Sadece Litres'te okuyun

Kitap dosya olarak indirilemez ancak uygulamamız üzerinden veya online olarak web sitemizden okunabilir.

Kitabı oku: «If You Love Me: True love. True terror. True story.»

Jane Smith, Alice Keale
Yazı tipi:

Copyright

Certain details in this story, including names, places and dates, have been changed to protect the family’s privacy.


HarperElement

An imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers

1 London Bridge Street

London SE1 9GF

www.harpercollins.co.uk

First published by HarperElement 2017

FIRST EDITION

© Alice Keale and Jane Smith 2017

Cover layout design © HarperCollinsPublishers Ltd 2017

Cover photograph © Stephen Carroll/Arcangel Images (posed by model)

A catalogue record of this book is available from the British Library

Alice Keale and Jane Smith assert the moral right to be identified as the authors of this work

All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. By payment of the required fees, you have been granted the nonexclusive, non-transferable right to access and read the text of this e-book on screen. No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, decompiled, reverse engineered, or stored in or introduced into any information storage retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the express written permission of HarperCollins e-books.

Find out about HarperCollins and the environment at

www.harpercollins.co.uk/green

Source ISBN: 9780008205256

Ebook Edition © January 2017 ISBN: 9780008205263

Version: 2016-12-20

Dedication

For my family and friends, who never gave up on me. I wouldn’t be where I am today without their continued love and support.

Contents

Cover

Title Page

Copyright

Dedication

Prologue

Chapter 1

Chapter 2

Chapter 3

Chapter 4

Chapter 5

Chapter 6

Chapter 7

Chapter 8

Chapter 9

Chapter 10

Chapter 11

Chapter 12

Chapter 13

Chapter 14

Chapter 15

Chapter 16

Chapter 17

About the Author

Moved by If You Love Me?

Moving Memoirs eNewsletter

About the Publisher

Prologue

I glanced down at the luminous hands of the large watch that made my wrist look as thin as a child’s. Surely that couldn’t be the right time. It couldn’t possibly have taken me as long as that just to get this far. Then I remembered that he’d set the watch before I left, so I knew it was accurate. Which meant that I would have to run even faster if I was going to reach the pub, take a photograph on his mobile phone and get back to the house in the few minutes that remained before time ran out.

Quickening my pace, I scanned the darkness of every side street and every shop doorway I passed. And I listened too, for the sound of approaching footsteps or distant voices.

As I ran past the café where we had sat together just a few hours earlier, I thought I saw a flicker of movement, and the ever-present knot of fear tightened inside me. It was almost 1 a.m. on a Wednesday night and I’d been certain I was the only person out on the street. But, suddenly, a man stepped out of the shadows directly in front of me.

I had to swerve off the pavement and on to the road to avoid being caught in his outstretched arms, and as I did so I was engulfed in the alcohol-laden breath he exhaled when he lunged towards me. I gasped in shocked surprise, but kept on running, ignoring the sharp objects I could feel cutting into the flesh of my bare, bruised feet and the incoherent shouts of the man who stumbled after me down the dimly lit street.

I couldn’t really blame him for pursuing me – a woman running naked through the streets of London in the middle of the night. Perhaps he thought I was playing some salacious game. It was certainly an explanation that would have made more sense than the real reason, which I didn’t understand myself – and I was completely sober.

I was frightened of the drunk man, and of what he might do if he caught up with me. But I was even more frightened of what would happen if I didn’t get home within the next three minutes. ‘Maybe this time it will be enough,’ I thought, as I ran, sobbing, through the darkness.

‘Please, God,’ I whispered into the night, ‘let it be this time.’

Chapter 1

Although my love life was pretty much a disaster, things were going well at work and I’d managed to save enough money for a deposit on a flat of my own. So when my flatmate, Connie, went to live with her boyfriend, I arranged to rent the spare room in my friend Cara’s flat until I could find somewhere to buy.

It was August 2011 and I was alone on what would be my last night in the rented flat Connie and I had shared. I’d already taken almost everything I was going to need in the short term to Cara’s place and stored the rest in the garage at my parents’ house in Devon. So all I had to do that evening was pack a small suitcase to take with me the next day. I was looking forward to buying a place of my own and starting the next phase of my life, and after having a nice dinner out with friends I was just thinking about heading off to bed for an early night when I heard the sound of breaking glass.

The flat was above some shops on quite a busy street, and my first thought was that there’d been a car accident. But what I saw when I looked out of the window was like a scene from a dystopian film. There were people running in every direction, most of them wearing hoodies and scarves that concealed their faces and some of them hurling what looked like bricks and bottles through shop windows. At first, I couldn’t make any sense of what was happening. Then, as I watched, with my back pressed against the wall beside the window so that I couldn’t be seen, a group of people started rocking a car from side to side, before stumbling backwards when smoke began to curl around it and then flames exploded out of it.

I was shaking as I phoned the police. ‘There’s rioting all over London,’ the police operator told me. ‘So it might be some time before anyone gets there. Just stay in your flat. Whatever you do, don’t go outside.’

I moved away from the window after speaking to her, and was crouched in the hallway when my phone rang. ‘Dad and I have been listening to the news,’ Mum said, sounding less worried than she would have done if she’d known the true situation. ‘Is there rioting where you are?’

‘It’s fine,’ I told her, walking from the hallway into my bedroom at the back of the flat and closing the door as I spoke, so that she wouldn’t hear the sounds from the street.

I didn’t know the neighbours, who’d only recently moved in to the flat next door. But after I’d reassured Mum, I knocked on their door and asked if I could sit with them for a while, because I didn’t want to be on my own. Something had been thrown through their living-room window just a few minutes earlier, and after they’d shown me the shards of glass that covered the carpet we sat in their bedroom, as far away from the street as we could get, and waited for the police to arrive. In fact, things had already started to calm down a bit by the time they got there, and I decided to go back to my place and try to get a couple of hours’ sleep.

It felt as though my head had only just touched the pillow when my phone rang again. It was Connie this time, and her voice was tight with anxiety as she asked, ‘Are you in the flat, Alice? It’s on TV. I’m watching it now. They’ve set fire to the shops underneath. You’ve got to get out.’

I’d been so tired I’d fallen into bed fully clothed and I was just grabbing my suitcase when there was a knock on the front door. The fireman who was standing there when I opened it told me, ‘We’re evacuating the building. They’ve fire-bombed the shop on the corner. You need to leave – now.’ So I followed my neighbours out on to the smoke-filled street, where the last of the rioters were being herded past the burning buildings and around the corner by police.

Someone had opened up a café a few doors down from the flat, to provide a refuge for people who’d had to be evacuated from their homes. It was about four o’clock in the morning by that time, and all the other people there looked as exhausted and dazed as I felt. Fortunately, the fire didn’t spread to my flat, and when the fire-fighters eventually got it under control, I was able to go back and try to sleep again for a couple of hours.

Someone from the letting agency was due to do an inventory later that morning, but I was so tired by the time he arrived that I left him to it. Cara was away for a couple of days, so she’d given me a key to let myself in to her flat, and although I had been planning to go there first to drop off my bag, being at work suddenly seemed like a much better option than sitting there on my own.

I worked at that time for a company that owned several art galleries, and when I emailed my boss to tell her what had happened and that I was going to be a bit late arriving at the office, she answered immediately, asking if I was all right and telling me to take the day off. I don’t think what had happened had really sunk in by that time. The adrenaline was still pumping around my body and although I was incredibly tired and shocked I wasn’t yet feeling particularly distressed, and my boss seemed to understand when I said I wanted to keep busy. So I did go in to work, and when I got there I was sitting at my desk talking to some of my colleagues about what had happened when Joe came over.

Joe held a senior position as head of a department at the company I worked for, and although I knew vaguely who he was I hadn’t ever spoken to him before. ‘I heard about your experience this morning,’ he said. ‘And I just wanted to make sure you were okay.’ He seemed genuinely concerned, so I assured him that I was fine, apart from being tired and finding it a bit difficult to process what I’d seen – the overturned cars, smashed windows, looted shops and people running riot through the streets. ‘I still think you need to go home,’ he said. ‘You’ve had a shock and when it catches up with you, home is the best place for you to be.’

He was right about the shock catching up with me. The adrenaline was already starting to subside and, as it did so, I was overcome by an almost paralysing weariness. So Joe got me a taxi, which the company paid for, and half an hour later I let myself in to Cara’s flat, with barely minutes to spare before exhaustion finally kicked in.

I sent Joe an email before I fell into bed, thanking him for the taxi and telling him he’d been right about home being the best place, which he answered immediately, saying, ‘It’s fine. Don’t worry about it. Just have a good rest. Joe X.’

I don’t sign off emails or texts with a kiss, except to family and close friends. But I know a lot of people do. So it probably wouldn’t have seemed particularly odd that Joe had done so if it hadn’t been for our relative positions at work and for the fact that we’d only spoken to each other for the first time that morning – although I was too weary to wonder about it by then.

I had just finished reading Joe’s email when Cara’s mum phoned to check that I’d been able to get into the flat and that everything was okay. It was while I was talking to her that the impact of the whole traumatic experience finally hit me and I had to end the call because I couldn’t stop sobbing. Then I went to bed and slept without waking until the following morning.

Joe made a point of coming to see me the next day, to ask if I was feeling better and if I’d managed to sleep. He sat on the edge of my desk in the large open-plan office for about half an hour, talking about what had happened and studying the diagram he asked me to draw to show exactly where the flat was in relation to where the rioting had kicked off in the street below.

Part of my job involved setting up exhibitions of paintings and sculpture at various galleries around the country, and although I hadn’t had any direct contact with Joe before then, he was ultimately responsible for my team. So there was nothing unusual in the fact that we were both included in the emails that were sent round to everyone a couple of days later suggesting we should all meet up for a drink after work one evening. We didn’t get the chance to talk to each other on that occasion, however, because I was held up at the office and didn’t make it to the bar until after Joe had left.

Meanwhile, what only a determined optimist would have referred to as my ‘love life’ was barely ticking over. Anthony, the married man I was ‘seeing’, had only been to my flat once during the few weeks prior to the night of the riots. But, based on the emails and texts he occasionally sent me – and on a great deal of wishful thinking – I still considered myself to be in a relationship with him. Not that my situation with Anthony had any relevance to how I felt about Joe. Although Joe was friendly and seemed very pleasant, I wasn’t interested in him in that way. So I was surprised to receive an email from him one day when I was doing some research in a large art gallery in London, asking if I’d like to meet for a quick coffee after work.

‘Unfortunately, I can’t,’ I emailed back. ‘I’m meeting some friends.’

His answer came almost immediately. ‘That’s a shame. I’m going to Berlin in the morning. I’ll be away for a week. Of course, we could always meet there for coffee …!’ To which I responded in the same jokey manner and was flattered when he suggested we should have a drink when he got back.

I did see him the following week, after his trip to Berlin, but he didn’t say anything about the emails or about getting together for a drink. So I sent a text to my best friend, Sarah, asking whether she thought I should mention it to him, and she answered, ‘Go for it! Just see what he’s like. You’ve been really miserable and you deserve to be happy.’ And when I texted Joe, he suggested meeting for a drink after work a few days later.

Apart from those few emails and texts, we’d only ever spoken to each other about work and the riots, so I don’t know what I was expecting to happen when we did meet up. I still believed I loved Anthony, even though we saw each other only rarely by that time. But although I wasn’t ready to admit it to myself yet, I think I already knew, on some level, that we weren’t going to have a future together, and I often wished I could have the sort of normal, uncomplicated relationship with a nice, single guy that most of my friends had.

I’d only really had one serious relationship before I started seeing Anthony – which had lasted several years before we split up. So the prospect of having what seemed to be a date with Joe made me both nervous and excited. In fact, I was so agitated on the day itself that I barely ate anything, and as I made my way to the trendy, expensive club where he’d suggested we should meet, my stomach was rumbling noisily.

‘Get a grip,’ I told myself severely as I pushed my way through the almost solid tide of commuters heading in the opposite direction, towards the train station from which I’d just come. ‘It isn’t really a date. You’re just meeting a man you barely know for a drink.’ It was true that I knew almost nothing about Joe, except that he was clever and seemed to be universally liked and respected by his colleagues. But, for some reason, I’d been looking forward all day to what I kept reminding myself was just a casual drink.

I’d been delayed leaving work and was a few minutes late by the time I arrived at the club and climbed the stairs to the rooftop bar where I was due to meet Joe. There was still time to stop for a moment in front of the long mirror on the landing, though, and when I did so I was horrified by the red-faced, flustered-looking woman staring back at me. ‘Well, that’s a good start,’ I told her. ‘He’s going to be thrilled when he sees you!’ Then I imagined what he might say, which made me wonder, anxiously, what I would say to him. What would we talk about? What if he thought I was boring – as well as being an unattractive shade of puce and suffering from severe, and very audible, digestive problems? What if he made a quick excuse and fled as soon as he could do so without appearing to be downright rude?

‘For heaven’s sake, calm down,’ I told the woman in the mirror, silently. ‘You can do this. People don’t normally dislike you. You can hold a conversation and have fun. You’ve got some really nice, intelligent friends who wouldn’t bother with you if you were boring and stupid. You just need to move away from the mirror now and believe that everything will be all right.’

When I stepped out on to the roof of the building a couple of seconds later, it was as if someone had suddenly turned up the volume on the muffled buzz of conversation that could be heard from inside. In fact, the bar was full of people, and as I scanned them in search of Joe I could feel the knot of anxiety tightening in my already protesting stomach. ‘Perhaps he hasn’t arrived yet,’ I thought. ‘Maybe something’s kept him late at work. Maybe he won’t come at all.’

Then I saw him, sitting on a sofa with his head bent over his phone. Just a split second later he looked up and saw me, and as his face broke into a smile the knot in my stomach unravelled and I suddenly felt completely calm. After that, even the awkward bit was easy – those seconds when you’ve spotted the person you’re meeting but still have to cross the ground between you, not knowing whether to maintain eye contact and keep smiling inanely or look away until you’re within hand-shaking or cheek-kissing distance.

Joe stood up when he saw me, and as soon as I was close enough to be able to hear him above the laughing chatter of the crowd he leaned forward and said into my ear, ‘I’ve got you a drink already. A gin and tonic. I hope that’s okay?’

‘That’s perfect,’ I said, sinking on to the sofa beside him. ‘Thanks. And hi.’

On the relatively rare occasions when I go out on weekday evenings when I’m working, I don’t stay out late. But Joe and I were still in the bar four hours later, laughing and talking as though we’d known each other for years. He was funny and charming, and the more we talked, the more struck we were by how much we seemed to have in common. Everything I liked, Joe liked – and had something interesting or insightful to say about it. We laughed at the same things, had the same list of countries we wanted to visit, admired the same people, loved the work of the same artists, had read or wanted to read the same books, had the same opinions about films we’d seen, and loved or loathed the same foods …

That first evening I spent with Joe was quite possibly the best evening of my entire life. I don’t know whether I lacked self-confidence any more than anyone else, but I could hardly believe that someone like him could be so obviously attracted to someone like me. The hours just flew by, and when he leaned towards me, put his hands very gently on my cheeks and kissed me, it felt like coming home.

‘I don’t want this evening to end,’ he said, voicing the thought that had been going through my mind for the last couple of hours. ‘Will you come back to my place tonight? Let’s agree not to have sex. Just come home with me – for a sleep-over.’ Tiny lines radiated out from his eyes when he laughed. ‘I just want to go to sleep knowing you’ll be there when I wake up. I know it sounds crazy, but I think I want to spend the rest of my life with you, Alice. I’ve never felt this way before.’

And maybe it would have sounded crazy to anyone who might have been listening in the bar that night. But it sounded perfectly sane to me, and it didn’t even cross my mind to say anything other than, ‘Yes, I will go home with you. I feel exactly the same way. I can’t explain it, but I feel as though I’ve known you for years, not just a few hours. I …’ I can’t remember now what I was going to say before Joe kissed me again and pushed every thought out of my head.

Agreeing to go home with Joe that night was completely out of character for me. That might sound unlikely in view of the fact that, of the few things you already know about me, one is that I was having an affair with a married man. But it’s true. It was something I wouldn’t even have dreamed of doing in normal circumstances, or if it hadn’t felt as though everything in my life suddenly made sense.

Sitting in the bar that night with a nice, uncomplicated, charismatic, interesting single man with a good job and a great sense of humour, it felt as though I might find love in my love life after all. Even more important, perhaps, was the fact that, by the end of the evening, I didn’t despise myself as much as I had done until then, because if someone like Joe could like me, there might be hope for me after all.

Sitting there with Joe that evening just felt right somehow. I’d met a lot of sleazy execs over the previous few years, the sort of creepy guys who prey on junior colleagues – people like Anthony, in fact, although I didn’t realise that at the time. But it was clear that Joe wasn’t the sort of person to take advantage of anyone. I’d heard people at work talking about how he’d helped a colleague who was going through a difficult time in his personal life and how if it hadn’t been for Joe’s intervention the man would have lost his job. ‘He stuck his neck out for Barry when he didn’t have to,’ someone said. ‘It’s the sort of thing he does.’ Everyone seemed to like him. And now, apparently, this genuine, kind, intelligent person liked me.

One of the many things Joe told me about himself that first evening was that he was married, although he and his wife had been separated for more years than they’d been together. ‘We got married too young,’ he told me. ‘We didn’t have any children and there wasn’t any property to be divided up – we both have jobs that enable us to support ourselves more than adequately financially. So although we haven’t seen each other for five or six years, we just never got around to divorcing.’

Then I told him about Jack – the boyfriend I’d lived with for several years after I left university and who had broken my heart – but not about Anthony, because I didn’t want him to judge me or change his mind about liking me. In fact, by the end of that first evening Joe liking me was so important that I lied to him and said there hadn’t been anyone since Jack. That’s the trouble with doing something you know is wrong: you end up doing more wrong things – like lying, for example – because you don’t want people to find out about it.

When we left the bar, we took a taxi back to Joe’s immaculate terraced house in a tree-lined street in an expensive part of south-west London. We didn’t have sex, as agreed. We just talked and talked into the early hours of the morning, more than I’d ever talked with anyone in my life before. And the more we talked, the more we found we had in common, and the more I felt as though I’d known Joe for years, which is the way he said he felt about me, too.

I don’t believe the happy-ever-after love stories of Hollywood movies. But I did start to wonder that night if maybe sometimes they weren’t as far-fetched as I’d always thought they were.

The next morning, Joe drove me to work, where I spent the rest of the day trying to concentrate on what I was supposed to be doing. And when sex was added to the agenda that evening, it was as perfect as every other aspect of our new relationship seemed to be.

For the next two weeks, we spent almost every night together. I was supposed to be flat hunting, which was why I’d been staying in my friend Cara’s flat since the day of the riots, when I first spoke to Joe. So I didn’t have much more than a suitcase full of clothes to transport when I moved in with him a couple of weeks after our first date at the bar. It sounds crazy now, to have taken such a major step after knowing him for such a short period of time. But it just felt right. Whatever we tell ourselves, I think most of us do hope we’ve got a soul mate out there somewhere and that one day we’ll find each other and live happily ever after. So when you think you’ve actually met your soul mate, why would you wait?

Although Jack and I had been together for years and I did love him, at no time during the course of our relationship did I ever feel what I felt with Joe almost from day one. When Jack and I split up, I’d got involved with Anthony almost by accident, because I was hurt and lonely and had begun to wonder if anyone would ever care about me again. For the last couple of years before I met Joe, and particularly after Jack dumped me, I hadn’t wanted to feel anything. Joe and I didn’t tell people at work that we were seeing each other. But that was our choice – at least, I think it was ours, rather than his, although I can’t really remember now. I did tell my friends, though, and was touched by how happy they were for me.

When I met Joe, it felt as though I’d been swept up by a whirlwind and that, suddenly, I had a future again. When we were together in the evenings we talked almost incessantly, and about everything, including when and where we would get married – ‘I know the perfect place for our wedding,’ Joe told me – where we would live, and how many children we would have.

The ‘perfect place for our wedding’ turned out to be a small town in France Joe had visited with his wife a couple of years after they’d got married. He described to me how he had stood on the steps of a church there one day during their holiday, looking out towards the mountains, and felt a sense of peace he’d never experienced before or since. ‘I can’t wait for you to see it,’ he said. And I told him I couldn’t wait either, while silently berating myself for wishing we could get married somewhere he hadn’t already visited with the wife he would first have to divorce.

Chapter 2

A lot of people have to deal with bad situations in their lives, and the things that had gone wrong for me before I met Joe weren’t really that bad at all, in the greater scheme of things.

The first time there was any indication that something might be wrong was during my second year at university. I’d had glandular fever, so for a while I thought that was why I was tearful and felt so low. But when all the other symptoms finally cleared up and I was still miserable for no apparent reason, the doctor diagnosed depression.

Fortunately, the antidepressants I was given worked well. So well, in fact, that I eventually decided it had just been an isolated incident and I stopped taking them. And then, of course, the depression came back. It was disappointing to have to face the fact that it hadn’t been ‘cured’ after all, and it was frustrating every time it recurred over the next few years. I was lucky, though, because it wasn’t ever bad enough to interfere with my life to any significant extent and I never had to be hospitalised.

I was doing a degree in the history of art when I had the first episode of depression, and I was lucky again in that it didn’t disrupt my studies and I was able to go on to finish my course. After my BA, I did a Masters degree, then worked as a temp for a while, before doing an internship at an auction house and eventually getting a job in an art gallery. A couple of years later, I was promoted within the same company and started earning a reasonable salary, which enabled me to pay to see a psychiatrist privately every few months, for reassurance as much as anything else.

I had all the usual insecurities and doubts most young people have about being ‘good enough’, but I had a good social life, was doing a job I enjoyed and, thanks largely to the tablets and to some cognitive behavioural therapy – which I found really useful – rarely had to take a day off work because of depression. So, apart from my family and the close friends who knew about my experience at university, no one was aware that there had ever been anything wrong with me at all.

The company I was working for had galleries and offices in numerous cities around the UK and abroad, and I was moved around a bit for the first couple of years after I was promoted, although only ever to places in England. By the time I started working on a more permanent basis in London, I’d been going out with my boyfriend Jack for almost four years.

Jack worked in an advertising agency in the Midlands and came to London most weekends to stay with me at the flat I shared with a friend from university. He planned to move down permanently as soon as the right job came up, and we were saving to buy a flat together. In fact, we’d begun to talk about getting married, and then he came to London one Friday evening and told me it was over.

Looking back on it now, I think that if Jack had already got a job in London our relationship might have ended sooner. We’d been together for seven years when he broke it off, and although we were comfortable in each other’s company, people change in their twenties, and in reality we no longer had very much in common and had been drifting apart. It was only because we didn’t see each other every day that we hadn’t noticed that was the case – although I realise, in retrospect, that Jack must have been more aware of it than I was.

It’s much easier to rationalise things when you look back on them from the distance of a few years than it is when you’ve just been dumped, and when Jack dumped me I was completely heartbroken. ‘Can’t we try to make it work?’ I kept pleading with him that Friday evening. But he’d made up his mind and nothing I could say was going to change it. He did try to be kind, though, and because he knew the break-up would come as a complete bolt from the blue to me and I’d be very upset, he’d arranged for my mum to be in London that weekend. He must have texted her before he left my flat, a couple of hours after he’d broken the news to me, because she turned up just a few minutes later.

I know Mum was worried about me and that she really did want to help. But there was probably nothing she could have said that would have reduced the impact of what felt almost like a physical blow. I was in a state of shock and certainly didn’t believe her when she told me everything was going to be okay and that I’d feel better about it all in a few days. I was twenty-nine years old, had believed Jack and I would be together for the rest of our lives, and just wanted to be left alone with my grief. So Mum went home the next morning, and I spent the rest of the weekend on my own in the flat, crying until I ran out of tears.

I didn’t want to go into work on the Monday morning. I didn’t want anyone to see me looking tear-stained and hopeless, and I couldn’t bear the thought of having to talk to people or, even worse, of suddenly bursting into tears. But I didn’t have much choice. I’d recently started working on a project that involved organising an exhibition at an art gallery in a town some distance from London, where I had to stay in a hotel for a couple of nights during the week. I was due to go back there that Monday morning, and had arranged a couple of important meetings for later in the day. I would have called in sick if it hadn’t been for the fact that I knew the art specialist I was working with was on a tight schedule and was relying on me to help him get the job done on time.

So when the train pulled out of the station in London on Monday morning, I was on it, looking tired and strained, and trying not to think about everything I’d just lost or the fact that, in the space of just two very miserable days, almost every aspect of the life I thought I was going to have had changed.

The art specialist, Anthony, and I were staying at the same hotel and would often have something to eat together in the evenings. And although I tried to act normally that first Monday, he could obviously see that something was wrong. So eventually, when we got back to the hotel, I stopped saying, ‘Yes, fine, thanks,’ whenever he asked if I was all right, and told him that my boyfriend and I had split up. He was very nice, and seemed to understand that I didn’t want to talk about it. Which meant that, for the next couple of days, I was able to throw myself into my work and not think about Jack or the future – until I was alone in my hotel room at night, when there was nothing to distract me from the misery that threatened to overwhelm me.

Somehow, I got through one day, then the next, then the rest of the week, then the weekend, which I spent alone again in the flat in London, snatching up my phone every time it rang in case it was Jack, calling to say he’d changed his mind; then not answering it because it wasn’t ever him.

The first phase of the work I was doing with Anthony took a couple of months to complete, by which time I was getting better at pretending – to other people, at least – that everything was going to be all right, although I didn’t actually believe that for a moment. While I was with Jack, I hadn’t really thought about the future, except in general terms when we talked about getting married or about where we’d live and what sort of flat we’d buy when we had saved up enough money for a deposit. ‘After Jack’, I did try to imagine the future, but whenever I did I couldn’t see anything in it for me at all, which was something I found incredibly frightening.

Looking back on it now, I realise that being dumped by Jack after we’d been together for seven years had shattered my already shaky self-confidence. At the time, however, I simply thought there was something wrong with me, that he had dumped me because I wasn’t good enough, and that no other man would ever want me. So when Anthony and I got a bit drunk one evening at the hotel and ended up kissing, I was grateful to him for making me feel wanted again, even if it was only for a few minutes before embarrassment kicked in.

I went back to London the next day and didn’t see Anthony again for a couple of weeks, when we met in another town to set up another exhibition. It was awkward at first, trying to pretend that we were purely work colleagues and that neither of us had any memory of having kissed. Then, one night, after we’d eaten our dinner together at the hotel and I’d gone back to my room, he knocked on my door and we ended up making love.

Pathetic as it might sound, it felt amazing to think that someone liked me enough to want to have sex with me, and that perhaps I did have something to offer after all. Anthony hadn’t tried to hide the fact that he was married, so I had absolutely no excuse for getting involved with him. But when he told me that he hadn’t ever had an affair before, that he loved me and simply couldn’t help himself, the extraordinary thought began to form in my mind that maybe Jack didn’t leave me because I’m unlovable and maybe my mother had been right and everything was going to be okay.

On the days when I was working with Anthony we maintained the same polite professional relationship we’d always had, then spent the nights together at whatever hotel we were staying at. So I don’t think anyone guessed that there was something going on between us. If they did, they didn’t ever say anything.

I can’t remember what I thought at the time about what we were doing, or what I really felt about Anthony. Although he wasn’t particularly charismatic or good-looking, he was a nice guy – if a man who cheats on his wife can ever really be called ‘nice’. It’s so stupid when I think about it now, and so naïve of me to have believed him when he told me some clichéd nonsense about his wife not understanding him. I imagine the truth was that she understood him only too well; and maybe his teenage son and daughter did too.

As Anthony was the one that was married, it could be said that his ‘sin’ was greater than mine. But I know that, in reality, I was as culpable as he was, because I knew that what I was doing was dishonest, which is why I didn’t tell any of my friends about him, not even my flatmate Connie or my best friend, Sarah. All I can say in my defence – and I know it’s a weak argument – is that I was so desperate to be loved and to feel valued that, at that particular moment in my life, I probably would have become involved with almost anyone who’d paid me any loving attention.

Anthony and I worked together on a few more projects after the first two, and spent pretty much every night together while we were away. He came to my flat in London sometimes too, on evenings during the week when Connie wasn’t there, although he never stayed the night. He often told me he loved me, and I told myself that I’d fallen in love with him. Or maybe it wasn’t simply a case of ‘telling myself’; maybe I really did love him. I certainly thought I did at the time. But now I don’t really know what I felt about anything.

We’d been seeing each other for a few weeks when something happened that should have rung alarm bells in my mind, but that completely failed to register with me as being peculiar in any way. I’d just been introduced to a researcher at an auction house where Anthony and I had been having some meetings, and while it was obvious that he already knew her, she was very frosty with him. When we were alone at the hotel later that evening, he made a point of telling me she was married and that they had an awkward relationship ‘because I think she thought I once tried to make a move on her’. I didn’t think any more about it until some time later, when I discovered he’d actually had numerous affairs before me, and that it was quite likely he was seeing other women while we were ‘together’.

Sometimes, Anthony talked about his wife and about how things weren’t working out between them. He didn’t ever say he’d leave her, though, and I didn’t ever ask him if he would. I don’t know what I thought was going to happen in the long term. I can’t really remember thinking about it at all. I was just happy to have someone – if you can call stealing time with someone else’s husband ‘having someone’.

You might think that having an affair with a married man would be complicated, whereas it was actually quite the opposite. The fact that he wasn’t ‘available’ meant that we weren’t a couple in the normal sense of the word, and as long as I didn’t allow myself to feel too much, every aspect of our relationship was beyond my control – which meant that I didn’t have to make any decisions, about the present or the future.

I’m the sort of person who likes to have people around me and things to do, so the weekends were very lonely. For years, Jack had been there every weekend and we’d done all the normal, reassuring things couples do. It seems like a very shallow thing to say in the circumstances, but even when I was seeing Anthony I think I was still clinging to the faint hope that Jack and I would get back together. I doubt whether it was ever a realistic hope, but it was kept alive to some extent by the fact that I was getting mixed messages from Jack, for example when he called in for a chat while I was at work one day, and when he sent me a card and a present for my thirtieth birthday.

One thing I’ve learned during the last few years is that you never really know what you’ll do in a particular situation. So I can’t say for certain that I’d have dropped Anthony if Jack had told me he’d changed his mind and wanted us to try to make a go of it. But I think I probably would have done so. Because even though I was in denial about it, I think I knew that my relationship with Anthony wasn’t going anywhere. We didn’t have to discuss it for me to realise that he wasn’t going to leave his wife and children. In fact, I don’t think that’s what I wanted. Selfish as it sounds, the hours I spent with him were just a distraction from the loneliness and misery I felt when I was on my own.

By the time I was thirty years old I had a good job, money in the bank, and friends who were getting married, buying houses, having children and doing all the other things I’d thought I was going to do with Jack – which it now looked as though I might never do at all. It didn’t matter how sternly I told myself, ‘It’s just a break-up. People go through far worse things in their lives. You’ll get over it. You’ll move on and meet someone else.’ I didn’t really believe it.

It felt as though Anthony was holding my head above water and that even though our relationship was wrong and probably didn’t have any future, I might drown without him. So I told myself we were well suited and things would work out, and ignored what I suspected to be the truth – that we weren’t and they wouldn’t.

Then one Saturday morning, when I was alone in the flat, wondering what to do with myself for the rest of the weekend, Anthony phoned. His phone calls were usually to arrange our next meeting, or sometimes just to tell me he was missing me. On that occasion, however, he was at the airport, about to board a flight to Amsterdam, and the first thing he said was, ‘We can’t go on seeing each other.’ And there it was again, the same feeling I’d had when Jack started to tell me it was all over between us, of wanting to freeze time so that whatever was going to happen next, didn’t. But the clock kept ticking and Anthony kept talking.

It turned out that his daughter had found one of my texts on his phone, which said something like ‘I miss you’ or ‘When will I see you again?’ Apparently, she’d waited until her mother was out of the house before confronting him, and then had promised not to tell her as long as he swore never to see me again.

As I listened to what Anthony was telling me, I could feel my cheeks burning with distress for his daughter and, selfishly, for myself too. My family and friends had done everything they could think of to comfort and support me when Jack dumped me. So I knew they loved me and wanted me to be happy. But I was also aware that they would be appalled – my parents especially – if they knew I was having an affair with a married man. So I hadn’t told even my closest friend. And now that I was being dumped again, I had no one to talk to, which I suppose was only what I deserved in the circumstances.

In hindsight, knowing what I know now about Anthony’s many extramarital relationships, he might have been lying about the confrontation with his daughter and the promise he’d had to make to her. Perhaps it was what he told every woman he had an affair with when he was ready to move on. Saying ‘I’m tired of you’ or ‘I’ve found someone else’ would be likely to lead to tears and pleading, possibly even to acts of revenge. Whereas ‘I still love you, but my daughter found your text message and I’m being forced to break it off for her sake’ is rather more difficult to argue with. That didn’t even cross my mind at the time, though, and I felt very guilty about my role in her distress.

So Anthony went to Amsterdam, and I spent the next few days feeling miserable and hating myself for lying to my mother every time she phoned and asked me what was wrong.

In fact, Anthony and I did start seeing each other again when he came back from Amsterdam. I can’t remember exactly how it happened, just that, despite feeling ashamed and guilty, I did want to continue our relationship and was easily persuaded to sleep with him the next time we found ourselves staying at the same hotel. The only thing that really changed was that he insisted I mustn’t ever contact him, which meant I had to wait for him to text or email me asking if my flatmate was out whenever he wanted to come to my flat for a couple of hours.

We’d been having an affair for about a year when he got a job that would take him out of London for weeks at a time. Even though we’d been seeing each other far less often during the last couple of months, we’d at least had some contact during working hours. Now, though, that was going to come to an end, and I couldn’t imagine how our relationship could continue. If only I’d realised then that the best possible thing to do would be to draw a line under the mistake I’d made and end things with Anthony. By not doing so, I not only colluded with him in the lies he was telling his family, I also missed the opportunity to dispel the dark, destructive cloud that was about to cast its shadow over almost every aspect of my life.

And then I met Joe.

Chapter 3

Meeting Joe was like being offered the new beginning I didn’t think I would ever have – or deserved. Suddenly, all the hurt and disappointment of the past didn’t matter any more. Every day I spent with Joe seemed to be better than the day before. I had fallen head over heels in love with him, and what was even more extraordinary was that he seemed to feel the same way about me. We had only been seeing each other for about a week when he told me he loved me. ‘I want to spend every minute of every day with you,’ he said. And I wanted that too.

It all happened so quickly and was so intense that it must have looked crazy from the outside. I know some of my friends were a bit anxious on my behalf, particularly the ones who’d seen how hard I’d fallen when Jack left me. ‘Do you think it might be a good idea to step back a bit?’ one of them asked me, tentatively. But it didn’t seem crazy at all from where I was standing. It felt completely right, and I was genuinely happy for the first time in years.

I’d told my mum about Joe during a phone call not long after we started going out. She didn’t know about Anthony, of course, but she’d been worried about me ever since my bout of depression at university, and her concern had only been exacerbated by how upset I was after the split with Jack. So I thought she’d be really happy for me when I told her I’d found someone special. And she was – until she asked how old Joe was. ‘That’s a huge age gap,’ she said, when I told her he was forty-four. ‘It’s only fourteen years,’ I countered. ‘And I’m thirty, not eighteen. I know what I want, Mum. And Joe does too.’ But there seemed to be nothing I could say to ease her anxiety. So I didn’t tell her when I moved in to live with him.

Ironically, perhaps, in view of Mum’s reaction to the age difference between Joe and me, my dad is quite a bit older than she is, and of a generation of men who tend not to discuss personal matters and emotions. So I didn’t talk to him about Joe at all.

I think it was because Mum was so concerned that she suddenly decided to come up to London for a flying visit. She said she just wanted to see me, but I knew that what she really wanted was an excuse to meet Joe and see for herself if her suspicions were correct and he really was the archetypal senior executive taking advantage of a younger colleague. Joe and I only met her briefly, for a coffee before she caught the train home again. But it was long enough for them to have a chat, and for Mum to decide that she liked him. Although she still had reservations about his age, she told me later, she no longer had any about his character.

To me, the difference in our ages was totally irrelevant and everything about our relationship seemed perfect. We were like the proverbial two peas in a pod, constantly surprised and delighted as we discovered still more things we agreed upon, views we shared, places we wanted to visit, books we loved or wanted to read … The list of our similarities seemed endless.

We drove to work together in the mornings, went out together in the evenings, slept together at night, and never once had an awkward moment or ran out of things to say to each other. I thought it was romantic when Joe told me, ‘I don’t ever want us to spend a single night apart.’ Although I didn’t think he meant it literally, it made me feel loved in a way I couldn’t remember ever having felt before. And when he asked me to marry him, I didn’t have to think about it for even a split second before I said yes, because spending the rest of my life with him seemed to be what I’d always been destined to do.

All the major decisions that would normally be made quite a long way down the line in any normal relationship had been made within two or three weeks of our first date at the bar. One of those decisions was that I would abandon my search for a flat, Joe would sell his house, and we would buy somewhere together. I always like to pay my own way, but although I was earning a good salary and had saved up almost £50,000 as a deposit on the flat I’d been intending to buy, Joe earned significantly more than I did and would be contributing considerably more to our joint house purchase and living costs. But, somehow, he made it seem as though we would be equal partners in everything we did.

I had a longstanding arrangement to go home to Devon for the weekend a couple of weeks after Mum’s flying visit to London, and although I’d planned to go on my own, Joe said he was going to come with me. I wouldn’t normally have taken a boyfriend home to meet my family in such a formal way so early in a new relationship, but I thought it was nice that Joe wanted to come. ‘Why go all that way on the train when I can drive us there?’ he said, when I told him I was quite happy to go on my own. ‘I don’t mind coming at all. And if we make a short detour on the way back on Sunday, we can have lunch with my mum. It’ll be a family weekend.’

Even though I’d fallen for Joe and was happier with him than I’d ever been in my life before, I didn’t really want to do the whole parent thing so soon. But somehow I ended up feeling as though it was what I’d wanted to do all along, and hadn’t liked to suggest it because I thought it would be a pain for him.

We arrived at my parents’ house late on the Friday evening, and the following morning Joe went out for a walk with my dad. Even when emotions aren’t being discussed, Dad is a man of few words, and he and Joe had very little in common. But Joe is very good at talking to people about the things they’re interested in, and when they came back from their walk together I could tell Dad liked him. In fact, everyone liked him. Joe’s good at reading people and responding to them appropriately, so as well as talking to my dad about the things that interested him, he joked with my mum, and was friendly but respectful to my sisters and their boyfriends when they came for dinner on the Saturday evening. I always enjoyed spending time with my family, but that was a particularly good weekend and I was proud of the man I’d fallen in love with.

Joe and I left Devon on the Sunday morning and headed back towards London, stopping on the way to have lunch with his mother in a village near Bristol. That went well too, although Joe was very nervous about it beforehand. His relationship with his mother seemed ambivalent, and although the picture he painted of her was of a difficult woman, it was clear that she was also a very important figure in his life. So I was nervous too, especially after he told me she hadn’t really liked his wife. But she was lovely, and when she apparently gave me her seal of approval during a phone call Joe made to her the next day, he was as happy as I had ever seen him.

A few days after our weekend in Devon, Joe suggested that we should go to Barcelona for a few days. I hadn’t had a holiday for at least eighteen months – the last one would have been while I was going out with Jack – and Barcelona was high on both our lists of places we wanted to visit. So I was really looking forward to it, and I wasn’t disappointed – by the city or by Joe.

When the time came, we walked around Barcelona until our feet ached, visited parks with extraordinary sculptures and art galleries that would have taken weeks to explore properly, sat in cafés, bars and restaurants talking about what we’d seen, hired a car and spent the day at the incredible Dalí Museum at Figueres, a couple of hours’ drive north of the city, talked some more, walked some more, and had the most amazing sex I’d ever had.

Every time I looked at Joe, he was smiling, and I know I was too. Then one evening, when we were having dinner in a bar, he leaned across the table, kissed me and said, ‘It’s so easy being on holiday with you. I’ve had the most incredible time. I feel as though I’ve known you for years, not weeks. I adore you, Alice Keale.’

‘I feel exactly the same,’ I said. ‘As though I’d known you all my life. In fact, I can’t really remember what I felt about anything before I knew you.’ And then we laughed about it later, when I pointed out to Joe that we’d become one of those nauseating, touchy-feely couples I used to roll my eyes at before I knew what it felt like to be in love and not to care what anyone else thinks.

Work seemed like something that existed in a parallel universe and I didn’t want the holiday to end. I wanted to keep travelling with Joe, to visit all the places we’d always wanted to visit and do all the things we’d always wanted to do, safe inside our bubble of happiness. But although the holiday did have to end, we were still happy when we got home, because just being with Joe was an amazing experience.

In contrast to my dad’s reticence when it came to talking about feelings and emotions, Joe was an open book. He told me about his relationship with his wife and how, towards the end of their marriage, the neighbours had phoned the police on several occasions when she lost her temper and started hurling furniture around their house. He mentioned another serious relationship too, which had lasted almost two years, until his girlfriend became pregnant and said she would only have the baby if he stayed with her, which he realised he no longer wanted to do. ‘We were sitting in the car,’ he told me, ‘arguing, as we often did by that time, when she suddenly hit the window with her fist with such force that the glass shattered. In fact, it cut her hand so badly she had to go to A&E.’

He talked a bit about his family too, about how devastated his mother had been when his father left her for a younger woman, when Joe himself was just a little boy, and how he’d both pitied and despised her, because she was always crying and because, for reasons he didn’t understand, he blamed her for the fact that he felt like the poor kid at his posh boarding school. He talked about his father’s subsequent wives and girlfriends too, and about his half-sister, who was born when he was in his twenties and who he liked but rarely saw.

But although Joe was open about the subjects he chose to talk about, whenever I asked him any specific questions about his relationships he would say, ‘This is about you, not me. I want to know everything about you, Alice Keale.’ So I told him about my life too, which was uneventful by comparison. What I didn’t tell him about was Anthony, I think because I wanted to be the person I saw reflected in Joe’s eyes, and admitting that I’d had an affair with a married man with children – just like the woman who ‘stole’ his father – would have been like painting a jagged, ugly black line across a perfect picture.

We were in the living room in Joe’s house one evening, sitting on the sofa, him at one end, me at the other, with my feet resting on his lap, when he said, ‘I don’t want us to have any secrets from each other. I want us to tell each other everything, to know that we can trust each other completely.’

‘I do too,’ I said, leaning forward as I spoke and putting my hand on his arm.

‘So is there anything you haven’t told me?’ he asked. ‘Any deep, dark secret you’ve been hiding from me that you want to make a clean breast of now?’ He laughed as he said it, and I tried to laugh too, although all I managed was a weak smile.

Although Joe had already asked me to move in with him, I hadn’t yet done so, and I was terrified that if he found out I wasn’t as perfect as he seemed to believe I was, it would scare him off. But I knew he was right and that we needed to know we could trust each other implicitly, which meant I was going to have to tell him the one thing I didn’t want him to know.

‘There is one thing I haven’t told you,’ I said at last, ignoring the urgent voice in my head that was shouting, ‘Don’t do this.’ Joe stopped massaging my feet, and when I dared to look up at him I saw that the smile had frozen on his face and there were anxious lines around his eyes. But it was too late to change my mind: if I didn’t tell him now, he would only try to guess what the ‘one thing’ might be, and then, as the doubt grew inside him, it would eventually obliterate the love he felt for me.

‘There is something you should know about me, Joe,’ I persisted. ‘I … I don’t like talking about it. No one knows except my family and closest friends. I didn’t tell Jack until we’d be going out for more than a year. But I want to be honest and open with you, the way I know you’ve been with me. So here goes.’ I took a deep breath and pressed my hands against my stomach. ‘I suffer from depression. I have done since I was eighteen. I take antidepressants every day – which, as you can see, work pretty well.’ I made a small sound like a rueful laugh. ‘It’s stupid, I know,’ I said quickly, suddenly wanting to keep talking so that I didn’t have to hear whatever it was Joe was going to say. ‘It isn’t something anyone should feel ashamed of or be afraid to talk about. But I do worry about what people will think of me if they know, and about it scaring them away. About it scaring you away.’

I couldn’t look at Joe while I was speaking. I didn’t want to witness wary withdrawal replace the love that, until then, I’d seen in his eyes whenever he looked at me. So I thought the worst when he gently removed my feet from his lap. Then he edged along the sofa towards me, took my hands in his and said, ‘I know, Alice. Or, at least, I guessed that it was something like that. But you’re wrong to think it might scare me away. It doesn’t bother me at all. In fact, it just makes me love you more.’

I didn’t want to remove my hands from Joe’s, so I let the tears drip slowly down my cheeks as I whispered, ‘How did you know?’

‘I saw you taking your meds one night,’ he said. ‘I just guessed.’ His arms were around me now, pressing my body against his chest so that I could breathe in the warm smell of him I loved so much. ‘But thank you, Alice. Thank you for telling me and for trusting me. I know it was difficult for you. I hope you realise now that I mean it when I say that you can talk to me about anything.’

I felt like a child whose waning faith in fairies or Father Christmas had just been restored, but who could still barely believe the good news was true. I knew Joe really meant it, though: I could tell him anything and he would still look after me and protect me, because he loved me. But even then I ignored the voice in my head that asked, derisively, ‘And what about Anthony?’

Although I didn’t want people to know about the depression, I didn’t ever try to pretend to myself that it wasn’t real. I was just wary of telling people about it because I didn’t know what they’d think, or if they’d treat me differently when they knew. Having it didn’t make me feel guilty or ashamed, though, which is the way I’d always felt about my relationship with Anthony, even before I met Joe.

Sitting with Joe’s arms around me made me feel safe and loved. So should I tell him about Anthony, and that he was still in touch with me? The knowledge of my depression hadn’t fazed him at all. Would he respond in the same way to the news that I’d had an affair with a married man who I still hadn’t told, categorically, that I was in love with someone else and it was over? Or would that be testing his love for me by pushing my luck one huge step too far?

In the end, I decided not to tell Joe my shameful secret. Instead, I would tell Anthony, once and for all, that I didn’t want to see him or have any contact with him any more.

After I started seeing Joe, I had stopped contacting Anthony, who must have realised after a few days that something was going on and sent me an email asking, ‘Are you pulling away?’ I should have been honest with him then and said ‘Yes’. How difficult would it have been to answer his email with just that one word, and to draw a line under the most shameful thing I had ever done in my life? Instead, I denied it.

I don’t know if not breaking things off with Anthony was purely cowardice on my part, because I thought ours was the only extramarital affair he’d ever had and couldn’t bring myself to hurt him when I believed he’d risked everything by falling in love with me. It sounds stupid when I actually say it like that, and I don’t think I ever did think it through clearly in those terms. I just didn’t want to compound one mistake with another by hurting him. Perhaps, even more selfishly, I was also afraid of not having a safety net if things didn’t work out with Joe – although I certainly didn’t think that consciously at the time.

The fact is, though, that whatever reason I thought I had for not telling Anthony it was all over between us, there was no excuse for telling him I missed him. And now my cowardice and duplicity were coming back to haunt me. What was worse, though, was that one day, after I’d told Joe about my depression, I agreed to meet Anthony for lunch. I didn’t want to go. I felt anxious and slightly panicky just thinking about it. But I didn’t know what else to do when he asked me. And then there we were, sitting facing each other across a table in a café, Anthony crying and refusing to look at me, while I sat staring at my uneaten food and wondering why on earth I had come.

‘I’m sorry,’ I told him again, ‘but I love Joe. What do you expect me to do, Anthony? We haven’t seen each other for weeks. You’re married. You’ve got a family, people to go home to every day. And now I’ve got someone who cares about me too. Can’t you be happy for me?’

‘Just don’t say anything else.’ Anthony’s face was contorted by distress. ‘I can’t believe that you went away with this man. I don’t think I can cope with this. I don’t want to hear any more.’ His distress had turned to anger as he spoke and he almost spat the last words at me. But I was angry too. It wasn’t fair of him to make me feel so guilty, after all the lonely hours I’d spent during the last few months, waiting and wondering if he was going to call me, not being able to text him in case his daughter looked at his phone again and told his wife that he’d been seeing someone else. He had always said that our relationship couldn’t go anywhere, that he would never leave his wife and children. He’d been honest about that at least. And I’d accepted it, because having part of someone seemed better than having no one at all.

As we sat there, silently blaming each other for our pain, I suddenly knew that I didn’t love Anthony and hadn’t ever really loved him, whatever I might have told myself. So why had I sent him emails telling him that I did? Why, even after I started seeing Joe, had I typed the words, ‘Yes, I do love you, Anthony. No one could ever equal you.’

I was telling the truth now, though. Finally, I was facing the reality of what I’d done. I didn’t know why I’d done it. But I did know that nothing could ever remove the stain my amoral actions had imprinted so irrevocably on the story of my life. I already hated the fact that I’d been someone’s mistress and a cheat, and now I felt terrible because my happiness was hurting Anthony. What I had done had been an aberration: the real Alice Keale wasn’t an amoral person; she was the person who loved Joe, openly and honestly. But Anthony knew me well enough to know that I was weak too, and that by manipulating my emotions he would make it difficult for me to cut the tenuous bond that existed between us and walk away.

Suddenly, I felt suffocated, and when Anthony stood up, having barely touched his food, I stood up too, and followed him out of the café. I’d always liked the fact that he was much taller than me, but when he stopped on the pavement outside and I looked up into his face I wondered what else I’d ever really liked about him, and why I’d allowed myself to become involved with a man who didn’t even come close to Joe, and wouldn’t have done so even if he hadn’t had a wife and family. It was hard to believe I’d been so unhappy, and so desperate for someone to want me, that I’d compromised my own integrity, risked breaking up another woman’s marriage, and convinced myself I loved him.

‘I’m sorry,’ I said again. ‘I’ve got to get back to work.’ Then I turned and walked away.

As soon as I was back in the office, I wrote an email to Anthony, unequivocal this time, telling him it really was over, that I didn’t love him and that I was tired of feeling guilty. ‘I’m happy with Joe,’ I wrote. ‘It took finding someone I really love to make me realise that our affair always was a mistake. I’m tired of lying and hiding our relationship. I want my life to be simple and uncomplicated again.’

As I typed, I felt a sense of relief flood over me. Then, just as I was about to press ‘Send’, an email appeared in my Inbox and I made the huge mistake of opening it first. By the time I’d read just the first two sentences, relief had been replaced by guilt again, because I believed that I was to blame for the pain Anthony was suffering. The sense I’d had since walking away from Anthony outside the café, of being strong and empowered by Joe’s love, simply evaporated and I knew I was too weak to cut him out of my life completely. Not because I wanted to have any contact with him, but because I felt that, having disrupted his life the way I believed I had done, it was my duty not to be the cause of distress.

So instead of sending my sensible, honest email, I agreed to meet Anthony for a drink after work a few days later, to celebrate his birthday. Then I tried to forget about him, which wasn’t difficult when I was with Joe.

One of the many things I liked so much about Joe was the fact that he was never afraid to show his feelings. I had a friend at university who went out with a guy who became almost hysterical if she tried to hold his hand in public. She left him eventually – partly because she couldn’t understand his reluctance to make what she saw as a statement to other people that they were a couple – and I can remember how bemused she was when he was upset, and how someone explained to her that some people just find it difficult to express their feelings. Well, Joe was the complete opposite of my friend’s erstwhile boyfriend, and he would often stop in the street to kiss me or tell me he loved me.

Another thing I liked about Joe was being driven by him. It’s such a simple thing, but it made me feel safe and relaxed to know that I didn’t have to do anything at all except sit beside him while he got us from wherever we were to wherever we were going. He liked to play music, loudly, in his car, and we were driving back from a restaurant one evening, singing along to his favourite song, when he suddenly stopped in the middle of the road.

‘What’s wrong?’ I asked him, sliding my feet back into the shoes I’d kicked off as soon as I’d sunk into my seat. ‘What is it, Joe? Are you okay?’

‘I’m fine,’ he told me, smiling as he always did. ‘In fact, I’m more than fine. I just wanted to tell you that I love you.’ Then he undid his seat belt, opened the car door and started to get out.

‘What are you doing?’ I asked him, laughing despite my bemusement. ‘Where are you going, Joe? What if a car comes up behind us?’

‘It’s a residential street and almost midnight,’ he said. ‘No one will come up behind us. And if they do, they’ll understand when I explain that I had to stop because I was so full of love for my perfect girlfriend that I wanted to run with her to the top of that hill and tell the world how wonderful she is.’ As he spoke, he pointed to a grassy slope in the park where we often sat and read newspapers at the weekends. Then he ran around the car, opened my door with a flourish, got down on one knee on the cold tarmac and said, in mock solemnity, ‘I adore you, Alice Keale. I want to spend the rest of my life with you.’

We were both laughing as he took my hand and we ran together to the top of the hill, where he wrapped me in his coat, put his arms around me, whispered, ‘I love you so much, Alice,’ and kissed me.

It was just one of Joe’s many spontaneous and romantic gestures. There were several occasions while we were on holiday in Barcelona when we found ourselves in some particularly beautiful spot and he got down on one knee and declared his undying love for me. He did it in London too, suddenly shouting ‘I love you, Alice Keale’ while we were buying food in the supermarket – which amused the other shoppers and made me blush. He left notes for me on the door of the fridge, had flowers delivered to my desk while I was at work, and ran out of the house in the middle of the night to buy chocolates at the 24-hour off-licence because I’d said, jokingly, that I wanted some.

It probably all sounds ridiculously sentimental to anyone else, the sort of over-the-top behaviour that isn’t normally indulged in by anyone beyond their teens. But I can’t describe the effect it had on me at the time. No one had ever shown me love like that before. No one had ever made me feel so special or so wanted. And as well as being in love with Joe, I think I was in love with that feeling too. I suppose that’s why I didn’t stop to wonder if it might all be too good to be true.

Chapter 4

I was thirty years old, I had a well-paid job that I loved, I’d saved up enough money to put down a deposit on a flat in London and, for the first time in my life, I had someone who was both willing and able to share with me whatever the future would bring. Why would anyone in their right mind risk throwing all that away and hurting the man they loved? In my case, the answer seems to have been because I was too afraid to say ‘It’s over’ to a man whose daughter probably hadn’t found a text on his phone and threatened to tell her mother – his wife – about me, who turned out to have had a string of girlfriends before me, and who went on to have many more when I had gone.

I don’t know why I did any of it: why I got involved with Anthony in the first place, why I didn’t break things off with him as soon as I met Joe, or why I lied to the man I truly believed was the one person who could, and would, make me happy and give me the future I’d begun to think I would never have.

When I’d agreed to have a drink with Anthony on his birthday, I think I had some misguided idea that if I told Joe most of the truth – that it was a friend’s birthday (true) and that several of us (not true) were meeting at the bar I was actually going to – it wouldn’t be as bad as lying about all of it. It was a stupid idea and a banal delusion to think that lying to Joe about anything to avoid upsetting Anthony would end any other way than in tears.

Quite late one Friday evening, a few days before Anthony’s birthday, he sent me a text. Joe was already in bed, and I was in the bathroom when the phone I’d left on the bedside table must have pinged. Although Anthony’s name would have come up on the screen, Joe didn’t say anything about it until we were getting ready to go out for coffee the next morning, when he suddenly said, ‘I’m probably just being silly, but who’s Anthony?’

That’s the trouble with telling a lie: you think, ‘It’ll just be this one’ – but it never is. Because after you’ve told one lie, there comes a time when you have to decide whether to come clean and admit it, or whether to tell another to hide the first one. It’s hard to choose the first option, especially when it involves having to admit to someone whose opinion you value that you haven’t been honest with them. But if you choose the second, you become like an inept spider, spinning a web around yourself that will eventually tangle and trap you in its silken threads. What’s even worse about the second option, however, is that the more lies you tell, the more you end up despising yourself, and then you start to doubt whether the person you love could ever really love someone like you.

I didn’t know that then, of course. So I chose option two and told Joe, ‘Oh, he’s just a colleague. He’s going to be at this birthday thing next week.’ Then I laughed and added, ‘I’m not interested in him, if that’s what you were thinking. He’s a married man, with children.’

I hated myself for the glibness of my deceit. But at least I seemed to have allayed any latent suspicions Joe might have had – or so I thought, until I found out later that he’d been planning to come to the bar and witness the truth for himself.

A few days before Anthony sent me that text, Joe had asked me for the pass code for my phone. ‘I want us to be able to read each other’s emails and texts and to merge our contacts,’ he told me, which some people might not have wanted to do, but which seemed like a nice thing to me. I don’t know why I deluded myself into believing I had nothing to hide. Perhaps all my attention was focused on fulfilling my wish to become part of something. Maybe that was also the reason why I didn’t really register the fact that, although I gave Joe my pass code and contacts, he didn’t actually give me his.

It was a Tuesday morning a couple of days before Anthony’s birthday and I was making coffee in the kitchen before work when I thought I heard Joe calling me. ‘Do you want me?’ I called back. ‘Joe? I’m in the kitchen.’ When he didn’t answer, I flicked the switch on the espresso machine and then snatched the pan of spitting milk off the hob, turning my head away as the sickly smell filled my nostrils and inhaling the far more pleasant aroma of strong coffee.

At that moment, a drop of rain hit the skylight above my head and I looked up at the grey clouds that had been gathering slowly all morning. It was the time of year I liked least: late autumn, I suppose you’d call it, although it already felt like winter. I hated the short winter days, when the sun sometimes seemed barely to have climbed above the horizon before it started sinking again, sucking all the light and energy out of the afternoon until all I wanted to do was go home and close the door.

I knew I wasn’t the only one who found the winter a bit depressing, or whose footsteps lightened and quickened when the spring came again. But on that particular day the rain and darkness of the morning didn’t bother me at all. It was five weeks since Joe and I had sat together in a bar for the first time and, for once, I was looking forward to the impending winter, when we would start putting in motion the plans we had made, to sell Joe’s house and look for one to buy together, before we got married in the spring.

I took a spoon out of the drawer and scooped up the skin that had formed on the milk in the pan, then tried to rinse it off under the tap, which never worked, but was something I did every time before dropping the spoon into the sink. I’d just put a cup on the espresso machine when I thought I heard Joe call my name again. ‘Did you say something?’ I called back, then took a step towards the kitchen door and listened. But the house was silent.

‘Damn,’ I said aloud, realising that I hadn’t positioned the cup correctly on the machine and some of the coffee had dripped down the outer surface of the white china and formed a small, dark pool on the worktop.

‘You lied to me!’ I was so startled by Joe’s voice that I yelped as I spun round and saw him standing in the open doorway of the kitchen. He was holding something in his hand, but it was the look on his face that made me gasp again. His lips formed a thin line – of pain or distress, I couldn’t tell which – and there was anger in his eyes where I had only ever seen love and warmth.

My first thought was that he was in physical pain, and I took a step towards him as I asked, ‘What is it? What’s happened?’ Then I froze when he turned his head away from me as if in disgust.

‘I said, you lied to me.’ Joe repeated the words slowly. ‘About Anthony. So tell me, Alice, who is Anthony really, this married man who’s just a colleague?’

And there it was – the lie, filling the space between us like something smashed and toxic.

My heart was racing and all I could think was, ‘What have I done? How could I have been so stupid?’ Suddenly, I knew with absolute certainty that only a fool, or someone with nothing to lose, would have chosen option two. I should have told Joe about Anthony when I had the chance. I should have explained to him how ashamed I was of getting involved with a married man, but that, until the first magical evening we had spent together five weeks ago, I had truly believed I might never get over the break-up with Jack, that no one would ever want me again, and that crushing depression would eventually take over my life and destroy any chance I might have had of finding love and happiness.

If I had done that – and if I’d had the courage to tell Anthony it was over – instead of compounding one lie with another, Joe might have understood and forgiven me. At least there would have been a chance, however slim, that he’d have valued my honesty in telling him more than he’d have despised me for having a deceitful affair with a married man. But now I risked losing him. And if I lost Joe, I’d lose everything that mattered to me. Worse still was the knowledge that I had hurt the one man I truly loved.

Why hadn’t I thought about all that before, when there was still a chance to tell the truth voluntarily? Nothing good could come out of it now, and as the terrible permutations ran through my head, I found myself struggling to breathe. There was still one certainty, though: I couldn’t lose Joe. And as my mind began to clear, I realised that, having chosen option two, I was stuck with it, and I was going to have to lie to Joe again.

‘Joe …’ I reached out my hand and took another step towards him, but he turned and ran out of the kitchen and down the stairs. As I ran after him, stumbling and only just managing to grab the banister in time to save myself from falling, I saw him snatch up my iPhone from the hall table.

‘Give it to me,’ I pleaded with him. ‘Please, Joe, don’t …’ Grasping his hand, I tried to prise his fingers apart so that he would release the phone. But he was much stronger than me and so upset that he barely seemed to be aware that I was touching him. And while we stood there in the hallway of his house, facing what, for me, might be the worst disaster of my life, I was thinking about all the emails I’d sent Anthony, all the stupid, cowardly lies I’d told him during the last six weeks.

I didn’t know what Joe had already seen, but I knew with desperate, gut-clenching certainty that he mustn’t read those emails. It didn’t matter that what I said in them wasn’t true. By lying to Anthony, I had betrayed Joe too. Like Judas. The two words were still echoing in my head when Joe suddenly pushed past me and ran back up the stairs and into the bathroom, slamming and bolting the door before I’d even turned and followed him.

‘Open the door, please, Joe.’ I pressed my forehead against it as I spoke. ‘Let me explain. Please, Joe. Just give me my phone and I can explain it all to you. It isn’t what it seems.’ I was crying now, but Joe didn’t answer. ‘If you don’t open the door, I’ll take all my pills and kill myself,’ I sobbed. I don’t know what made me say it. I don’t think I’d have done it. So perhaps, on some subconscious level, I just wanted proof that he still cared enough about me to want to stop me. And he did open the door. But when I reached out my hand and tried to grab his arm, he almost flung me against the wall as he ran past me into the kitchen, snatched an orange from the fruit bowl and threw it at me, while I stood in the doorway, shaking with anguish and despair.

‘I should never have trusted you,’ he shouted at me. ‘I haven’t ever told anyone some of the things I’ve told you. The first time in my life I trust someone and open up to them, and look what happens.’ His self-deprecating laugh was almost worse than his anger, which returned almost immediately as he pointed to the open door of the living room and shouted, ‘Right there on the sofa. We were sitting right there when we talked about trust for the first time. No secrets, that’s what we agreed. I asked you, Alice: is there anything else you want to tell me? And you said no. I was so happy. And now you’ve ruined everything. I don’t understand. Explain it to me, Alice. How could you do this to me?’

Then, suddenly, his anger seemed to burst like a bubble, leaving him limp and depleted. Sinking into a chair, he put his head in his hands and began to cry. I was sobbing too, but I stayed where I was in the doorway, not daring to move towards him or try to touch him, because I knew that it was my lies and deceit that had broken him.

When Joe eventually raised his head again, the expression on his face was like that of a vulnerable little boy who’s been overwhelmed by emotions he doesn’t understand and can’t control. I did take a step towards him then. I wanted to wrap my arms around him, to do something to smooth away the hurt and make him happy again. But I found that I couldn’t touch him, because I knew I had caused the pain he was suffering. I had taken the trust of a good man and snapped it with my bare hands. And for what? Perhaps it would have been understandable – although no less despicable – if I had loved Anthony, then or ever. But when faced with a choice between hurting a man I didn’t love and breaking the trust of a man I adored, I’d chosen – for some inexplicable, incomprehensible reason – to do the one thing that would hurt both of us more than we had ever been hurt in our lives before.

I knew then that I couldn’t stop Joe from reading the emails I’d sent Anthony. And when he had read them he would know the truth – not that I loved Anthony, which I didn’t, but that I was a deceitful liar; and then he would leave me.

‘How did I become this person?’ I asked myself. I wasn’t brought up to tell lies. It was so out of character, so unlike the real me. Making the drunken decision to get involved with Anthony that first night in the hotel had been like crossing a line between honesty and deceit. Once I’d crossed it, lying seemed to have become easier – almost imperative, I’d allowed myself to believe. Now Joe hated me because I’d broken his heart; but not as much as I hated myself.

I hadn’t seen Anthony since that miserable lunchtime we’d spent together, when I told him I loved Joe and broke things off with him, before later relenting and agreeing to meet him on his birthday. And although I’d deleted all the texts we’d exchanged, there were still emails for Joe to read, full of the false words I’d written to Anthony. So I begged him again to give me my phone and let me delete them, but he refused.

Joe’s reaction to what I now think of as ‘the discovery’ was dramatic. He was very angry, distraught and heart-broken. But although he shouted and screamed at me, he wasn’t violent. He didn’t tell me to leave and then throw my clothes out on to the street after me, as he might have done. He didn’t even say he needed some time alone so he could think. In fact, he didn’t seem to want me to go. And as I was desperate to cling on to any part of what we’d had, in the hope of somehow being able to make amends, I called in sick at work that morning and stayed.

For the rest of that day, Joe trawled through my emails and bombarded me with questions. I knew Joe despised me for being dishonest; I didn’t want him to hate me even more for being sexually amoral too. So I continued to deny that the relationship I’d had with Anthony had ever been sexual. Then Joe found the emails that proved otherwise and I realised, too late, that I’d made everything even worse than it might otherwise have been, because now he knew he couldn’t believe anything I said about anything.

The questioning continued without a break throughout the entire day. Bizarrely, perhaps, we went to a local bistro for lunch, although we barely touched our food, in Joe’s case because the only time he stopped asking me questions was when he was dry retching.

We hardly slept that night either. Joe wanted to know everything about my affair with Anthony, where and when we had slept, what I’d been wearing on each occasion, what I’d said to him and what he’d said to me, every tiny detail about the hotel room … Answering his endless stream of questions was exhausting and humiliating. But if that’s what it was going to take to make Joe understand why I’d lied, it was worth it.

I still wonder sometimes what I would have done that day – the day of the discovery – if I’d known what lay ahead.

I didn’t leave Joe’s flat that day because I was afraid that, if I did, everything would be over between us forever, and because Joe didn’t ask me to go. Instead, the barrage of questions continued, with Joe asking them in a voice that was sometimes angry, sometimes cold, and me answering them as best I could, first with more lies, then by telling him as much as I dared of the truth. I knew that, because of what he’d discovered, Joe had changed his opinion of me completely, and it felt as though everything that had been perfect was irrevocably spoiled and horrible.

‘How could you get involved with a married man?’ he kept asking me, and every time he said it I thought about what his dad had done when Joe was a little boy and how badly it had affected him at the time and – I realise now – ever since. ‘What you did is abhorrent,’ Joe said. And there really wasn’t anything I could do but agree.

Ücretsiz ön izlemeyi tamamladınız.

Türler ve etiketler

Yaş sınırı:
0+
Litres'teki yayın tarihi:
29 haziran 2019
Hacim:
262 s. 5 illüstrasyon
ISBN:
9780008205263
Telif hakkı:
HarperCollins