruled by a weak and ineffectual leader, the Elector George William, whose ideas about war were limited to the notion that if attacked one should surrender and change sides. It would prove a disastrous policy for Berlin.
With Wallenstein’s men approaching fast the elector was finally forced to do something. He tried to gather a defence force but could muster fewer than 1,000 troops; when they entered Berlin in order to organize themselves the confused citizens pelted them with stones, believing them to be on a secret mission to convert them from Lutheranism to Calvinism.12 The troops were of little use. By the summer of 1626 Wallenstein had overrun most of Germany and had based himself at Crossen on the Oder. His troops threatened to ransack the towns of the Mark if they were not paid compensation. Brandenburg’s ‘obligation’ was assessed at 60,000 gulden, and to encourage payment Wallenstein rounded up hundreds of people and held them hostage. The money was finally paid, but it made little difference. His troops entered Berlin for the first time on 15 November 1627 and ransacked the city, looting and raping. They returned a year later, bringing another wave of terror. Forty thousand troops arrived in February 1630, and this time they remained for over a year, leaving a legacy of destruction, hunger and disease in their wake. Each occupation meant more brutality for the people, who prayed: ‘Is there no God in heaven that will take our part? Are we then such utterly forsaken sheep? Must we look on while our houses and dwellings are burnt before our eyes?’13 This is one reason why there is only one late Renaissance building still standing in central Berlin.14
After four years of occupation by the Catholic forces Berlin’s fortunes appeared to be changing. The apparent salvation came in the form of one of the great heroes of the Protestant cause, the king of Sweden, Gustavus Adolphus, who had landed at Usedom in Pomerania in July 1630 and had begun to march south. The imperial commander, Tilly, had already taken the outer fortifications of Magdeburg by April, but as the Swedes approached he feared that he might be caught between the city and the Swedish forces. He gave the order to attack, but tragically could not control his own insubordinate, bloodthirsty troops, and on 20 May 1631, in one of the most outrageous acts of the war, 30,000 of the people of Magdeburg were hacked or burned to death in a matter of hours. The news of the massacre infuriated the Swedish king, who was spurred on by the desire to avenge the disaster. By the end of May 1631 his men, wearing the telltale yellow and blue ribbon around their hats, had driven the imperial troops south and had reached the gates of Berlin. Gustavus Adolphus now demanded that the dithering Elector George William sign a Treaty of Alliance with Sweden. The elector’s attempts to try to evade his obligation so infuriated the Swedish king that on 21 June he brought his army to the gates of Berlin and aimed his cannon directly at the electoral palace. George William cowered inside, sending his wife and mother-in-law out to pacify the king, but on 23 June the treaty was finalized, putting Berlin firmly under Swedish rule. Brandenburg and the fortresses of Spandau and Küstrin were placed at the disposal of the Swedish king, Berlin was occupied, and Gustavus Adophus himself took up residence there for a time, demanding 30,000 thalers a year for the upkeep of his troops.
Any hopes Berliners might have had for an improvement in their lives were quickly dashed. The new occupation force, which remained until 1634, behaved as badly as Wallenstein’s men had done. The situation would worsen again. In 1635 the emperor’s forces began to move north once more; armies swept into the Mark Brandenburg from the south and Berlin became part of the central battlefield of the war. That year marked the beginning of the last and most horrible phase of the conflict in the Mark Brandenburg; fighting between Sweden and the emperor was constant and the city changed hands and was plundered and occupied on numerous occasions. In 1638 George William fled to Königsberg, leaving Berlin under the control of the imperial Catholic general Adam Graf zu Schwarzenberg and stripping it of its Residenz status. Schwarzenberg was detested by Berliners. Not only did he treat the city as his own, but he took to burning down part of Berlin every time an enemy army approached to try to dissuade them from attacking; much of the city was destroyed in this manner – particularly in a raging fire of 1640. In January 1641 word spread that the Swedes were moving towards Berlin once again, and this time Schwarzenberg gave the order to burn Cölln. As the buildings blazed it was discovered that the Swedish ‘army’ consisted of only 1,000 poorly equipped men, 360 of whom were easily captured. To Berliners’ delight Schwarzenberg died suddenly in March 1641, releasing them from his grim hold, but by now Berlin had only 845 houses left, 200 of which were empty. Cölln had been almost completely destroyed.
With such meagre defence of its ideas, it was no wonder that the Enlightenment would soon fade. The death knell was sounded when Frederick the Great was succeeded by Frederick William II in 1786, a man who opposed the Enlightenment and soon became terrified by the implications of the French Revolution. After 1789 many Berliners turned against their own Enlightenment thinkers and some societies and clubs voluntarily closed themselves down rather than be associated with the spread of Jacobinism. Those who held on to their Enlightenment beliefs were labelled ‘Nicolai-iten’ and treated with disdain. The self-censorship extended to all levels of society. Immanuel Kant dutifully stopped writing about religion when, in 1794, his works were declared derogatory to Christianity, noting in his papers: ‘To withdraw or deny one’s convictions is base, but silence in such a case as this is the subject’s duty.’119 The Berlin salons of Dorothea Veit and Henriette Herz and Rahel Levin (later Varnhagen von Ense) enjoyed a brief flurry of activity between the time of Frederick’s death and 1806, attracting men from Fichte to the Humboldt brothers to Varnhagen and Schlegel, but this ended with the Napoleonic Wars, when ‘friendships between commoners and nobles and the open display of Jewish wealth and culture all became deeply controversial’.120 Rahel Varnhagen would soon lament: ‘where are our days, when we were all together! They went under in the year ‘06. Went under like a ship: containing the loveliest goods of life, the loveliest pleasures.’121
Perhaps the most poignant symbol of the sad decline of the Enlightenment was the defection from the circle around the once-revered Friedrich Nicolai. Nicolai hung on to his ideals until the end. He was deeply resentful of the coming of Romanticism and was so appalled by Goethe’s The Sufferings of Young Werther that in 1775 he wrote a lame satire called The Friends of Young Werther; he disliked Kant and mocked Herder’s cult of folk songs and interest in German national identity. But his time had passed. Goethe and Schiller attacked him in Xenien and Goethe used him as the model for the ludicrous character Proktophantasmist in the first part of Faust. By the time of his death in 1811 he had become a figure of ridicule amongst the new intellectual elite in Berlin. The Enlightenment, the ‘coming of the light’, had brought a brief period of tolerance to the city, but its most fundamental principles had already been pushed aside by the time of the French Revolution. The Enlightenment would leave a legacy, but not the one envisaged by Mendelssohn and Lessing and Nicolai. By shattering the belief in traditional religion and loosening the bonds to an old way of life it had left an immense vacuum in people’s lives. The Enlightenment thinkers had hoped the void would be filled by notions of tolerance, reason and universal brotherhood, but this was not to be. Instead, people turned to nationalism – not merely the cultural nationalism of Lessing and Klopstock and Herder, but the political nationalism which would be sparked off by one of the most formative events in Berlin history: the arrival of Napoleon.
III The Emerging Giant
Bring in the wine! A toast! To liberty!
(Faust, Part I)
‘FROM HERE AND TODAY,’ Goethe said to friends shortly after the French Revolution, ‘a new epoch in world history is dawning, and you will be able to say that you were there’.1 During his eighty-two years the genius poet witnessed the dramatic changes which rocked Europe and Berlin, from the Napoleonic Wars and the coming of the Industrial Revolution to the birth of that essentially urban movement which he did so much to bring about – Romanticism. It was a time of great uncertainty, of turmoil and, for many in Germany, of humiliation. At the end of his life Goethe said sadly: ‘I thank God that I am not young in so thoroughly finished a world.’
For an era of such extraordinary importance it started calmly enough. In the last years of his life Frederick the Great had become a recluse, languishing at Sanssouci with only his dogs for company. He had grown weary of life and when he died in 1786 Berliners seemed almost relieved. The Enlightenment was already faltering and the Sturm und Drang (storm and stress) writers were ushering in a new, wilder culture. Then, in 1789, the news of an extraordinary upheaval exploded across Europe.
The French Revolution shook every aspect of European life, from politics to the economy, from literature to philosophy. It propelled Europe headlong into the modern era. When the news from Paris first reached Germany the revolution was heralded as the precursor to a new, better age. Kant praised it, Hölderlin called it a ‘beloved wonder’, the young Hegel called it a ‘glorious sunrise’ and was so moved that he and his friend Schelling planted a Liberty Tree in the Tübingen market place, Klopstock and Schiller became honorary French citizens, Herder and Fichte and Beethoven wrote of a new age of liberty and brotherly love. Wordsworth captured the dream in his immortal lines: ‘Bliss was it in that dawn to be alive, But to be young was very heaven!’2
The dream was short lived. Within months news of the September massacres had turned erstwhile supporters against the revolution. Iffland and Gneisenau were now scathing about the Terror, von Gentz published Burke’s critique of the revolution, Kotzebue wrote a burlesque mocking Paris, Klopstock mourned that ‘our Golden Dream is shattered’. On 8 February 1793, after the execution of Louis XVI, Schiller wrote, ‘I feel so sickened by these abominable butchers’, and six months later fumed that the revolution had ‘plunged not only that unhappy people itself, but a considerable part of Europe and a whole century, back into barbarism and slavery’.3 The longing for Freiheit, Gleichheit, Brüderlichkeit had ended in the bloody crash of the guillotine.
In Germany the profound disappointment turned to fear when it became obvious that the violence would not be contained in France. War threatened on the Rhine. The Gironde party, hoping for a diversion abroad to prevent the Jacobins and Royalists from gaining power, began to churn out pamphlets and posters proclaiming that ‘France owned the Rhine’ and that it was France’s ‘mission’ to bring the ideas of the revolution to enslaved peoples ‘yearning to be free’. The problem for Germans was that this ‘freedom’ would come through the force of arms.
In April 1792 France declared war on Austria and, by implication, on her ally Prussia. It was the start of the Revolutionary Wars. The disorganized Germans were no match for the zealous French army and by September France had won the great victory at Valmy. By 1794 all German territory west of the Rhine was held by the occupying forces. Austria now fought alone in Italy against the new commander-in-chief of the Army of the Interior, a young Corsican named Napoleon Bonaparte who had already astonished the world with his military genius. On 9 November 1799 he returned to Paris and was made first consul. In 1804 Napoleon Bonaparte declared himself emperor. He was thirty-five years old.
Napoleon was determined to make German states virtual colonies of France. In 1805 he resumed the campaign in the east and by 1806 had dissolved the Holy Roman Empire, forcing the emperor, Francis II, to abdicate. Germany had ceased to exist as a unified political body. Napoleon reorganized the German Reich into a new entity: the Confederation of the Rhine.
Until now Prussia had remained neutral in the European war. In his Annalen Goethe wrote: ‘Europe had changed shape, cities and navies were being destroyed on land and sea, but central and northern Germany profited from a certain feverish peace which enabled us to enjoy a doubtful safety.’ The ‘feverish peace’ which had so encouraged the cultural flowering in Weimar and in Berlin itself was almost at an end. Tension was growing between Paris and Berlin. In 1805 Napoleon had tried to use Prussian-occupied Hanover as bait in his peace negotiations with Britain. Tension was exacerbated when in 1806 he had the Nuremberg bookseller Johann Palm executed for publishing an anonymous pamphlet attacking France: the trial caused a sensation and roused popular anger throughout German lands. In the end it was his violation of the Treaty of Schönbrunn which provoked Frederick William III of Prussia to make his disastrous declaration of war on 1 October 1806. Prussia was now fighting alone against the mighty French army. It was doomed to fail.
It was not surprising that Prussia lost to France in 1806. When Frederick the Great died he left Prussia in the hands of his nephew Frederick William II, who was neither intelligent nor dedicated enough to keep the worn-out system alive. He had ignored the army and the bureaucracy while creating a glittering life at court – it was he who invited Mozart to Berlin to conduct The Marriage of Figaro. It was renowned for its courtesans, its corruption and its domination by the strange cult called the Rosicrucian Order. The members of the sect had transformed life at court with their palace seances in which people communed with spirits of the dead or with the elements, and with their truly depraved rituals which were said to prolong human life.4 When the system began to fall apart the king had merely increased controls and religious censorship. Instead of modernizing, Berlin had taken on the appearance of a frenzied and decadent eighteenth-century court. Frederick William II died in 1797 but his successor Frederick William III brought little change. He was less ostentatious and debauched than his predecessor but he lacked character, finding it impossible to make decisions and dithering and procrastinating at a time when Prussia needed a firm hand. It is telling that it was not he but his consort, the beautiful young Queen Luise, who would become the heroine of Berlin for taking a stand against the French and against Napoleon. By the time Napoleon invaded Prussia Berlin had languished under thirty years of incompetent rule.5
Napoleon needed only one week, from 10 to 17 October, to smash this once formidable opponent. Prussian divisions were knocked down one by one while the fortresses from Erfurt to Halle, Spandau to Stettin to Magdeburg surrendered in turn – only Kolberg at the Prussian Pomeranian coast held out until 1807. The final battles were fought on 14 October 1806, at Auerstedt and to the south at Jena. The latter was an unmitigated disaster. Last-minute changes in the Prussian battle plan resulted in confusion and a tangle of troops with no supply lines and no communication. At that moment the French attacked and within hours the Prussians were retreating in panic. One young man who heard the noise of battle from his room in Jena was Friedrich Hegel, who hastily scribbled the last words of his Phenomenology of Spirit so that he could hide it from the occupying forces. The Prussian army, which had risen to such prominence under Frederick the Great, had collapsed.
News of the catastrophe at Jena reached Berlin the following day and it became obvious that the city could no longer be defended. Panicky officials began to load wagons with everything from weapons from the arsenal to state papers; the king and queen were spirited off to Königsberg and those with means fled east. As the governor of the city, General von der Schulenburg-Kehnert, prepared to leave he posted the infamous declaration explaining how Berliners were expected to behave now that they had been defeated. ‘The King has lost a battle,’ it read. ‘The first duty of the citizen is now to be quiet. This duty I charge the inhabitants of Berlin to perform. The King and his brothers live.’ With that, Berliners were left to face French occupation alone. Henriette Herz, who calmly decided to remain in her Berlin apartments, wrote of the announcement: ‘How laconic! And yet part of it is superfluous. For who in Berlin thought of disturbing his quiet? The announcement was read, but few countenances showed any expression of fear, most no expression at all; at the utmost one or two people went away shaking their heads with an air that seemed to say, really, it has come a little too quick!’6
Napoleon entered Berlin on 27 October 1806 and as his triumphal procession made its way under the newly completed Brandenburg Gate and down Unter den Linden curious Berliners lined the streets to watch him pass. The sculptor Gottfried Schadow, who had designed the new Quadriga atop the Brandenburg Gate, sketched the stubble-faced victor glowering at the people from under his hat. That evening French troops celebrated by breaking into churches, plundering wine cellars and raiding food stores.7 Napoleon dismissed the acting governor Prince Hatzfeld and ordered the councillors to gather 2,000 eminent Berliners together; sixty were elected to a new city council, with seven forming the executive. He appeased Berliners by promising political reforms, the institution of the Code Napoléon and a modern constitution, but soon after the signatures were dry on the Treaty of Tilsit of July 1807 it became clear that he saw Berlin as little more than a subjugated capital from which to squeeze reparations.
Tilsit was Prussia’s final humiliation. Despite the occupation of Berlin Prussia had remained formally allied to Russia and at war with France, but on 14 June 1807 Napoleon defeated the tsar at Friedland and Russia sued for peace. On 9 July Tsar Alexander and Napoleon met on a luxurious raft on the river Niemen; Frederick William was forced to wait on the riverbank while the two leaders signed the treaty which dismembered Prussia and removed her territory west of the Elbe along with most Prussian-held territory in Poland, which became the grand duchy of Warsaw under the duke of Saxony. Prussia, which had had a population of 6 million at the death of Frederick the Great, now had only 4,938,000 people. Only four provinces were left, all of which were occupied by Napoleon. The land was impoverished and weakened by war and the Prussian army was reduced to 42,000 men, 16,000 of whom were to be at Napoleon’s disposal. Furthermore, Prussia was forced to pay an indemnity of over 100 million francs and also to cover the costs of the occupation of a huge foreign army of over 150,000 men, a burden which would cost 216 million francs.8 Napoleon knew that Prussia would be unable to raise the money quickly and used this tardiness as an excuse to continue his occupation. At the same time, the French stripped Berlin of its wealth and its few treasures; the official list of plunder included 116 paintings, 96 busts and statues, 183 bronzes, 538 gems, 7,262 medals and coins, manuscripts, amber and the Quadriga, which had only just been placed atop the Brandenburg Gate. This was a meagre haul compared to the 4,000 cartloads of booty taken from Rome, which became the foundation of the Musée Napoléon (the Louvre), but the loss of their few treasures irked the population. There was also a good deal of unofficial looting and Berliners were forced to watch as officers piled goods on to boats and sent them off to Paris.9 Berliners also resented the rowdy troops quartered in their homes and the creation of huge French barracks like the Camp Napoléonburg in Charlottenburg, which housed 25,000 men. Manufacturers and merchants suffered from a drop in trade brought about by Napoleon’s ‘continental system’, but even when Napoleon replaced the blockade with an import ban of between 40 and 50 per cent, scarcity and price rises caused hardship. Berliners could not believe that their mighty capital had fallen so quickly and so far.
Napoleon was astounded by the ease of his victory over Prussia. When he visited the tomb of Frederick the Great he told his officers: ‘Hats off, gentlemen! If he were still alive, we would not be here.’10 Napoleon’s words were echoed by Queen Luise, who lamented that Prussia had ‘gone to sleep on the laurels of Frederick the Great’. The problem lay in part with Frederick’s own success. His obsessive control over the army and administration had kept enlightened absolutism alive long past its natural life. His successors had ignored his advice, but for an artificial state made strong primarily by its oversized army the decision to allow it to decay had been a form of suicide.
Napoleon’s occupation of Berlin did have one surprising benefit: it ushered in a period of reform which led to profound changes in the army, education and administration of Prussia. The reason was clear. Under the old system of absolutism the monarchy had seen no need to change. Napoleon’s lightning strike had exposed the rot in the system. Even the reactionary king understood that if he did not introduce reforms Prussia would never again attain great power status in Europe. He did not want reforms because he felt they were right; he introduced them because he had no choice. Prussia could no longer survive as an absolutist state. It was a question of reform or perish.
Berlin was now under French military control and although the king was in Königsberg the government in Berlin did appear to be pro-French, not least because open defiance of Napoleon would have led to immediate reprisals. In return for his loyalty the king was allowed some autonomy in the running of his government and managed to appoint a number of ministers who were given unheard of authority despite being clandestine opponents of France. Frederick William advised that the Prussian state should ‘replace by spiritual strength those material things which have been lost’. The reformers wanted to modernize the army, improve the educational system, and above all create a constitutional government. Under normal circumstances the king would have seen these ideas as radical and dangerous. As it was, they were his only hope if he was to preserve his own power.
The city of Berlin remains something of a shrine to the reformers who struggled to modernize Prussia under the watchful eye of the French. Statues, plaques, busts, streets and squares still bear the names of men hailed as everything from German nationalists to the ‘fathers of German democracy’. Humboldt University – so named by the Soviets in 1945 – is graced by statues of the brothers Alexander and Wilhelm; statues of Freiherr vom and zum Stein and August von Gneisenau stand on Unter den Linden; Hardenbergstrasse, Hardenberg Platz, Gneisenaustrasse and Niebuhrstrasse criss-cross the west end. Ironically these ‘great Berliners’ had come from elsewhere: Scharnhorst and Hardenberg were Hanoverians, Niebuhr was educated in Holstein, Stein was Franconian and educated in Hanover, Blücher and Queen Luise were from Mecklenburg, and only the Humboldt brothers, Schleiermacher and von Schön were born in Prussia. Many had originally come to Berlin to work in the civil service and were shocked to find their adopted city subjugated by a foreign power. The reformers were universally anti-French. Stein had initially adopted a tolerant line but when Napoleon continued to demand larger sums from destitute Prussia he realized that the only course open to them was to wage war on France and provoke a popular uprising.11 Gneisenau said, ‘As a patriot I sigh. In the time of peace we have neglected much, occupied ourselves with trivialities, flattered the people’s love of show, and neglected war which is a very serious matter.’12 Heinrich von Bülow wrote in 1806 that leaders who let even large armies ‘lie idle in garrison service, where it rusts and bastardizes and sinks into a spiritless militia of the sort that German students call Philistine … The fact is certain, Prussia has lost her independence since she forgot how to make use of 200,000 men.’13 And Hardenberg had warned the king: ‘a radical treatment of the defects of our administration is absolutely and urgently necessary.’14 The most influential of the reformers was Stein, who was appointed after Tilsit in July 1807. He would be in power only one year, but his impact on the government and administration of Berlin would be remarkable.
Baron vom und zum Stein came from an old Thuringian family but had moved to Berlin to take up a post in the Prussian General Directory in July 1804. He was highly independent, had a fiery temperament and a determination which had already set him apart from his colleagues. After Jena Stein and his friend Hardenberg persuaded the king to dismiss the Kabinett, the powerful but irresponsible group of courtiers which had helped lead Prussia to ruin and included men like Lombard, Beyme and von Köckeritz and the ineffectual and stupid minister of foreign affairs Haugwitz; Lombard had in fact been a traitor, feeding information to Napoleon while pretending to advise the king. In 1807 Stein was presented to the king as the ‘only man’ who could save Prussia and in his memoirs Stein recalled looking out at the defeated capital, a sight which fuelled his desire to create a ‘rousing, moral, religious, patriotic spirit in the nation, of inspiring it anew with courage, self-confidence, readiness for every sacrifice in the cause of independence of the foreigners and of national honour, and of seizing the first favourable opportunity to begin the bloody and hazardous struggle for both’.15
Stein began by taking over the Civil Organization Commission, which included men like von Schön, Niebuhr and Stägemann. Like Stein they had been deeply influenced by Adam Smith, had worked to rid Prussia of backward class divisions and hoped to set up representative institutions in their place.16 Stein’s first accomplishment was the Emancipation Edict of 9 October 1807, which freed the estates from ancient restrictions and allowed all men to engage in the occupation or business of their choice irrespective of birth; it abolished serfdom and allowed noblemen to engage in trade while curbing the restrictive guilds. Stein’s government reforms were equally radical. The Edict for Local Institutions abolished all existing administrative bodies, reorganized local government districts and centralized the administration of the state to allow for coherent centralized government and for the efficient distribution of resources. The new Council of State was to be presided over by a president, ministers of the crown, royal princes, and appointed privy councillors; a smaller body, the Council of Ministers, was to deal with ordinary government business. For this five ministries were created: Foreign Affairs, War, Finance, Justice and Internal Affairs, with the first meeting held in the Berlin Rathaus on 6 July 1809. The council survived until 1918 and its creation marked the beginning of Berlin’s domination of Prussian, then German, national government affairs. For the first time ministers were freed from the direct interference of the king and the court. At the municipal level Berlin was given special status, with its own elected city council and with a magistrate and an elected Bürgermeister and Oberbürgermeister. The mayors were still subject to official approval by the king, and police and justice came under state jurisdiction, but Berliners gained control over many other functions from road building to housing. These would prove crucial in regulating development in the coming era of rapid industrialization and would later make Berlin’s municipal administration the envy of Europe.
While Stein reformed the civil service Wilhelm von Humboldt tackled education reform. Born in 1767, the sparkling, generous Humboldt had long been a popular figure in the Berlin salons of Henriette Herz, Dorothea Veit and Carl Laroche. He had championed classical education and the concept of Bildung from an early age. For him education was not merely the chance to learn a trade or set of skills but rather gave the individual the chance to develop his Humanität, his human spirit. He was a meritocrat and believed in education for all irrespective of birth – his reforms would do much to further the rise of the bourgeoisie in nineteenth-century Berlin. In 1808 he was appointed the king’s chief of educational and ecclesiastical affairs in the new Ministry of the Interior and set about reshaping the Prussian education system. He abolished class-based schools like the Ritter or Knight’s Academies, made education compulsory for all, improved elementary schooling and introduced a classical curriculum into a new kind of secondary school which he called the Gymnasium. His proudest achievement was the creation of a new university.
Berlin University came about as a direct result of the Napoleonic Wars. The Peace of Tilsit had forced Prussia to hand over the universities of Duisberg, Erlangen and, the most important, Halle; neither of the two remaining universities, Königsberg or Frankfurt-an-der-Oder, were regarded as suitable as the central Prussian seat of learning. In September 1807 the king agreed to the creation of a new university in Berlin and on 16 August 1809 he pledged an annual sum of 150,000 thalers and donated the beautiful Prince Henry’s Palace on Unter den Linden to the new university. The Humboldt brothers now travelled throughout Germany recruiting for the faculty, and the list of luminaries they attracted was impressive – the first rector was the famous professor of jurisprudence, Schmalz, while the first elected rector was the philosopher Fichte. The university could soon boast Schleiermacher and De Wette in theology, Friedländer, Hufeland, Reil and Holrausch in medicine, Wolf, Buttman, Rühs and Niebuhr in history, Tralles in mathematics (Gauss turned down the offer), Savigny in law, Oltmanns in astronomy and a host of other prominent intellectuals of the day.17 The university opened on 15 October 1810 and the first work published was Niebuhr’s Roman History. It quickly became a central feature of Berlin life and a magnet for leading German intellectuals, many of whom, from the Humboldts to Fichte, from the Grimm brothers to Schelling, from Hegel to Ranke, would leave an indelible mark on German intellectual life.18
It was here that the concept of Bildung and of Wissenschaft (knowledge) evolved into a movement which would sweep nineteenth-century Germany and Europe. The student was not to focus on a specific subject or learn a practical profession through repeating a restricted programme, but was to learn how to be curious, how to explore new subjects and to pursue knowledge for its own sake. Berlin University became something of a temple to knowledge, and its professors were treated with reverence not because of their birth, but because they embodied the classical ideal of the educated man. The magnanimous Humboldt was perfectly serious when he said that it was ‘no less useless for the carpenter to have learned Greek than it is for the scholar to make tables’. Berlin came closer to achieving his ideal of a free classical education for all in the first half of the nineteenth century than at any time since.19
The other institution to undergo reform was the military. For centuries the Prussian army had been a state within a state, living in a world of its own with its own police, its own codes of conduct, its own church, and with virtually no links to civil society. Prussians had been amazed to see French soldiers march into their country, fired up with patriotism and nationalistic pride. The introduction of conscription in 1792 had not only created an endless supply of recruits, it had also unified the nation and the army. The French soldier was not a sujet harangued and beaten like his Prussian counterpart; he was a citoyen. The French military, it was said, was the French people in uniform. The reformers in Prussia hoped that if they could harness the will of the people in a similar way they could provoke a national uprising and rid Prussia of the French occupiers.
The main reformers, including Gneisenau, Boyen and Count Götzen, were brought together in Hardenberg’s Military Organization Commission, but the most influential of all was General Scharnhorst, whose story mirrors the revolutionary nature of his times. In any previous era this boy of peasant stock would have been barred from a military career but he lived in a revolutionary age. As a young man he entered military school in Hanover and his brilliant strategic mind soon brought him to the attention of his superiors. He moved to Prussia where he entered the service and, although he was constantly put down by men – including General Yorck – for being a commoner, his lectures were recognized for their brilliance. Scharnhorst was eventually ennobled. His influence cannot be underestimated; Arndt called him the ‘greatest of the reformers’ while Clausewitz called him the ‘father of my mind’.20
The military reforms were radical and reflected Scharnhorst’s meritocratic views. In 1807 he dismissed 208 woolly-minded officers and replaced them with professionals; he opened the army to commoners; he dissolved the old cadet schools; he set up new institutes, including the Berlin Academy, and abolished the infamous and degrading punishments so characteristic of the Prussian military. More revolutionary still was Scharnhorst’s idea of the creation of a new force, a militia called the Landwehr. Napoleon had limited the Prussian army to 43,000 troops but Scharnhorst quietly sent soldiers on leave every month and replaced them with new recruits, building up a secret reserve which would ultimately enable Prussia to raise 280,000 men. On 17 March 1808 Napoleon permitted the creation of the Landwehr for all men between seventeen and forty not in the regular army, and in April allowed the Landsturm for all those capable of auxiliary work. Napoleon had assumed that they would be cannon fodder for his own armies; in fact they would eventually fight against France in the Wars of Liberation.
Given the pervading climate it is not surprising that Biedermeier Berlin produced little art of note. Sadly many of the great artists who had been drawn to the city during the heady days of the Romantic period now found their careers blocked. Felix Mendelssohn, who in 1820 had re-introduced Bach’s St Matthew Passion to Berlin and who should have succeeded to the directorship of the Singakademie, was passed over for the dull Karl Friedrich Rungenhagen. Carl Maria von Weber, who had inaugurated Romantic opera with the première of Der Freischütz in 1821, was rejected by the court composer Gaspare Spontini and moved to Dresden: the Berliner Giacomo Meyerbeer was forced to leave for lack of work and was only offered the position of director of the Opera in 1842 under Frederick William IV; Hector Berlioz and Richard Wagner both spent time in Berlin but were disappointed by its repressive atmosphere and moved elsewhere. Even the great sculptor and artist Johann Gottfried Schadow, who had created the Quadriga and who had been so scathing about the French occupation of Berlin, received no more commissions in his own city. He was superseded by the more solid Christian Daniel Rauch, who completed the great equestrian statue of Frederick the Great and had statues of the successful generals of the Napoleonic Wars – Blücher, Yorck, Gneisenau, Scharnhorst and Bülow – lined up along Unter den Linden. But Berlin still failed to impress. When Pastor Karl Philipp Moritz first saw London he exclaimed: ‘How great had seemed Berlin to me when I saw it from the tower of St Mary’s and looked down on it from the hill at Tempelhof … how insignificant it now seemed when I set it in my imagination against London!’67 The only field in which Biedermeier excelled and served to change the spartan view of Berlin was in architecture. This was largely thanks to the gift of one man, Karl Friedrich Schinkel.68
In 1826 the Viennese writer and friend of Beethoven’s, Franz Grillparzer, journeyed to Berlin in one of the new post coaches: ‘Finally the towers of Berlin,’ he wrote. ‘Through the gates. Beautiful. The collection of buildings more beautiful than I have seen together. The streets wide. Kingly.’69 Such praise was rare before the arrival of Schinkel, the greatest German architect of the nineteenth century. It was he who, over the space of a long and dynamic career, transformed central Berlin, giving the city centre a unified feel with his elegant neo-classical buildings in the ‘Prussian style’. Schinkel gave form to Unter den Linden, the Platz der Akademie, the Lustgarten and, with Lenné, the Tiergarten. If, as it is said, the first Roman emperor ‘found a city of brick and left it marble’, Schinkel found a city of wood and left it brick. But much of Schinkel’s brick was covered with plaster, swathed in marble and surrounded by columns of Saxon sandstone, sculptures and elaborate wrought iron. His gifts ranged from interior and set design – he created fabulous iron furniture, was one of the first to do lithographs, and designed the magnificent star-studded set for the Queen of the Night in Mozart’s The Magic Flute – to draughtsmanship and painting. But Schinkel’s career also reflected the triumph of reaction in Berlin. He had started out as an ardent Prussian reformer but, like so many of his generation, had retreated from political life after the disappointment following the Wars of Liberation. Instead he became a pillar of the establishment in the apolitical and naive world of Biedermeier Berlin.
Schinkel’s life spanned the era from the end of absolutism to the end of the Biedermeier years. He was born in 1781 in the little garrison town of Neurippen to the north of Berlin. It was a time of extraordinary change. By the time the family moved to Berlin in 1794 Kant had published The Critique of Pure Reason, Frederick the Great had died, and the ideas of the French Revolution were reverberating across Europe. The young Karl was sent to school at the famous Graue Kloster but in 1797 decided to become an architect after seeing Friedrich Gilly’s plans for a vast monument to Frederick the Great. He studied with Gilly and was given his first commission – a garden pavilion – in 1806. The revolution and ensuing turmoil had a powerful influence both on his personal and professional life. Schinkel watched from his rooms on the Alexanderplatz as French troops marched into Berlin in 1806 and like many of his contemporaries he was roused into a patriotic fervour by Fichte’s 1807 Addresses to the German Nation. He joined the Berlin Romantic literary circle and was befriended by Achim and Bettina von Arnim, Clemens von Brentano, Karl von Savigny and others; like many of them he volunteered to serve in the Prussian Landsturm after the declaration of war on France. Schinkel’s ardent patriotism was reflected in his work. By 1805 he had already designed a monument to Martin Luther; he would soon create sets for Undine and Faust and planned to illustrate Brentano’s fairy tales. His paintings, like the melancholy Bohemian Mountain Range at Sunset, were executed in the high Romantic style and were clearly influenced by Caspar David Friedrich’s lonely landscapes which he saw exhibited in Berlin in 1810. During the occupation he painted large dioramas of historic scenes to bolster public morale and in 1812 exhibited the vast Burning of Moscow to emphasize Russian fighting spirit against the Grande Armée: it showed thick brown clouds of smoke billowing over Moscow and the people stoically walking away as the French moved up towards the high towers of the Kremlin.
Schinkel’s patriotic service continued after the defeat of Napoleon. He designed the decorations which streamed from the Brandenburg Gate for the victory parade in 1814 and he helped to organize the great exhibition of war booty returned to Berlin from Paris. He produced a medal for Blücher showing the great general as Hercules in a lionskin on one side and St Michael defeating Satan – a reference to Napoleon – on the other. He designed the Iron Cross – and created the Pickelhaube or pointed helmet, which would later become the very symbol of Prussian militarism. Above all, his patriotism was reflected in his architecture, and in his use of the ‘national style’ – Gothic. Schinkel believed that Gothic architecture represented Romanticism, eternal Christianity, the lost Germany of the Middle Ages, even the ‘German soul’. The Gothic style provided a model for the development of Prussia and embodied the call for liberty and freedom, for reform and for the creation of a unified German state. Most of his early plans were in this style. When Queen Luise died in 1810 Schinkel submitted to the king drawings for a memorial chapel complete with guardian angels, high arches and tracery windows meant to evoke the very entrance to paradise. After the war he designed a vast Liberation Fountain, which had the Germanic chieftain Hermann rearing up on his horse and holding a spear to the belly of the fallen Roman Quintilius Varus who, weighed down by his imperial armour, bore a striking likeness to Napoleon. He designed a great Gothic cathedral to commemorate the Wars of Liberation and submitted plans for the rebuilding of the Petrikirche. But none of these huge projects was ever built. The reasons were political.
During the Napoleonic period Frederick William III had appeared to support the reformers, the German nationalists, the volunteers for the Landsturm, and the liberals who wanted political change, but with the defeat of France he quickly reverted to his old ways. Calls for political reform, for a unified Germany, for a constitution and for a representative government were now considered subversive and dangerous and the Gothic style was intrinsically linked to them. As such, it fell out of favour. Instead, the king now preferred buildings which gave an air of stability and safety, above all those designed in the neo-classical style.
Schinkel’s work was greatly affected by this change in royal preference. Frederick William III chose a Doric mausoleum over a Gothic tomb for his wife and halted plans for the great Gothic cathedral in Berlin because of a lack of funds. Schinkel had to make do with the cast iron Gothic monument in Kreuzberg created under the direction of Major von Reiche, the nephew of the eminent general ennobled after Waterloo, and although the crown prince commissioned a number of small Gothic monuments they did not amount to much. By 1820 Schinkel had been forced to abandon the Gothic in favour of classicism. Some saw this as tantamount to a betrayal of the fight for German unity, but despite his love for medieval architecture Schinkel wanted above all to build. For over a decade his most important work would reflect the needs of the reactionary Prussian state.
To be fair Schinkel did not see the two styles as mutually exclusive. Other artists, from Beethoven to Hölderlin to Möricke – and even Goethe in Faust – had mixed elements of Romanticism and neo-classicism and Schinkel convinced himself that educating people about the values of ancient Greece was the next best thing to evoking the spirit of medieval Germany. For him Greek architecture had been the product of a harmonious, integrated and free society which could be seen as a model for Prussia – ‘the most felicitous state of freedom within the law’. And art and culture were the key: beautiful buildings could, in Schinkel’s words, ‘ennoble all human relations’. But the view epitomized the problem of the Biedermeier world. It was naive to think that the creation of buildings and paintings and sculpture could somehow educate the people in democratic principles. Schinkel had convinced himself that his buildings were somehow ‘liberating’ Berlin. On the contrary he was legitimating the rule of one of the most reactionary regimes in Europe.
Schinkel’s career as an architect began in earnest in 1818, four years after the Congress of Vienna, with the completion of his first great commission – the Neue Wache or New Guard House. It was a small monument to Prussia’s victorious army. Built in the shape of a Roman castrum with a Doric portico of six simple columns it remains the most striking monument on Unter den Linden. The king liked it and it led to new commissions. Within the next two decades Schinkel touched virtually every corner of the city centre, converting the baroque cathedral across from the Schloss, planning the Lustgarten, creating the Schlossbrücke, building the Schauspielhaus or theatre, which opened in 1824, and a number of private houses and palaces, including a residence for Prince William on Unter den Linden and the Palais Redern on Pariser Platz, and drawing up plans for everything from a new library to gatehouses for the Potsdamer Platz. In a letter to Sulpice Boissiére in 1822 he said he hoped his work would create ‘beauty in itself and for the city’.70
His crowning work in the neo-classical style, and the building which he considered his greatest work, was the Altes Museum, which was completed in 1830. It remains a great Berlin landmark. From the outside it looms like a vast Greek stoa with its grand row of eighteen Ionic columns marching in perfect symmetry across the northern end of the Lustgarten. The vast rotunda, modelled on the Pantheon in Rome, is hidden from view from the outside and comes as a marvellous surprise to the visitor. Schinkel intended the rotunda to be a temple to art and culture; a sanctuary where ‘the sight of a beautiful and sublime room must make the visitor receptive and create the proper mood for the enjoyment and acknowledgement of what the building contains’.71 After studying the exhibits the visitor could leave via the Treppenhaus, which connected the museum-temple to the busy secular world of Berlin. The position was vital. The museum was placed across from the Royal Palace, flanked by the arsenal and the cathedral, and next to the Stock Exchange and the Neue Packhof or New Customs House, which was completed in 1832. By placing it here Schinkel was trying to prove that art could fit into the civil order and to demonstrate that culture was indeed equal to the pillars of Prussian society represented by the military, the monarchy, the Church and the new emerging power of industry. It was an absurd delusion. Art was not as powerful as the rival institutions and never would be. When Robert Smirke designed the British Museum in 1824 it was placed miles from Whitehall and St Paul’s and the City, and the English would have thought it absurd that culture could be seen as a rival to parliament or the military or industry in the running of their country. Schinkel’s notion that culture was a substitute for political action was typical of Biedermeier Berlin. However beautiful his symmetrical, clear, austere neo-classical buildings, he had come to mirror that fatal tendency in the Berlin educated middle class: the belief that they could influence politics through culture.
What Schinkel did not seem to recognize was that far from being a political activist he had in fact become a pillar of the Prussian establishment. He was a trusted public servant and in 1838 was considered reliable enough to be elevated to the highest office of public works in Prussia. The sheer number of commissions and projects which came to him through the royal family made him the most famous architect in Prussia, but he was a court architect in all but name. His claims to be leading Prussians to a better, more democratic world through his architecture and his art rang increasingly hollow.
In many ways the Altes Museum heralded the end of pedagogic architecture in Berlin and by the time it was finished the Biedermeier world was beginning to crumble. Even Schinkel foreshadowed the change and in the last decade of his life began to explore other forms of architecture by developing an ahistorical functional style inspired in part by British industrial architecture.72 His new designs included plans for a shopping bazaar on Unter den Linden and the surprisingly modern purple brick Bauakademie, so wantonly destroyed by the East Germans after the Second World War. His late works hinted at a new age to come, when the edifying public buildings of the past would make way for hotels, factories, department stores and train stations, built not to educate or to ennoble the public, but to facilitate trade and commerce.73
By the time Schinkel died in 1840 many of those excluded from the Prussian elite were growing increasingly angry at the censorship and repression which still characterized Berlin. If Schinkel had renounced the fervent nationalism and politics of his youth there were many in Berlin who had not, and the work of those in exile was finding its way back to the city. Groups of reform-minded individuals were forming political groups disguised as poetry clubs, literary circles and music societies to defy the ban on the fledgling political parties; works written during the Napoleonic occupation were rediscovered; the longing for national unity was growing stronger. However civilized and sedate the Biedermeier years had been, however gracious Schinkel’s neo-classical masterpieces had appeared, they had represented the artificial calm of a middle class shielded from the political realities of the day. Heinrich Heine was suspicious of the new elegant city with its ‘long stretches of uniform houses, the long wide streets … but with no care given to the opinion of the masses.’74 In his famous lines he foreshadowed things to come: ‘Berlin, Berlin, great city of misery! In you, there is nothing to find but anguish and martyrdom … They respect rights as if they were candles.’75 Biedermeier, and all it stood for, was set to come to a sudden and violent end in the revolutionary year of 1848.
IV From Revolution to Realpolitik
Needs must, when the Devil drives!
Business and duty rule our lives.
(Faust, Part I)
BY THE LATE 1820s the absolutist systems bolstered by the Congress of Vienna were starting to break down. Europe was changing. Its population was growing, industrialization was bringing social and economic change and people were becoming increasingly impatient with the outmoded system which blocked any chance of reform. In Germany young men who had been exhilarated by their experiences in the Wars of Liberation resented retreating to a dull, stifling world. Artists and writers and ex-soldiers fuelled the Young Germany movement led by Karl Gutzkow and Heinrich Laube, who in turn introduced themes of rebellion and emancipation in their Zeitromanen (novels of the times). New oppositional poets and songwriters, including Hoffmann von Fallersleben (who wrote the German national anthem but lost his job because of his political views), Georg Herwegh and Ferdinand Freiligrath (both of whom were sent into exile), and the continuing influence of Heinrich Heine, began to challenge the status quo.1 The students in the Burschenschaften dressed themselves in medieval clothes, grew long hair and beards, and gathered secretly in old ruins to reaffirm their calls for a unified German fatherland. Then, in the 1830s, revolutions began to erupt all over Europe. News of the fall of the Bourbons in France in 1830 raised hopes that the period of reaction might soon be at an end. The Belgians began to fight for independence from the Dutch, while Poland rose up and fought for independence against Russia. The Polish insurrection was particularly important in Berlin. It lasted nearly a year and despite the fact that the Prussian king backed the tsar’s brutal repression, there was much sympathy for the victims in the city itself. Thousands of Poles found sanctuary in Berlin and were championed by the population; Harro Harring wrote Freedom’s Salvation in their honour and Richard Wagner, then in Leipzig, wrote: ‘The victories achieved by the Poles during a short period in May of 1831 aroused my ecstatic admiration: it seemed to me as if the world had been created anew by some miracle.’2 Two years later while staying in Berlin he wrote the overture Polonia and Berlin salons were now filled with music by Chopin and the rousing poetry of Mickiewicz.3
Then in May 1832 German students organized the Hambach Festival: 20,000 liberal supporters gathered with black, red and gold banners to honour the new political spirit of the age. In Berlin despite constant repression intellectuals again began to call openly for German unity; Dahlmann wrote that the civil service should be open to all, and others called for a representative government. When William Jacob visited Berlin in 1819 he had noted that liberals there seemed uncertain of their goals, but by the mid-1830s a coherent set of calls for political reform found expression.4 Some merely wanted to lift the most repressive censorship laws; others wanted to challenge the power of the aristocracy and the military, but for most the underlying hope was that Germany could unify as a nation state based on the rule of law – a state which would represent the common will. Liberals demanded basic rights: freedom of expression, of association, of right to property and education; they wanted to retain the monarchy but have participation of the nation in government. For them the people – the Volk – did not mean the masses but rather an educated elite; universal suffrage was still considered a dangerous idea best left to the radical democrats. But nationalism was a powerful force; the idea of the Kulturnation and the liberal idea of the Staatsnation had begun to fuse, and when the French demanded the Rhine as a frontier in 1840 Germans reacted in a wave of patriotism.5 Nikolaus Becker’s Rheinlied became a hit with the lines ‘They shall not have it, the free German Rhine’. Die Wacht am Rhein (Watch on the Rhine) was heard everywhere, as was Hoffmann von Fallersleben’s Deutschlandlied, now the German national anthem, whose sentiments, like Verdi’s Nabucco in Italy, mirrored the longing for unity. Far from being an aggressive song of conquest it called for people to forget their petty differences and put a united ‘Germany, Germany above all’.
The political changes were reflected in many aspects of culture. Berliners now wanted to discuss politics, to be active, to have news from other nationalist groups in the rest of Germany. This thirst for information contributed to the sharp rise in the number of newspapers. The first liberal newspapers to break through the censorship of the Metternich era had to be smuggled into the city from other German states. Oppositional publications founded by Young Hegelians and Young Germany – including Görres’s Rheinischer Merkur and the Rheinische Zeitung edited by Karl Marx – were under constant threat; Görres was forced into exile in 1827 and Marx’s paper was banned in 1843. In 1846 the liberal Deutsche Zeitung was founded in Heidelberg to cover not a single region, but the whole of Germany. Berlin also produced publications of its own, including the Vossische Zeitung whose circulation doubled to 20,000 between 1840 and 1848; it was also home to conservative papers like the 1831 Politische Wochenblatt, and the Neue Preussische Zeitung, known as the ‘Cross Newspaper’ because of the Iron Cross on its front page.6 The cutting, satirical magazine Kladderadatsch was started in 1848 and had reached a circulation of 39,000 by 1860. By 1862 Berlin would publish fifty-eight weekly papers and thirty-two dailies.
Newspapers were not the only means of spreading information in the era of repression. The university was still a centre of independent thought; Hegel, the champion of the state, held a chair of philosophy at the university from 1817 and his influence was already widespread. Literary societies and educational groups, choral and gymnastic festivals, shooting matches and poetry groups were increasingly used as covers for political meetings, and liberalism flourished in the German coffee houses and Konditereien of Berlin like Josty, Spargnapani and Stehely. Literary societies like the 1824 Mittwochsgesellschaft (Wednesday Society) or its rival Der Tunnel über der Spree, founded by Moritz Saphir in 1827, and newspaper reading rooms like that started by Gustav Julius, provided places where people could meet in relative safety to discuss the works of Hegel, Heine, Ludwig Börne and later Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels.7 Despite police controls increasing numbers of periodicals, pamphlets and cartoons appeared which were critical of the government. Finally, there was a flurry of excitement in liberal circles in 1840 when the repressive king died and was succeeded by his son Frederick William IV. This, they hoped, was the chance for reform they had been waiting for.
King Frederick William IV came to the throne on a wave of optimism in the city. He was a humane man and seemed to espouse liberal ideas; indeed one of his first acts was to free political prisoners and to appoint the liberal heroes, the brothers J. and W. Grimm, Savigny, Schelling and Tieck, who had been turfed out of Göttingen by the king of Hanover, to professorships at Berlin University.8 Unlike his father he loved the grandiose neo-Gothic architecture then coming into vogue and hoped to build an enormous national cathedral on the banks of the Spree. He loved ceremony and colour and show and used Berlin as a personal parade ground, holding mock manoeuvres and even mistakenly blasting out windows with his cannon. Despite his liberal tendencies, he was first and foremost the king of Prussia. He liked the appearance of freedom and he genuinely wanted to be liked, but he refused to accept any diminution of his power. Frederick William IV was an impulsive man who could be kind and charming one minute and violent and brutal the next; this neurosis ultimately ended in mental collapse. As one observer put it, his people were like an animal on a long string; he liked them to enjoy ‘freedom’ and was distressed if they hurt themselves by pulling on it, but he still would not cut the string. After a short period of grace he once again began to oppress those intent on reform.
There was widespread disappointment in Berlin when it became clear there would be nothing but cosmetic change. Once again people began to be prosecuted for minor infringements: Johann Jacoby, a regular at the liberal Siegel’s Konditorei, was arrested in February 1841 for publishing a pamphlet called Vier Fragen (Four Questions), which was mildly critical of the government. But Berlin was heating up. The Industrial Revolution was finally reaching the city, its population was growing and social problems like destitution, homelessness, rising disease and crime rates were putting pressure on the old system. The problem was made worse by a simmering economic crisis in the east which resulted in the 1844 revolt of the Silesian weavers and the famine in Silesia and East Prussia of 1847. When the new king refused all demands for fundamental reform the frustration amongst the intellectual elite and the political classes increased. They could never have started a revolution on their own – Berlin was no Paris or Warsaw or Vienna. But revolution was coming. Once again, the spark was ignited in France.
The turbulent year of European revolution started in Paris on 22 February 1848. The bourgeois king Louis-Philippe had infuriated the populace by prohibiting a banquet which had been planned in order to raise money for reforms. Within hours students, workers and the national guard were raging through the streets of Paris demanding an end to political repression. The king was forced to flee and France was declared a republic. News of the triumph spread rapidly through Europe: the patriotic movement had begun in Italy and the writer Massimo d’Azeglio proclaimed the ‘principle of open conspiracy’; Garibaldi was forced out of the country. The wave of violence spread east. The first uprisings in Baden and Saxony saw demonstrators demanding freedom of assembly and of the press, trial by jury and the creation of a people’s militia. Unrest spread rapidly through the rest of Germany and people used petitions, strikes, demonstrations and the fear of revolution to extract political reforms from the terrified rulers.9 By March Berlin was a tinderbox ready to explode. Berliners now gathered daily at the Zelten in the Tiergarten to hear speeches, read pamphlets and sign petitions for change.10 Then, on 13 March, the news broke that the revolution had reached Vienna and that the architect of the hated Carlsbad decrees, Metternich, had been forced to flee to England hidden in a laundry basket; Frederick William IV was convinced he had to act quickly to avoid the same fate. On the evening of 17 March he drafted a series of political reforms in order to appease his people. He also appointed the hard-line General von Prittwitz as military commander of Berlin.11
Sunday 18 March 1848 dawned peacefully in the city. A large crowd, including radicals, students, craftsmen and apprentices, gathered at the palace to hear the king speak; most were unarmed, although workers from the Borsig factory had brought axes with them. The municipal authorities had agreed to admit a deputation demanding a modern constitution, freedom of speech and of the press, the right of citizens to bear arms and the withdrawal of troops from Berlin. The group of representatives was received by the king that morning but was surprised to learn that he had already passed a law which granted freedom of the press, abolished censorship, called for a united Diet and the reorganization of the German federal constitution, and that he had drafted a modest constitution for Prussia itself. However, he had said nothing about withdrawal of the troops.12
Berlin was still very much a military city but the oppressive presence of a disproportionate number of soldiers had long been a source of friction between Berliners and the government. The people were tired of barracks and parade grounds and abusive officers in their midst; after the Napoleonic Wars they had demanded a military which represented the people – a people’s militia. They had a point. On that March day there were more than 20,000 troops on the streets, many of whom stood and jeered at the civilians in front of the palace. None of the citizens had guns nor any intention of fighting the Berlin garrison; they cheered the king when he appeared to announce the reforms. But when the speech ended, and still nothing had been said about the military, people began to chant: ‘Withdraw the troops! Withdraw the troops!’ The king was horrified.
Frederick William was willing to introduce some reforms but the call to banish the military challenged the very legitimacy of the Prussian monarch. In his eyes it amounted to a call for the king to renounce the very power on which his authority had rested since the Thirty Years War.13 He did not respond; indeed, in an attempt to appease the army he told the cavalry to ‘clean up’ the palace square. The order was misunderstood. Rather than simply clearing the area the troops began to ride towards the crowd brandishing their swords and pushing the people back into the side streets; Major von Falkenstein chased one group to the Breitestrasse while a second was pushed towards the Lange Brücke. Suddenly two rifle shots rang out. These were probably accidental but the crowd thought that the troops had opened fire. Cries of ‘Assassins!’ rang through the air and the people began to fight back. The army opened fire in earnest amidst screams from the public. The revolution in Berlin had begun.
Within minutes barricades were being put up throughout the city centre. The first, made out of two hackney coaches, an overturned carriage, the sentry box from the front of a bank and some old barrels, was constructed at the corner of Oberwallstrasse and Jägerstrasse. The barricade in Friedrichstrasse was made out of Mother Schmiddecke’s fruit stall; and the biggest of all, at the corner of Königstrasse on the Alexanderplatz, was put together out of blocks of granite. Republicans and socialists manned the barricades with students, craftsmen, workers, liberal intellectuals and destitute migrants from the east. Some had firearms but most were armed with makeshift weapons like pitchforks and bricks; a small brass cannon had also been found and loaded with marbles. The king refused to speak to the people, further increasing suspicions that he had been behind the order to shoot. Fighting intensified throughout the afternoon. Fierce battles were raging by nightfall.14 The violence was made worse by rumours that the military were tying prisoners in cellars and beating them with rifle butts. Berlin was ablaze; the artillery sheds at the Oranienburg Gate and the iron foundry went up in flames and all the customs houses were burning. Citizen Hesse took the reservist arsenal in Lindenstrasse and distributed weapons while women and children pelted the troops from windows and rooftops with paving stones and tiles. Over 230 people were killed in the fighting on the night of 18 March. The king feared a civil war. On 19 March, to the fury of the military, he ordered the troops to stop firing. In a dramatic gesture he rode up to the barricades and through the city draped in a flag bearing the black, red and gold colours of the revolution, and followed this with the famous speech ‘To my dear Berliners’, in which he called for the cessation of violence and the removal of the barricades in the ‘true old Berlin spirit’ of reconciliation. Negotiations began at the palace. This time, when the citizens demanded the withdrawal of troops from Berlin, the king obliged. He also promised a national assembly to debate the draft for a constitution and promised to find a solution to the national question.15
The new Stock Exchange was closely linked to the industrial transformation and between 1851 and 1857 119 joint stock companies were founded in Prussia. In its second year the Berlin Stock Exchange reported a ‘very considerable and lively turnover in stocks and shares in internal and foreign accounts and for investment and speculation purposes’.64 Berlin trading was heaviest in commodities such as grain, coal and iron, but money was soon needed for growth in industries from metalwork to textiles. The resources of the propertied classes were restricted and financing with one’s own credit and capital was risky, so even in the 1850s entrepreneurs were going to the public to collect capital assets and use them to finance their new projects. The share quickly became a fashionable object in Berlin, a status symbol and topic of polite conversation amongst the very new members of the middle class. The money generated by industry helped to fuel investment, and Berlin found itself in a seemingly endless upward spiral of growth and prosperity. The immensely optimistic newly rich middle class began to change the social face of the city, and the late nineteenth century was to become the golden age of the Besitzbürgertum.
These propertied middle classes initially consisted of self-made men, often the sons of craftsmen or skilled labourers like Borsig or professionals like Siemens who had, through skill and sheer hard work, made fortunes for themselves in the new industries. These men could not aspire to ennoblement and instead worked towards non-hereditary titles and conferments which became highly coveted until well into the 1890s. Receiving the title of Kommerzienrat or Privy Councillor meant that a businessman had ‘arrived’; a title could greatly enhance the standing of the recipient’s business and substantially improve its credit rating. The titles were granted by the king on the recommendation of the Minister of Commerce and holders were nominated by public figures, noblemen, municipal corporations or dignitaries; sons sometimes recommended their fathers in connection with some business jubilee. At least until 1886 a candidate had to pass through a rigorous selection procedure. He had to own or be part owner of a successful enterprise and be active in its management; he might have developed a new branch of industry or enhanced Prussia’s business reputation abroad; he should have done charitable or Church or municipal government work; he had to have good labour relations in his factories, and he had to be considered a ‘notable’ and play a prominent public role. In Berlin a candidate required a minimum personal fortune of 1 million marks, although candidates from the provinces needed half that much. The political restrictions were made very clear: the candidate had to be ‘politically reliable’ – support for the liberals was a tremendous handicap which had to be compensated for by other qualifications; opposition to government made it very difficult for one to get a title and liberal activists and active supporters of the Fortschrittspartei (Progress party) were barred without question.65
The preferments were something of a meritocracy in the otherwise class-and code-ridden city, and one measure of this was the large number of titles granted to Jewish businessmen. The later tragedy of the Holocaust was particularly difficult to accept in a city which rose to prominence largely because of its entrepreneurial Jewish population; indeed without the input of these Jews the city would never have reached the economic and financial heights of the nineteenth century. Unlike areas such as the Ruhr, where most title holders were Gentiles, over 40 per cent of those in Berlin were Jewish and it was estimated that about half the economic activity in the city was generated by Jewish businessmen.66 Their success attracted more Jews to the city so that by the 1870s 80 per cent of Prussian Jews had moved to Berlin. The Jews were important in industries and services centred there; whereas Gentile millionaires tended to be in the coal, iron, steel, metallurgy and machine-building industries, Jews were particularly successful in banking, manufacturing and trade, all of which were highly represented in the Prussian capital. Berlin industrial history was shaped by important Jewish families not only in banking and finance but, like the Reichenbeims and Goldschmidts, also in clothing; the silk manufacturers the Meyers had royal patronage; the Liebermanns were an old trading family which made a fortune in calico and pioneered the use of mechanical manufacturing. Jews were also prominent in brewing and distilling and all the service industries. Thanks to the capital generated there economic decision-making came to be concentrated in Berlin, at the expense of Frank-furt-am-Main, Cologne, Hamburg and other older centres. Berlin was never free of anti-Semitism but Jews were given more freedom and were increasingly seen as important and respected members of mid nineteenth-century Berlin society. One measure of this acceptance was the increase in official recognition of their contribution in the form of orders which gave them a seal of respectability in the Gentile world. The fact that a candidate for honours like the Geheimer Kommerzienrat was Jewish was mentioned in the confidential reports as a minor flaw but not insurmountable as long as he showed Christian or patriotic ‘virtues’ – to be a liberal or even a Catholic was often seen as a more serious hurdle to advancement. One report stated that ‘the candidate, although Jewish, employed in his office mainly Christian clerks’ or ‘although a Jew, he has always acted in a Christian spirit’; of another, ‘it is precisely because he is a Jew and a traditional liberal, but in times of need a generous patriot, that his appointment would be generally welcomed’.67 It was only in the final quarter of the century, when racial anti-Semitism was on the rise, that such recommendations became rare. Ironically one of the triggers would be jealousy of increasing Jewish wealth and success which Berliners themselves had championed in the mid nineteenth century.
The economic rise of Berlin throughout the nineteenth century is one of the most remarkable success stories in history, made all the more dramatic given the depths to which it had fallen under Napoleon. In the early part of the century Berlin had been an economic backwater languishing on the edge of western Europe; when Napoleon marched in it had only one steam engine in the Royal Porcelain Works, and even that did not work. Compared with the new English industrial cities like Birmingham and Manchester Berlin was little more than a village and, locked as it was in the midst of a sandy wasteland, seemed an unnatural place for an economic giant. And yet, within decades, it had become the mightiest industrial capital on the continent. No European city rose from obscurity so quickly, and none would be so drunk on its success. By the end of the century Berlin had mushroomed at a breathtaking pace and had outstripped its formidable rivals, Paris and London, in industrial output. The population growth was staggering: in 1800 it stood at 915,000; by 1890 it had shot up to 2 million, and by 1914 it would be nearly 4 million, making it the largest city in Europe. Berlin’s transformation was due to an explosive combination of factors which included the importance derived from its role as the Prussian capital, the coming of the railway, Otto von Bismarck’s early support of the Zollverein, and the new breed of Berlin entrepreneur determined to put his city on the map.
But despite its success it was not a city at ease with itself. Political reforms were non-existent, social reforms were grudgingly introduced, and all this at a time when hundreds of thousands of people were moving to the city to fill the new factories and the tenement blocks. They would become part of a force so powerful that by the end of the century Berlin would act both as the conservative capital of Germany, and the centre of the German working-class movement – the ‘other’ part of the city known as ‘Red Berlin’.
V The Rise of Red Berlin
God help the poor.
(Faust, Part I)
ON A DAMP AFTERNOON in October 1836 a black and yellow postal coach pulled into Berlin and a young student stepped out on to the pavement. He had just written a short verse to his beloved in Bonn: ‘The two skies. On the journey to Berlin in a carriage. The mountains pass, the forests recede. Gone from sight they leave no trace behind.’1 It was not a promising start. After finding rooms in Lessing’s old house in the Mittelstrasse (with ‘cultured people’) the gaunt man, his face adorned by a rather unsuccessful moustache and wispy beard, set off to register at the university. Had he remained in the Rhineland the world might have been spared a great deal of turmoil and bloodshed, but his experiences in Berlin would redirect his career and change him from a drunken, duelling provincial student into the creator of scientific socialism and the driving force behind the international Communist movement. Berliners can be forgiven for ignoring the arrival of Karl Heinrich Marx, forced to Berlin by a father tired of his loutish behaviour in Bonn, but they would hear of him soon enough.2 And Marx was only one of the litany of Communist saints who would be drawn to this burgeoning industrial city; Friedrich Engels, Ferdinand Lassalle, August Bebel, Karl Liebknecht, Karl Radek, Rosa Luxemburg and even Lenin, who visited twelve times and who later slid through Germany on his way to lead the Russian Revolution, would be drawn to the new centre of the European working-class movement. Between Marx’s arrival and the end of the First World War the sprawling industrial city became known as ‘Red Berlin’, a powerful symbol lionized by the left and feared, even loathed, by just about everybody else.
When Marx first arrived in Berlin he found a city charged with pre-revolutionary tension. He threw himself into the radical circles at the university, joined the Doktorklub, a group of earnest young men who met over coffee and the eighty newspapers of the reading room of the Café Stehely, and was inspired by the latest works by the Young Germans like Heinrich Heine, Ludwig Börne, Karl Gutzkow and Theodor Mondt.3 But above all it was in Berlin that the young Marx came into contact with the works of Berlin’s most prominent philosopher: Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel.4
‘Only one man understands me,’ Hegel muttered towards the end of his life, ‘and even he does not.’5 The complaint was widespread; Hegel’s cryptic style, coupled with the fact that many of his works were published from lecture notes, added to the difficulty in deciphering his already obscure and abstract writing. Schopenhauer would call Hegel’s work ‘pure nonsense’ created by ‘stringing together senseless and extravagant mazes of words, such as had previously been known only in madhouses’, which had resulted in the ‘most bare faced general mystification that has ever taken place … and will remain as a monument to German stupidity’.6 It did not help that Hegel had attempted nothing less than the placement of all human knowledge into a coherent philosophy of history. Despite the savage criticism his work was, in Engels’s words, a ‘triumphal procession which lasted for decades’ and was later used to legitimate two of the most influential – and mutually exclusive – developments in history: the rise of chauvinistic Prussian nationalism, and the creation of scientific socialism. Hegel would be given the dubious honour of being invoked both by William II and by Marx.
Hegel was born in Stuttgart in 1770 and struggled for many years as a poor and unknown lecturer, confiding in his friend Schlegel that he had often gone hungry. His house at Jena was stormed by Napoleon’s soldiers and he barely managed to survive while in Nuremberg and Heidelberg, but by the time he reached Berlin in 1818 he had become the well-known author of Logic and the Encyclopaedia of the Philosophical Sciences and his birthday was jointly celebrated with that of the other icon of the fledgling German nation – Goethe.
Hegel was above all a product of his age. Golo Mann has said of him: ‘What Napoleon was to the political history of the period Hegel was to its intellectual history.’7 One sees in his work the desperate search for answers to the political turmoil which had ripped apart the Europe of his youth. For Hegel, the most important aspect of existence was the notion that everything – every idea and every situation – must always change, be torn down, and give rise to its opposite. If there is peace there will be war and, although this will result in violence and pain and bloodshed, eventually the warring parties will come to some reconciliation which will form a ‘higher stage’, a greater whole. The new status quo would not last either – it too would spawn its opposite, and the same process would be repeated again and again. This was the dialectic which swung through history like a giant pendulum, affecting everything from art to philosophy, from fashion to politics. For Hegel the great dualisms of history – the divisions between public and private or between the individual and society – would one day be reconciled through this relentless process. Only then would man achieve complete knowledge and fulfil the world spirit – Geist.8
Hegel died in 1831, and his followers immediately split into two antagonistic groups known as the Old Hegelians and the Young Hegelians. The first were ultra-conservative and would eventually use his defence of the all-powerful state – the Machtstaat – to legitimate Bismarck’s unification of Germany in 1871 and to justify chauvinistic nationalism and militarism well into the twentieth century. Because of this Hegel has been called everything from the father of nationalism to the harbinger of totalitarianism, but although he defended the Machtstaat, it is ahistorical to suggest that he either foresaw or would have approved of the policies later carried out in his name. He would have been appalled to see his face staring out gloomily from the pages of Nazi propaganda.9
Hegel’s other disciples, the Young Hegelians, saw his work as proof of precisely the opposite view. For them Hegel’s dialectic proved that what is ‘rational’ today is ‘irrational’ tomorrow, and that everything from religion to culture to politics must be destroyed to make way for something new, something better. Using Hegel as their guide they began to denounce their own society.10
Hegel had been a religious man all his life but his followers set about proving him wrong. Using his own methodology they tried to show that religion was a human construct whose time had passed. In 1835, four years after Hegel’s death, David Friedrich Strauss wrote his Life of Jesus, in which he used the dialectic to ‘prove’ that the New Testament was a myth. In his Kritik der evangelischen Geschichte der Synoptiker Bruno Bauer denied that Jesus was the son of God, and in The Essence of Christianity Ludwig Feuerbach tried to show that it was not God who had created man, but rather man who had created God, and that the deity was nothing more than a projection of human needs and desires. It was Feuerbach who coined the now famous expression ‘You are what you eat’ – by which he meant that man is not fashioned in the image of God but is nothing more than biological matter.11 Arnold Ruge became the leading Young Hegelian of the 1848 era and, using Hegel’s ‘terror of reason’, attacked everything from politics to the Romantics. He called for an end to ephemeral liberal theorizing and proclaimed that democracy would not simply ‘happen’ but must be fought for using principles of science and reason. He also chided Germans for being as passive about politics as they were ‘about the weather’. In 1838 Arnold Ruge and Theodor Ernst Echtermeyer founded the Hallesche Jahrbücher für deutsche Wissenschaft und Kunst, which became a rallying point for radical intellectuals; it was banned by the Prussian government in 1841 and Ruge was forced to flee to Paris, but not before he and others – above all Bruno Bauer – had influenced the young Marx.12
Marx was captivated by the new ideas sweeping 1830s Berlin and wrote to his father that he was attaching himself ‘ever more closely to the current philosophy’. His father sneered that he had merely replaced ‘degeneration in a learned dressing-gown and uncombed hair with degeneration with a beer glass’, but Marx was serious and had already started to struggle with Hegel’s troubled legacy.13 Marx agreed with Hegel that society was moving towards a Utopia but for him human beings had to make their own history, albeit under conditions which they had not chosen. To do this they had to act politically. Marx turned Hegel on his head, transforming Hegel’s passive view into a call for action. The epitaph on his gravestone in Highgate cemetery reads: ‘Philosophers have only explained the world in different ways, what matters is that it should be changed.’
In Berlin Marx drank in the theories of the Young Hegelians: religion became the ‘opium of the masses’; political action was necessary to create the perfect society; and it was possible to achieve an ideal world if one followed rational scientific principles. Nevertheless at this point in his development the young student showed more interest in the coffee houses, the theatres and the salons of Berlin than in the working-class districts to the north and it was only later, in Paris, that he first noticed the ‘nobility’ in the ‘toil-worn bodies’ of the workers and discovered his own ‘agent of history’ – the proletariat. Only then would the Hegelian ideas absorbed in Berlin fit into a vast system which explained how society was dominated by a class struggle between capitalists and workers and how, when the workers were made aware of their class consciousness, they would inaugurate a revolution and bring about a Communist society in which there would be plenty for all, classes would disappear, ideology would vanish, the state would wither away, and all human beings would live together in peace and self-fulfilment. It was a seductive idea and, although Marx left Berlin in 1841 as a virtually unknown academic, all of ‘Red Berlin’ would have his name on their lips by the time of his death in 1883. The city was growing, the Industrial Revolution was bringing inexorable change, and the urban working class was becoming a force in its own right. The new industrial areas north of the Oranienburg Gate would soon be fertile ground for the revolutionary ideas spread by Marx and his disciples.
The radicals, the neo-Hegelians, and indeed Marx himself came to maturity during a particularly grim phase in nineteenth-century industrialization. Berlin was no exception. Long hours, terrible working conditions, exploitation and brutality were the rule in the early factories and even before Marx’s arrival many were beginning to understand that however prosperous industrial Berlin appeared to be to the casual visitor it was a savage and terrible place for many of its inhabitants. Contemporary posters show the city haunted by a hideous black devil hovering above the buildings, waiting to devour those foolish enough to venture through the gates.14 Mothers in the villages of the Mark Brandenburg warned their children of the evil and depravity of the ‘Demon Berlin’, and conservatives grumbled about the hazards of having such a hotbed of radicalism in their midst. But the vast majority of the new working class who made up the overgrown industrial slums had not wanted to live in Berlin at all; they were immigrants who flooded into the city after their traditional way of life had collapsed in the east.
Berliners have created a great many myths about themselves, and one of the most enduring is the image of the ‘typical Berliner’. Every tour guide, local historian and Kneipe (bar) philosopher will expound at length about the collective wit, disrespect for authority, suspicion of leaders and tradition of tolerance which epitomizes a true Berliner. He will invariably point to medieval examples of Berliner Unwille or to Goethe’s musings about the audacious local temperament, or recall Queen Victoria’s daughter’s description of Berliners as ‘bristly, thorny … with their sharp tongues, their cutting sarcasms about everybody and everything’ as proof of this heritage. But like so many modern myths, it is largely a nineteenth-century creation. It is true that Berlin has always been a magnet for immigrants, and everyone from the Wends and the French Huguenots to the Jewish merchants and Dutch and Bohemian craftsmen left their mark on the city, but nothing could compare with the wave of people which swept into Berlin from Saxony and the east Elbian lands throughout the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. By 1900 more than 60 per cent of Berliners were either immigrants or the children of immigrants and this percentage skyrocketed in the years between 1900 and 1914, when the population doubled again.15 Visitors commented that Berlin looked more like a New York or a Chicago than any equivalent European city, and it developed a culture to match. A quick look through a modern telephone directory still reveals a plethora of common Bohemian, Moravian and Polish names, but these destitute strangers were brought together not by a common language or religion, but by poverty and fear, by the factory floor and the rental barrack. It was from these reluctant migrants, and not their earlier counterparts, that the caricature of the coarse, tough, witty, irreverent Berliner was born.
The reasons for the mass migration to the city were complex but ultimately lay in the fact that the land in the east could not sustain a large rural population. If one journeys overland from Berlin through the Mark Brandenburg into Poland and what were then the provinces of Mecklenburg, Pomerania and West and East Prussia one passes a seemingly endless patchwork of sandy fields broken by a few straggly pine forests and small villages. It was here that the Junkers, descendants of the settlers who had accompanied the old Teutonic conquerors to the area, lived on their estates, and fiercely defended their feudal privileges. Some were as poor as the French hobereaux who had to stay in bed while their only pair of trousers was being mended, but the larger landowners had become wealthier throughout the nineteenth century as rational methods of production, Liebig’s mineral fertilizers, and modern equipment triumphed over the sandy soil.16 They would suffer later when cheap imports of Russian and American grain undercut their products, but they prospered for much of the nineteenth century and were particularly important to the recovery of Prussia after the Napoleonic Wars. The ‘agrarian revolution’ which took place after the victory was bolstered by the reforms introduced between 1807 and 1821, but although they improved production and strengthened the Junkers’ power they had unforeseen consequences. Serfs were able to ‘buy’ their freedom from the lord by returning half the land they had once worked, but they were then left with tiny plots of poor soil from which it was impossible to make a living. Few could afford to buy seeds, farming equipment or supplies, and as the lord’s woodlands, grazing areas and common fields were now out of bounds few could survive for long. A desperately poor rural substratum emerged, with ex-serfs drifting around the countryside collecting wood, poaching, begging or stealing.17 The new, large-scale agriculture was achieved at the expense of peasant ownership, and between 1811 and 1890 the number of large estates increased by two-thirds in the east Elbian region. For their part the estate owners became increasingly powerful and continued to exert an extraordinary influence on the Prussian (and later the German) government. At the same time improved efficiency saw a vast increase in the population – Prussia’s grew by 26 per cent between 1840 and 1860 alone – but as fewer people were needed to work the land unemployment rose. Many were drawn to the new industrial cities.18 By the end of the century thousands of immigrants had moved in from West and East Prussia, Brandenburg, Pomerania and Mecklenburg.
To make matters worse, the crisis in agricultural labour coincided with the introduction of free trade in the North German Confederation and with the corresponding breakdown of the medieval guild system. Before 1810 only a privileged few had been entitled to become master-craftsmen, but the free trade laws did away with the strict code which required all silversmiths, jewellers, furniture makers, stone masons and a host of others to join one of the exclusive guilds. In 1820 there had been thirty masters and journeymen per 1,000 Prussians, but this had already doubled by 1850. Independent artisans were forced to work from home or to hire themselves out for menial repair work on battered furniture or church silver, and a newcomer could only hold his own against new mass-produced items by constantly increasing the length of his working day. Many simply gave up and went to the city.19
The Industrial Revolution hit the traditional cottage industries just as hard. There were half a million small linen and wool looms and tens of thousands of spinners in Prussia alone in the early nineteenth century, but as the shining new factories began to spring up in Europe’s cities life for traditional workers became a struggle for survival. Hollow-eyed children were sent to work at the age of four; Huhn (chicken) on a menu could mean Hund (dog); and even the cannibalistic jokes running through Kayssler’s social commentary, akin to Swiftian satire about Irish children, were not considered far fetched by those who visited the region. Linguet’s observation that ‘you can be sure that [the city] where the most human beings are at the point of dying of hunger is the one where the most hands are employed in working the shuttle’ was an apt description for much of the east.20 It was clear that the cottage weavers were fighting a losing battle.
The spark which ignited the powder keg was started by famine. From 1843 Prussia experienced successive failures in both the grain and potato harvests, and food riots became increasingly common in Berlin after 1845. By this time around 70 per cent of a labourer’s income was spent on food – a dire situation when, according to the great liberal scientist Rudolf Virchow, workers’ real wages dropped by 45 per cent between 1844 and 1847.21 The latter was the year of the ‘Potato Revolution’, which saw violence on the streets of Berlin provoked by endless food shortages and an outbreak of typhus, a disease brought on by malnutrition.22 It was put down by the military. But the situation was worse in Silesia. There linen weavers could no longer compete with new mechanical production techniques employed in Britain and they were penniless and starving. Eighty thousand people contracted typhus and around 16,000 people died that winter. Thousands rose up in desperation against the local merchants and middlemen in a pitiful attempt to get food and to somehow reverse the course of the Industrial Revolution. The weavers blamed the wealthy middlemen, who were detested for flaunting their coaches and clothes and estates as the people went hungry. Three hundred weavers attacked their factories and homes in 1847, smashing property and burning the records of their debts. Not amused by the cartloads of ‘German Luddites’ bearing down on them with sticks and pitchforks, the merchants asked the Prussian military to intervene and the latter, nervous about the persistent whispers of revolution floating around Europe, crushed the revolt with brute force.23
In more settled times an incident like this would soon have been forgotten, but the story of the revolt became one of the first great rallying myths of the emerging working class; indeed it fuelled the Marxist belief that industrial capitalism must inevitably lead to the degradation and impoverishment – to the pauperization – of workers. Heinrich Heine wrote about it in his early poem of social protest The Silesian Weavers; it was taken up by Gerhart Hauptmann in his eerie, disturbing – and banned – play Die Weber (The Weavers) and by Käthe Kollwitz in her black lithographs of the same name; it cropped up in Franz Mehring’s essay Hauptmanns Weavers, in Friedrich Kayssler’s The Weavers’ Social Drama, and was later alluded to by many a left-wing Berlin writer of the nineteenth century. The frightened and starving cottage weavers would never know of their place in history, but they packed up their belongings and left for Berlin, adding to the mass of new arrivals there. Evidence of this exodus has long since disappeared under the weight of the more terrible things which have since happened in eastern Germany and Poland. Perhaps the closest equivalent one can find today are the chillingly quiet villages near Chernobyl in Ukraine which resemble the abandoned settlements that once littered the territory east of the Elbe. There the evidence of rapid departure is everywhere: small brightly painted wooden houses line the dusty roads, old bottles stand on kitchen window sills, benches where neighbours once chatted in the sun lie at the edges of overgrown gardens, and rusting wire still clings to empty chicken coops. In the 1980s the fear of radiation forced people to move; in the mid nineteenth century it was starvation, but the end result was the same: a destitute population compelled to emigrate in search of a better life.
In 1847 400,000 peasants, merchants and artisans left the eastern provinces; by 1870 it was over 800,000 per year and over 2 million Germans emigrated in the years between 1850 and 1870. Of the 133,700 who officially registered in Berlin in 1870 (many did not) over half were young men of working age. The city population surged to 1 million following demobilization after the war of 1871; twenty years later it doubled again, and it had reached 4 million by 1914. Most continued to come from the east; in 1911 alone 1,046,162 people came to Berlin from German lands along with 97,683 from Russia; this was in contrast to the mere 7,611 who came from western countries like Holland or 3,682 from Italy.24 Huge tent cities sprang up on the fringes of a Berlin bloated with desperate people hoping to get work – older men with families to feed and a few qualifications, or rural untrained youths with no idea about life in the city. Many had hoped to make enough money in Berlin to buy a passage to America but had been trapped by their poverty.
Ücretsiz ön izlemeyi tamamladınız.